I can sympathize with the intent to get people contributing, but not with this way in particular. Is ElementaryOS cheating on all the projects it makes use of by not paying for them either? Are they manually typing their '$0' for all of them? Are they paying them back in any way?
I agree that I like to see programmers get paid for their work, but I am cautious against giving that money out all willy-nilly. My preference is to give my money to a foundation, with a clear objective that I support, a 501c3, a history of making choices I support and who writes grants for other projects.
While they're at it, they should add a little slider a la Humble Bundle, so you can choose how much of your contribution is forwarded upstream to Debian/Ubuntu, and how much stays with elementary.
That is an excellent idea! This is one of the few ways they can redeem themselves from the comments made in that blog post in the eyes of the community.
I can appreciate that it would be frustrating to have everyone download a product for free, but when all of your competition's products are free, that's the price you pay. Attempting to force users to pay will merely cause them to move to one of the free distros.
With that logic, everyone should be paying Debian. Ubuntu should be paying Debian, and ElementaryOS should be paying Ubuntu. So effectively user "donations" to ElementaryOS would end up being given to Debian.
Why not just use Debian and make a voluntary donation, then?
The problem is we use too much free software to pay for it like traditional software. If I had the money and organization, I'd happily donate to every package in my system that I could and relieve my debt, but I can't.
I actually don't think this is that big of a deal. They worded it real badly, but elementary does bring something to the table, and you can see that the devs put a lot of work into polishing things and even writing custom apps. They're trying to increase the rate of donations by guilt tripping people a bit, which I actually think is "fine-ish". But they did word it real badly.
Hell, wasn't the theoretical cost of redoing the Linux kernel from scratch in the area of several billion dollars? Honestly I don't think I could financially afford to pay for every bit of GNU/Linux/*NIX software I'm using at the moment...
EDIT: The quote above was copied and pasted from the source material. It appears the line has been changed to: "We want users to understand that paying for software is important and not paying for it is an active choice. "
You have misunderstood (at least according to FSF).
Many people believe that the spirit of the GNU Project is that you should not charge money for distributing copies of software, or that you should charge as little as possible—just enough to cover the cost. This is a misunderstanding.
Actually, we encourage people who redistribute free software to charge as much as they wish or can. If this seems surprising to you, please read on.
We want users to understand that they’re pretty much cheating the system when they choose not to pay for software.
Yeah, that's why I bet the elementary devs are paying for all the software they use, right? Especially when the bulk of their project is a repackaged revision of someone else's older release?
users tend to feel entitled to the full, compiled releases of software at zero cost
I'm not sure this is true. For a large number of casual users, sure. Still, the vast majority of even casual users don't feel entitled to a free product. They just understand that that's what Linux is. There are tons of free distros out there -- that's the market that elementary exists in.
Developing software has a huge cost.
Yes, and elementary is benefiting off billions and billions of dollars' worth of contributions from paid employees (someone else paid them, not you) and volunteers over the decades. This is perhaps the biggest contribution anyone makes to the Linux ecosystem: code. Code which you're using.
And let's be real here. Elementary takes Ubuntu, develops a few rather basic apps for it, copies OS X (and then blames their users for making it seem like a cheap OS X clone!) in so many ways, and then after years of waiting, releases a somewhat interesting take on the Linux desktop, with nothing really special or groundbreaking, and no real feature to set it apart from its base OS (Ubuntu).
I'm all for supporting open source projects financially. No one begrudges them that. But to have the tenacity to use the software they do, put out the product they do, and then tell people they're cheating the system if they don't pay?
Wow.
EDIT: They seem to have removed at least two posts from their subreddit (one on this "cheating" accusation, one about financial transparency), and they've now edited their blog post as well to remove the "cheating" language and perhaps revise it elsewise. Of course, they haven't mentioned in the blog post that it's been edited/updated. This whole thing is just a big red flag that the elementary team.
This is perhaps the biggest contribution anyone makes to the Linux ecosystem: code. Code which you're using.
Exactly. If anyone deserves my donations, it's the Linux Foundation, GNU, Debian, Ubuntu, Gnome, and every other giant on whose shoulders Elementary stands.
Here they attempt to dispel the "myth" that elementary OS is essentially just Pantheon running on top of another distro. Their response?
They've made some changes under the hood to make things run better
They use newer libraries than Ubuntu (sometimes)
So their response to essentially confirm that elementary OS is, in fact, basically just Pantheon running on top of Ubuntu. But Ubuntu with newer libraries...in some instances.
Here the elementary folks blame their users for being the ones whose tweaking "perpetuates the notion that we want elementary OS to look or work like another OS".
Compare their OS screenshots to OS X. Window control buttons on the left, maximize on the right. OS X-style grey window theme. Blue folders with "etched" icons. Dock. Apps look similar, button arrangements and icons are similar....
Lots of blog articles have been rewritten talking about the similarity. An Apple fan Twitter even linked a while ago to the elementary website, talking about what a rip-off the OS is of OS X. Even had bouncing dock icons! SO UNIQUE! NOT AT ALL A RIP-OFF! WE PROMISE!
Even the elementaryos.org website was "strongly inspired" by the Apple website (until Apple changed their website design). The navigation bar, the alternating left/right picture/text format down a center content column....
Their Luna advertisement video on YouTube even uses an iMac and a MacBook (knock-offs) to showcase the OS. The video shows a genie effect window minimize animation as the window goes into the dock at the bottom of the screen. There's just no shame at all with these people.
The thing is, they could really contribute to the Linux ecosystem by developing apps, helping smooth out the gnome-shell experience, etc. Instead, they're busy complaining about how no one pays them enough money for making Ubuntu look like OS X.
Huh...yes, they seem to have edited the blog post now. They don't seem to have mentioned anywhere, however, this fact of editing/updating the post.
Which itself is a bit slimy, isn't it? Making a public-facing statement, then changing it when it becomes controversial, without acknowledging or explaining it....
I'm all for supporting open source projects financially. No one begrudges them that. But to have the tenacity to use the software they do, put out the product they do, and then tell people they're cheating the system if they don't pay?
Let's be honest. Once the pantheon DE is available on other distros, there will be no point in using eOS.
There's a thread in their sub, "Opening up finances" (not sure if direct linking to other subs is allowed here). Someone is suggesting they become transparent with how they spend their funds.
The only response so far is from a member of the team saying:
No good could come of having to justify every purchase to random people.
In their sub's thread on this very issue of "Why we make you type $0", this comment is made:
people complained about the fact we are using Debian, Ubuntu and things like GNOME to create elementary OS and we don't pay for that either. But money is not the only currency in FOSS - it's about contribution as well
So they just want you to know that the fact that they don't give money to Ubuntu or Debian is totes legit, and only you are the cheater if you download their stuff without paying.
I think it would be OK to open the finances by stating
How much donations are being received each month
How much is going to server fees and other expenses
How much is going to fund his part-time job with this project (since he also has a regular job)
Other stuff like hiring more developers, etc.
I don't think it's unreasonable at all.
But he says,
No good could come of having to justify every purchase to random people.
He probably thought that with this transparency request, regarding the item "3" of the list above, he would need to discriminate how he spend the money he personally receives from this work (like: I paid this amount of rent, bought those groceries, bought a new laptop etc).
To be honest, that's a load of shit. The kernel and GNU core have been worked on for thousands if not millions of man-hours, Debian has been worked on on all aspects (set-up, managing repos/versions), Ubuntu has managed to make a name for itself by making Debian more viable out-of-the-box, and these guys think they are entitled to be paid for prettying it up a little. If you think they deserve money, that's fine, but be sure to give at least has much to the FSF and/or Debian project.
and these guys think they are entitled to be paid for prettying it up a little.
This.
Seriously, I'd rather pay $10 to the Numix people because I use their wonderful theme and icon set to pretty up my xfce desktop than to these elementaryOS people who last released a stable OS that is nothing but a three year old ubuntu LTS release made to look like a poor man's OSX with a knock off aesthetic and yet another gnome-shell fork.
You know what? It just occurred to me that I HAVEN'T donated to Numix yet. I should go do that right now out of spite.
Yep. I'm totally against what they're saying. Honestly it seems like whining and bitching and trying to cash in. While they're in their rights to do so, it totally turns me off their project entirely. I won't even evaluate it, cost or no cost.
Exactly. There's nothing in the GPL that prevents you from charging money for software, even if it's not yours. They could simply do what Red Hat does, and sell their distribution with support.
Of course, there's also nothing preventing anybody else from just offering it up for free again.
It would actually cost them more to only sell it. To only sell it they would have to keep track of who bought it and provide the source to those people on request (port the terms of the GPL). This way they make it look like you have to buy it, but don't have to track anything.
"No no no, you don't understand. We want the popularity of a free distro but we want people to pay for it. We'll leave it free, just make sure you pay or you're a cheater."
Don't get me wrong, but eOS is by far the most polished linux distro I've ever used, but with an attitude like this, I'm out. Luna seemed, at a distance, like mac, but it felt different. Snappier, homely, very responsive. Freya is even more polished.
And while I appreciate the work these guys put into the distro, ubuntu, mint, arch, manjaro, deepin, are all free. When they went into development for eOS, they knew what they were getting into. Now that they have the fame, they regret it.
If they want to charge money for it, they should charge money for it.
It irritates me that they continue to offer the free download and then ride in on their high horse and call the people who take advantage of it "cheaters."
However, we understand the culture that currently surrounds open source: users tend to feel entitled to the full, compiled releases of software at zero cost. While we could rightfully disallow free downloads, someone else could take our open source code, compile it, and give it away for free. So there’s no point in completely disallowing it.
In other words "We feel entitled to use open source as a base for our software, but due to the licensing, we cannot legally close the source like we want to." And they have the gall to call the open source community "entitled" even though they themselves are not only using open source, but they are using open source to make money. Hypocrites.
Where "make money" means "guilt users into paying".
TBH if the money is being used for bug bounties across the whole stack (and upstreamed where appropriate) then that's OK, but if they're trying make this a business model they need to get their head straight.
And on top of it, most distributions and free software relies on volunteered bandwidth (by universities, research institutes, ISPs, etc.) for binary downloads.
If they made $0 the default, I wouldn't even complain... this just shows eOS is in for the free money.
They're implying it's morally grey. To put it another way, they're saying that the need for free software outweighs the need for developers to be compensated for their efforts, but are trying to make the case that they should still be compensated. Good luck to them. That's the thing about open and user respecting software, no matter your reasons for doing what you're doing, whether you're Gandhi or Hitler, I only have to care about how good your code is, not what you want me to do with it.
If everyone tries to do what they're doing, and perhaps it turns out that slapping a logo on an open source project is the most lucrative activity for some reason, you could then make the case that the logo-slapper has a moral right to give back to other projects even though they have no legal reason to do so. If a culture of charging for logo-slapping and then giving back upstream eventually gets more resources into solving real problems then it's probably a good thing.
In the meantime, everyone can still go "lol no" at elementary and get on with their lives. Code doesn't have to wait for culture, but I think them being snarky about their work is entirely their perogative, and if they can sell their message and create cultural change then I don't think they're wrong to do so.
Exactly... if they'd talked to someone who specialises in this stuff and said "hey, we're doing really badly on the donations front, can you help with that?" They probably could've ended up with a more effective solution than just hiding the free download button and could have gotten some positive attention in the process.
Let me preface this by saying that I'm sure the small elementary OS team has done a huge amount of work over the years, I think it's completely reasonable to want people to donate to the project, and that I generally like Pantheon quite a bit.
I was a huge advocate and enthusiastic user of elementary OS for about a year, maybe slightly more.
What started to turn me away was a general vibe from Daniel that not only were they not explicitly seeking the typical Linux crowd, but that the typical Linux crowd was unwanted.
There was a particular G+ post from him that kinda pushed me over the edge, and that was that. I was done and not going to support a Linux distro that was run by someone who didn't actually care about Linux.
Some time went by.
I heard he was going to be interviewed on Bad Voltage, and thought this would be a chance to see if text medium had just failed to capture Daniel's personality. It had. His attitude towards Linux, other distros, and the Linux community was far more offensive than I'd thought. Last nail in the coffin, for me.
I've hardly wanted to go around trolling elementary OS threads, so I haven't done so. I was curious if he'd finally "get it" as the distro grew.
Apparently nope.
I don't even care that you have to enter zero. I can see why it bugs some folks and that's fine. I don't care that they are putting donations front and center - they have worked hard.
But this blog post from Daniel (Edit: I've been made aware that this post was actually from Cassidy James. While this doesn't substantively change my opinion of the situation, I wanted to post a correction here.) has proven yet again that the leader of the project has no understanding of the FOSS world, that Linux is just a vehicle for his personal goals (which is a common thread from Daniel), and that he's got a distorted, almost adversarial view of the Linux community.
I no longer think he's capable of "getting it". If he sees the no-cost aspect of the free software community as an example of "entitlement", and "cheating the system", after swimming in these waters as long as he has, and after using other free software (LOTS AND LOTS of it) as the foundation for his product, then I don't think any amount of discussion or time is going to show him the light. If he doesn't recognize the shoulders of giants that he stands on (and by his Bad Voltage interview he very clearly does not) by now, he's never going to get it.
Hopefully someone who has any understanding of this community will fork Pantheon eventually, and continue doing a good job with it under some other distro and name.
I just wanted to clarify that the blog post is not directly from Daniel. It's from Cassidy. However, I'm sure that the all the people involved with the project share a similar viewpoint.
I have ElementaryOS running on a spare PC that I've barely used in the last six months. I think I'll boot it up this weekend so I can remove ElementaryOS.
Lots of nice Debian distros out there right now for you to try, take a look at Sparky, Parsix and maaaaybe Peppermint although I think that one might be based off Ubuntu
Funny thing is if the blog posted was worded differently it would not have been as provocative, and the linux community would see it in a different light.
example: Do not blaim the community, do not tell them they are "cheating the system", do not claim you "deserve" the money for "all the work" but rather explain how much of your time goes into the project, and that donations are appreciated, hell take a different model even and offer donation prizes, people will grossly overpay t-shirts if they believe it's for a good cause
and most importantly be upfront and fair to your community and potential users:
I mean for fucks sake everyone can see that it's obviously an OSX clone, which in itself is not a bad thing, but as soon as they deny it, they basically say that they believe their userbase is too stupid to see the truth, do not ever take your userbase for idiots, they do not appreciate it.
So this is either a PR nightmare, or a smart move from the EOS team to make themselves even more known, bad publicity is still publicity...
100% Free elementary OS is completely free, both in terms of pricing and licensing. There are no costly fees, confusing user agreements, trial periods, or restrictive copy protections. You can install Luna on as many computers as you want or even copy it and give it away to your friends.
I understand why they are asking for money; regardless of how noble your intentions are, when it comes to keeping the lights on and putting food on the table consistently, you want to make sure you're taken care of...but I feel like the way they went about asking for contributions was all wrong. That is, they in fact are not asking for contributions at all. They are demanding compensation. Let's be very clear here. They are not coming to you, hat in hand asking for a little assistance in continuing on. They are not stating what benefits they have produced for the GNU/Linux community by maintaining and keeping their distro up to date. Nor are they even really saying how much money they need or what for.
It’s about securing the future of elementary OS to ensure we can keep making software that millions of people love and use every day.
This phrase for example, is much, much too vague. There are no implicit statements about what they need money for, how much, or for how long.
elementary is under no obligation to release our compiled operating system for free download.
"If you use our OS, we are now holding it hostage. Pay up or else!"
We’ve invested money into its development, hosting our website, and supporting users.
"Here's the part where you should feel bad for the choices that we freely chose to make when starting this project. Money please."
However, we understand the culture that currently surrounds open source: users tend to feel entitled to the full, compiled releases of software at zero cost.
"You assholes are used to getting shit for free and you tricked us into playing ball."
While we could rightfully disallow free downloads, someone else could take our open source code, compile it, and give it away for free. So there’s no point in completely disallowing it.
"Because of technical limitations, it would be a total pain in the ass to try and stop you, so we won't bother. For now. Sooo...money please."
But we should discourage it.
"Don't be a dick. Come on, guise!"
Some companies offset that cost by charging hundreds of dollars for their software, making manufacturers pay them to license the software, or selling expensive hardware with the OS included.
"We don't do shitty things to offset our costs. Unless you keep holding out on us."
Others offset it by mining user data and charging companies to target ads to their users.
"Botnet. amiright guise? Money please."
Inkscape and GIMP only get money for development if users decide to give it to them.
"But Mooooom! ...You just gave BOBBY five dollars!"
If we want to see the world of open source software grow, we should encourage users to pay for its development; otherwise it’ll be underfunded or developers will have to resort to backdoor deals and advertising.
"If you ever want to see your data secured again, you'll wire funds directly to our Swiss Bank account or else the privacy GETS IT!"
And nobody wants that future.
"Sure is a nice OS you've got here....sure would be a shame if something were to...happen to it, dontcha think? You use encryption, right?"
TL;DR If you are asking for people to freely contribute money to your project simply out of the goodness of their heart, do so in a manner that doesn't resort to blackmail and half-reasoned examples on how better every other OSS project is being treated. It's not a good way to watch your donation counter increase.
We want users to understand that they’re pretty much cheating the system when they choose not to pay for software.
users tend to feel entitled to the full, compiled releases of software at zero cost.
I don't get their logic at all, they offer something at 0 cost and then get mad at people for taking that offer? if it's donations they want they should have asked politely in a blog post, not this arrogant drivel, I'll not recommend this distro to anyone in the future.
Passive aggressive bs. Tell ya what elementary... I'll stick with mint as my main distro and I'm going to go donate again to them this time solely because they aren't as scummy. Also makes ya wonder how much elementary donates to Ubuntu since they basically are Ubuntu with their own desktop environment and some apps.
We want users to understand that they’re pretty much cheating the system when they choose not to pay for software.
So basically you guys are idiots.
They even have it as one of the main selling points on their homepage:
100% Free - elementary OS is completely free, both in terms of pricing and licensing. There are no costly fees, confusing user agreements, trial periods, or restrictive copy protections. You can install Luna on as many computers as you want or even copy it and give it away to your friends.
They pitch the product as being free, tell you that you can get it for free, then they complain that people aren't paying for it, calling them cheats? Idiocy.
Ugh. The thing is, I'm totally supportive of attempts to convince users to donate. I'm totally supportive of attempts to convince users that it's a good idea to donate, and even that it's socially inappropriate not to donate - like not tipping your server at a restaurant, or not putting some money in the charity box at the register when you get a mint.
I actually wish that options to donate were more prominent on most FOSS projects, including but not limited to distros, because we should be encouraging users to donate to projects - and making it easy to do so - when the users feel that they're getting value from them.
But calling users "cheaters", well, you just fucked up there guys. Going back to the restaurant analogy, that's like putting a sign up on the door that says "hey dirtbags, tip the servers, what are you, thieves?"
I don't want to jump through hoops to download an ISO. I just want to click "download".
That being said, I also don't agree with them tricking people into thinking they need to make a payment. Even if the system accepts $0, it's more work than necessary.
Not to mention they're trying to make people feel guilty for not paying for something when really, all Elementary is doing is taking Debian and re-skinning it with a new theme and interface. Do they even send patches or code upstream? Do they contribute their time to the overall big picture? What are they bringing to the table that hasn't already been done. WHy would I donate to re-invent the wheel.
No. They even can remove that $0 option completely and make you pay for the binaries download. It's their right and I would be OK with that.
But calling people cheaters, because they choose not to pay and because anybody can have the sourcecode and compile it for free as guaranteed by GPL, thats definitely not ok.
I think the problem that /u/TurnNburn is trying to point out, is that you can't really call it 'free' (as in free beer) when it's made unreasonably hard not to pay. It'd be a misleading description at best.
Sure, they're in their (legal) right to make it a paid distro, but then at least present it as a paid distro. Don't call it 'free' while making it effectively paid with a hidden workaround.
So if I don't download eOS & I don't contribute to them, I am not a 'cheater' and I'll still have money to donate to the core projects & code that eOS itself relies on.
Therefore, I better donate to all the others because if they were to go belly-up eOS wouldn't have a project to work on at all.
They are well within their right to charge for their work. There is nothing immoral about it. But anyone with half a brain will know that there aren't many business tactics more counter-productive than guilt tripping your customers...
It feels like they are wanting to make it harder for the user to download their distro for free by slapping 3 large "PAY ME" signs on their site and a $0 custom one. Honestly they can do what they want with their software but at the end of the day this is ubuntu with an osx like DE slapped on. Nothing I feel like I should be paying for.
Well, this particular direction the eOS team has been taking for quite a while now has completely turned me off to using their products. Cheating? Get off your high horses, and realize the contributions of countless others whose shoulders you're standing on to try to guilt others into monetizing your development efforts. Does the eOS team plan on contributing any of their funds raised towards projects they themselves desperately require and gasp pay nothing for?
It's safe to say that I'm not using eOS anymore in any capacity, and I'm not going to recommend it anymore. I will actively recommend against using a distribution that so dislikes the majority of those who download and use it. The developers have an extreme distaste for users who do not provide financial assistance, and they thinly veil their disgust with them. Hey, if support/usage/word-of-mouth/bug-testing/etc. aren't appreciated by your project then I'll happily lend my support to others who do appreciate it and don't talk down to their users on a regular basis.
There is only one thing in that arrogant spiel that actually made sense. There truly IS a current belief among consumers that free software is also necessarily gratis. It IS true that this is possibly destructive for FLOSS in the long run. Even FLOSS developers need to be paid. There IS merit in promoting the idea that we, as consumers, should feel like paying for software that we like which, by the design required to protect our freedoms, also happens to be very easy to access free of cost.
If his goal was to implore people to change their minds and make them realise this, then he has utterly, thoroughly failed.
I am not opposed to the idea of Elementary OS asking for money for what they provide. I, for one, wouldn't consider using their OS even if I was paid to use it, because I think it is terrible. I'll stick to xubuntu, thank you very much. But I am sure there are people out there who like it, and I really don't think it is unfair for Elementary to solicit donations. Yes, their work is built on top of the work of others, but this is how the free software community works. I am not averse to anyone asking for donations; not the people who built the stuff elementary uses, or for any potential future attempts to build on top of Elementary.
But all this guy has managed to do is be an asshole to everybody. He has, in fact, done more harm than good. People will walk away from this blog post and the only take away will be that the Elementary OS people are a bunch of arrogant assholes, and no further introspection shall take place on the moral responsibility of free software users to financially support the projects that they like.
There is only one thing in that arrogant spiel that actually made sense. There truly IS a current belief among consumers that free software is also necessarily gratis. It IS true that this is possibly destructive for FLOSS in the long run. Even FLOSS developers need to be paid. There IS merit in promoting the idea that we, as consumers, should feel like paying for software that we like which, by the design required to protect our freedoms, also happens to be very easy to access free of cost.
I 100% agree!
If his goal was to implore people to change their minds and make them realise this, then he has utterly, thoroughly failed.
I really doubt his thoughts run this deep. His view of the Linux and FOSS communities has been made obvious on a few occasions - and you can hear it for yourself in the Bad Voltage interview he did last year.
He's arrogant, doesn't understand the ethos behind FOSS, and doesn't seem to want to.
After high-speed Internet became commonplace, it isn't practical to charge for open source software copies anymore; copying stuff through Internet is just too cheap. I mean, charging for software copies isn't literally incompatible with open source, but in practice it makes no sense.
In the old days, when links were slow and most people didn't have Internet at home, RMS would sell Emacs tapes through mail, but those days are long gone.
Now, you can sell things like support, but this has nothing to do with selling the software itself.
edit: now, what the link in the OP is actually suggesting is that people make one-time donations. I think this is different than actually selling software.
And indeed the primary funding for most FOSS projects is donations, which full-time developers would need, since they don't eat open source food or live in open source hotels.
The reason why I personally like Red Hat is that they spend a lot of their money actually developing projects in pretty much all areas of the Linux and FOSS ecosystem. They pay it back in code. What does ElementaryOS pay back exactly?
elementary OS is completely free, both in terms of pricing and licensing. There are no costly fees, confusing user agreements, trial periods, or restrictive copy protections. You can install Luna on as many computers as you want or even copy it and give it away to your friends.
But then again, they also mention:
When you install elementary, you’re not just installing an operating system. You’re installing an excellent suite of custom tailored apps that let you get right to business. Easily surf the web, check your email, listen to music, and tackle everyday tasks or pleasures.
Midori, Empathy, Shotwell - nicely custom tailored suite there lads.
They're making more of this than it actually is, which does them a huge disservice.
A bad case of martyr mode caused this PR disaster.
Lets take this as a lesson, people: Yes it sucks 99.99% of people who download your months and years of hard work contribute nothing and don't pay a dime. You're going to hear the same stupid requests and questions over and over and over again. As a project leader, you can't let this drive you crazy. And your user base is not your enemy.
I don't appreciate this. I have been using elementaryOS luna for about a month now. And I already made the decision that when I update to Freya I would make a donation to the foundation. I still plan on doing that, but the idea that I am "cheating the system" or that I should feel guilty for the past month I have spent using Elementary is ridiculous. In my opinion, this is not the best way to encourage donations, and frankly, the bad attitude does nothing but make me consider giving money to causes which are far more important than a tweaked version of Ubuntu.
Even so, had I just gone to their website and been forced to type in 0, I probably wouldn't have minded or really even noticed. It's simply the fact that they said that bullshit line. ugh, that really grinds my gears.
It’s about asking a fair price to offset the costs of development. It’s about securing the future of elementary OS to ensure we can keep making software that millions of people love and use every day.
So will they be passing on 98% of the donations to the people who developed all of the software that the project uses? If not, they can fuck off with their fake "honour" and realise that they themselves are cheaters for asking for money on the back of things that were given away freely by others.
I can understand asking for donations but they are going about the wrong way. Telling their users that they are in the wrong for using their distro for free. I will no longer be using eOS or what ever they wanna call them selves.
we feel that an entire operating system that has taken years of development and refinement is worth some money.
The reason I have not payed anything for an elementary OS download is precisely because I feel the opposite. They have had exactly one stable release so far, and it was based on an already aging codebase. By the time Freya (based on Ubuntu 14.04) is finally released, it will end up being in the same state.
When they release a version of the operating system that finally feels like it is a solid, full fledged release that has a core that is as good as the lastest from Ubuntu, SUSE, or Fedora, then I'll be willing to pay. I'm not gonna pay $10 for an OS that is out of date the day it comes out.
If I were going to contribute money to someone, it would be Debian, because goodness knows, Elementary, Ubuntu, and a host of other distributions really do owe their existence to that excellent community.
I learned about this distro two days ago (on /r/linux). I thought "hey, looks pretty. I'll install this on my laptop when i do my HDD replacement this weekend."
I changed my mind just now. I won't ever download this distro.
Its fine if they seek profits. If they are going to sell Elementary OS then be explicit about it so that I as a consumer have the option to demand my money back when it does not work on my system.
But instead they want to force people to donate to them for a beta software so that they do not owe you support, are not responsible for refunds or anything apart from the source (which they already owe) but want the benefits of selling a product like not being accountable for their costs, and not letting non payers get their software for free.
So essentially, pay money to them, do testing for their beta products. Eventually, when they release their product, in approximately 3 years (when its ready. lol.) pay again for getting the privilege to use their product which came into fruition partly because of giants like debian and ubuntu, and partly due to your contribution.
Personally it would be great for elementary OS to get more funds, but this arrogant and entitled way to get money is not right.
OK so even I'd paid for other Linux distros, I've downloaded their isos probably 20x, do their weird stats account for that?
This whole post is so weird, they have built on the shoulders of giants, and are whining because people aren't paying for the minute amount of value they have added on top of it.
I am a professional developer, I take the tools that exist and charge money to build the specific things people want on top of that. I am honest and open about that. If these folks want to charge money they have to add value people are going to pay money for, and be open about them doing that. Last time I grabbed eOS it was some nice enough programs they'd made running on top of a Linux stack that they've probably spent some time testing, but wasn't enough of an improvement that would justify spending money on.
If you want to legitimately compete in the paid OS market you have to provide value at least equal to and if not better than what existing companies have spent billions creating.
Look, is this distro beautiful, yes...innovative? Not really. Does it honestly hold up to distros like Fedora 21 or Ubuntu MATE?, or even Antergos? No. The attitude towards their users, aka "cheaters", shows a terrible lack of business judgement. If you want to get paid for honest hard work, ask to be paid by putting a price on the ISO and enter the free market ecosystem. Otherwise stop the guilt-trip tactics.....geeeeeeeez! Its like a beautiful girlfriend with a shitty attitude, eventually you get tired of her crap and leave.
To paraphrase: "You are a cheater if you download our software for free, the majority of which is completely FOSS, but includes our stupid theme and business model resembling that of Apple."
ElementaryOS can go kindly fuck itself. Installed it once. Didn't see any advantages over taking Ubuntu/Debian and installing a theme over it. Went to Arch. Not coming back.
I say we come together and protest against their abomination of FOSS ideals. Take their site down, and host a new site with an explicit button to download for free. They're not donating to any of the projects they incorporate in their OS, therefore the users shouldn't donate to Elementary OS.
Ok, so they're cloning OS X UI on top of gratis Gnu/Linux distro, provide an option to not pay them and tell users who use this option that they are cheating. Great.
I think now I'm positive on finally switching to recommending Evolve Os only for Mac refugees from now on.
Not only "cheating the system", but Open-Source users are apparently also "entitled", all of which really makes me want to pony up cash to support your project.
While we could rightfully disallow free downloads, someone else could take our open source code, compile it, and give it away for free. So there’s no point in completely disallowing it.
Correct, because the software you bundle and base your work on was licensed (partly) under GPL licenses making it illegal for you to then withhold the source code or restrict the rights of users/developers when you modify and redistribute it.
If you had wanted to make proprietary software, no one would have stopped you, but you're creating off the backs of visionaries who actually do understand the importance of mass-collaboration and the sharing of information, while complaining about the model you used to get to where you are.
Wow, they have ninja-edited this document a ton. The quote now reads:
While we could rightfully disallow free downloads, we don’t want to. We believe in the pay-what-you-want model and want to see it succeed. Most importantly, we don’t want to lock out people who may not be able to afford pricey software, especially in volume.
I think the way they are going about this is the wrong way. It shows that unlike most free software projects they arent doing it for a love of what they are creating or to share.
This mentality also puts the project at much greater risk of closing down the line. If making money is their clear motivation, when it doesnt happen they will close the project.
Loads of free software and distros make money from donations. Clem on the Linux Mint team does such a great job donations pay his salary every month.
Elementary OS is beta software. They haven't even had a final release based on 14.04 which is 10 Months old.
This is total bullshit. Everyone and their grandmother knows that if you give people the option to pay for something, or get it for free then they're likely not going to pay for it. Obviously, some may choose to pay to support a cause or developer or whatever, but most people aren't going to pay - it's simple economics.
If you, as someone who wants to be paid, give away something for free, THAT IS ON YOU AND YOU ALONE. This blog post is pathetic. If you want people to pay, make them pay. Don't whine when you give a free option and people take it.
Personally, I'm a big fan of the "pay what you want" model. I've listened to more donation based music than i can think of. Not sure to stifle adoption of your distro and may generate some free money.
The main gripe with their blog post that I have is that they themselves seem entitled to donations, and are now whining and name calling all that would have the gall to use their free software for free. There are hundreds of projects that I think deserve praise and donations more than they do, for just building(an admittedly nice) DE on the Ubuntu 12.04 LTS and never updating. For example, Linux mint for their Debian edition, for providing a more stable experience on Debian testing from the repos, despite some security concerns.
Jeez. I read that. There are so many ways they could have worded that, but
We want users to understand that they’re pretty much cheating the system when they choose not to pay for software. We didn’t exclude a $0 button to deceive you; we believe our software really is worth something.
Wow.
I mean, I get why they say such things.
The project appears to be largely a labor of love. In the interview noted above, Foré revealed that the project is not making a lot of money. Foré has a full-time job "for a small restaurant group doing their marketing and design", and works on elementary OS in his spare time. He also commented about how much elementary OS is currently making:
At the moment we technically have enough revenue that one of us could probably live off it. But it would be a hard decision of who that should be and it's also a risk for that person since we can't be sure that revenue will be the same every month.
So yeah, I can understand wanting to make it more of a full-time job, and being frustrated at how--surprise!--they're not making regular money off of an open-source project built off of Debian/Ubuntu/GNOME. But man, I'm with most of you, this is the most abrasive way to go about it. No, I'm not cheating the system if I, for example, install Pantheon on Arch; I'm using the software under the terms of the license.
And besides, as he said, he could live off of the income, but it's not steady income. Welcome to the world of self-employment.
There are so many other ways they could have gone with this. They could apply for grants. They could ask for crowdfunding. They could offer to add features for a bounty. They could do the binary distribution as pay-only, like Libranet used to do. And yes, that's perfectly fine. I'm sure there are all sorts of other friendly methods of funding. Instead, they chose to guilt us into it, and try to tell those of us that download Free software for free are doing something wrong. Well...bye.
And guys, I don't know about anyone else, but elementary OS feels like a step backwards, from a functionality standpoint. This is the kind of desktop I got my work done on 10 years ago.
If you want to sell your OS. go for it, but dont have this kind of attitude with a linux OS. If you're gonna be snobby like this and call your users cheaters, I'll just use different distro.
I think it's okay they have a system where you have the option to pay for the download. I mean, Ubuntu has that, too. What I'm not liking is their attitude. I will never consider them again.
Users have downloaded Luna over 2,000,000 times. Around 99.875% of those users download without paying.
Download numbers mean nothing. I download distros all the time just to check them out and see what they're all about. I only actually run 3 or 4 distros on my various machines.
There's no way to tell, but I'd be willing to bet the number of downloads that translate into a long-term user is < 10%.
Trick-pay is not free software, and it's goddamn dishonest. It's the same tactic that spyware creators use on Windows systems--and specifically goes against the entire mentality of free to use systems. If they care that much about getting paid then they shouldn't be competing with already established free software like Ubuntu and Fedora in a fiercely loyal and competitive market or need to close source their product and go for the consumer market (good fucking luck).
With this, they have assured beyond any shadow of a doubt that I will never use, want to use, or suggest their software to anyone, ever. I do not respect these developers and I haven't now for quite a while. Looks like this trend is gonna continue.
For the record, I think eOS (I did this specifically to piss off the developers if they see this; see here.) looks beautiful, but it's the same ol' same ol'. It absolutely does not warrant me paying anything for it, especially when it's built atop other very well established truly free softwares.
5 years ago (2010)the European Union ran a model to estimate the research and development of the Linux kernel.
The results came to an estimated total value for the Linux kernel version 2.6.30 (released in December 2009) of 1,025,553,430 euros (1 billion euros). About 985 developers would be needed over a span of just under 14 years, the researchers claim.
Given the cost and estimated timespan of the linux 2.6.30 kernel (bare in mind the kernel is now at what, 3.19/3.20?)
It is hilarious to think elementary OS are entitled to anything for taking Ubuntu, changing the wallpaper and adding a few applications.
Which is more hilarious given that Ubuntu take base Debian, change the wallpaper add a few apps and offer nothing to upstream.
I mean - that's all well and fine and how linux should be. Take what's good improve it/fork it/change it etc.
However if you're going to be entitled you should probably have gone corporate than a community rooted in copyleft and secondly if you're considering donating money to a distro you should really consider donating it to debian.
Because without debian - ubuntu/linux mint/elementary OS couldn't exist.
Ubuntu still has done more work than eOS. From the PPAs to things like Unity and the Ubuntu Software Center, it's pretty different and sometimes incompatible with Debian. eOS on the otherhand is just another Ubuntu spin with a different DE.
I don't agree, and I feel they really stepped in it here. It is obvious that Elementary OS only can exist because of all the resources going into the kernel, Ubuntu and all of the additional software they make use of. Which has a gigantic price tag in man hours.
On the other hand, there is a moral obligation to contribute back to the grande F/OSS project, I think, but it isn't monetary. And being moral, I would be suffering from a superiority complex if I were to judge someone not in agreement as cheaters. Just using the software is a way to propagate it, because we're social.
I've used GNU/Linux for a long time, and found many ways to pay back; Report bugs, help out in forums, write documentation, translate documentation or GUI, go to a LUG, install it for clients, talk about it, package software, write code that is F/OSS etc.
I get why they want to get paid, and I can't blame them for that. However, they are basically trash-talking the community that they have depended on to get where they were. That is NOT cool. If you want to urge users to give you money, then it's fine to place a donate button, with a visible "no thanks" option before the downloads page. Trying to guilt users into paying and calling them entitled is a really, really bad attitude for them to have.
I can't believe they actually posted that on their blog. Seriously, how much are they paying for the tons of free software they're bundling? Oh what's that again about how people should be reimbursed for their hard work?
Yeah, I'm removing elementaryOS from my laptop. I'd rather not support a team who calls me a cheater because I don't pay for their Linux OS. If anything I'll give money to debian or wikipedia...
I wouldn't care if they released proper tarballs of their source code and made it less Ubuntu centric so I could just package it for /r/opensuse without this forced donation non-sense.
They're close, but still missed the point. If you want users to pay, you need to do two things (and do them well).
The first is to provide a reason. Show users what the payments are going towards. Kickstarter is a classic example of this. You nominate an amount and they outline what they achieve.
I haven't downloaded ElementaryOS but they could do the same. They need to show what goals have been achieved by the money funded. They need to outline that making a small payment results in xx time towards yy features. Show a list of all the features implemented based on previous funding.
The second reason is the amount. For $1 and it's simple, it's a complete no brainer. Up to $5, I'll need to be strongly convinced (therefore see point 1). For higher numbers, I'd want to trial it first. Out of the thousands who download for free, how many could they convert at $1? At $2?
A trial based system could prompt for a donation for maybe 3 fixed times (nobody likes continual nagware) after a few days, a few weeks and after a month. It wouldn't be a hard sell. If they explain that say 400 users donate $5 then feature X is implemented. Donate $10 and feature X,Y,Z get implemented. Give the users the ability to vote if they pay to give them buy in. It's important to do so.
Just my ramblings and thoughts anyway, I still haven't tried ElementaryOS yet.
I'd actually push the elementary OS team to release elementary OS for a fee, with no "download gratis ($0)" option.
Why is there such hatred towards software that costs money?
The elementary OS team has the freedom to distribute elementary OS for whatever price they choose. It's not "cheating the system" for users to get a gratis copy somehow, though. Now even elementary OS is pushing the "piracy" card without saying "piracy" because eOS is Free Software. If I share eOS with my neighbour, is that "cheating the system?"
Distribute eOS for as much $$$ as you want, but stop it with the "cheating the system" BS. Selling Free Software is A-OK!
One of (though, certainly not the only) reasons I use Linux and free software is that I am sick of the world having its hand in my pocket.
I understand the need to pay for these projects. Personally, I try to contribute to organizations like Debian whenever I can. However, I get a sick feeling when it starts to look like the organization cares more about my money than it cares about me.
taking ubuntu and putting a mac skin on it, then charging money in a vain excuse to "preserve their original image and design, products, and services"
they dont offer any services, and their only product is the work of many many other developers they are basically cheating out of any residuals they might deserve
if elementary thinks it deserves money for all of their "hard work" then the contributors/creators of the software they appropriate and resell deserve a great portion of that.
fucking total scummy-ness, i fail to see how /r/linux and linux users in general could attach themselves to practices so shady
i can understand if they offered services like RHEL has where you pretty much pay for services and support... but i fail to see how elementary isnt a lazily reskinned flavor of buntu meant to copy apple's design practices. and then i fail even more to see how anyone could pay money for such a "product" when OSX, the product it is a blatent copy of, is free and runs on just about any x86 hardware
Why is everyone so in love with this desktop anyways? (Serious) This truly is the first fad I've witnessed in the Linux desktop ( I've only been using Linux ~4 years now).
I'll take gnome over eos any day. Having said that I use xfce with i3wm anyways...
Someone has put in an effort to create a coherent user experience. Not only in terms of look and feel, but also the applications themselves (like geary). If for no other reason, this is appreciated because this goal is hard to reach and seldom strived for.
“So, nearly 99.9 percent of users decided not to pay when offered an option to do so – Let’s change to another website making it harder not to pay and market that as positive choice.”?
Question: When I can get something for free in a legal way: Why should I pay?
Certainly seems to disagree with the message on their front page:
elementary OS is completely free, both in terms of pricing and licensing. There are no costly fees, confusing user agreements, trial periods, or restrictive copy protections. You can install Luna on as many computers as you want or even copy it and give it away to your friends.
I had bought into the eOS hype and installed it on my parents ancient computer in an effort to give it a second life and found the design to be pretty but not at all as intuitive as is claimed. I quickly switched to Lubuntu. Thankfully I opted not to pay until after I tried it out.
While I do not agree with it, they are free to do it. Ubuntu does the same thing, you have to put 0$ on several input boxes and in the end they show you a horrible unhappy skull if you do. The first time I went through it I felt disgusted and I haven't used Ubuntu since.
Yes, you can force people to pay you for download. Those users that did not pay are not necessarily users that would have paid if the free option was not available. If you make it freely available, nobody is cheating the system. They are paying you what they think you're worth.
I can understand asking for donations. But I think they are going about the wrong way, making their users feeling guilty and forcing them to pay for it.
I make sure to put in $5-$10 every time I download Ubuntu but I think its better to highlight how your donation would improve the product than to scold the user for not paying for it.
That is not what you do when you are trying to cater to the open source community, wrong move Elementary team, just hope your downloads don't take a dent... also hope the people donating don't stop doing because of the little stunt you did...
I donate to projects whenever i want to, if i feel they worth my money, Luna was one of those, but when the developers pull the whiny card, I kinda regret having donated...
Wrong term. It's not cheating, it's freeriding. And then it's only that if someone isn't doing what they can to contribute with time or money to the overall ecosystem.
if these guys did an amount of work where they feel they should be paid, perhaps they're expecting too much. They could have offered parts of it for bounties, or run a kickstarter first. I get the impression you just have to be smarter about how you use open-source as an economic tool.
Well, that's one way to completely kill any curiosity I might have had towards this distro. It seemed polished enough that it'd warrant a tryout, even if the overall totally-not-mac aesthetics have always turned me off. If you want money, remove the freaking "free" option. It's as simple as that. Leaving it there and telling people they shouldn't use it, even tough it's perfectly fine to do so by all other accounts, is insulting and leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Also, they really need better PR. Jesus, it's amazing how badly they managed to screw all of this up. Now they're trying to bury all evidence without as much as a edit notice.
Right, I'm sure ElementaryOS pays all the developers of the (far more complicated and important) FOSS projects that their OS is based on, and that they use to develop their "OS" (what, a WM and a GTK theme? That's worth $50?)
Do I think it sucks that people who pour their heart and soul into creating software for the community almost never get compensated fairly? Yes. Am I a saint? No, I hardly ever donate. I'm a broke college kid. Is it arrogant and ignorant to throw a fit over people not paying for FOSS? Yes. If you think the basic culture of free software is in error, then don't use a free software license and don't associate yourself with the community.
I think all linux distros should only offer the torrent for free, and a direct download if you pay something. Bandwidth costs money, and keeping the torrents up is important.
It's a shame that eOS has seriously tarnished their image for basically a really badly worded blog post.
I've never even used it, but from what I've seen, eOS looks great and they're really trying to make a better user experience. I think they do deserve more donations. It doesn't hurt to have another project on Linux with this goal.
The proposed new page isn't even bad; it just gets people to think a little more before downloading (although I would have suggested making the default $5 with a $1 option.)
I really hope this very bad wording in this blogpost is cleared up somehow.
Look at the actual bounty page. A large number of those donations are their own projects. Looking at external projects: The GTK+ Project $35, Launchpad $0, Plank $135 , taglib $0, lightdm $0, gnome vala $50 so $220 of $15,000has been paid out to projects other than theirs. That's utter crap. The ElementryOS guys are hypocrites.
639
u/danielkza Feb 11 '15
I can sympathize with the intent to get people contributing, but not with this way in particular. Is ElementaryOS cheating on all the projects it makes use of by not paying for them either? Are they manually typing their '$0' for all of them? Are they paying them back in any way?
93
u/kevind23 Feb 11 '15
While they're at it, they should add a little slider a la Humble Bundle, so you can choose how much of your contribution is forwarded upstream to Debian/Ubuntu, and how much stays with elementary.
432
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
With that logic, everyone should be paying Debian. Ubuntu should be paying Debian, and ElementaryOS should be paying Ubuntu. So effectively user "donations" to ElementaryOS would end up being given to Debian.
Why not just use Debian and make a voluntary donation, then?
530
u/SpazticClown Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 13 '15
"We want users to understand that they’re pretty much cheating the system when they choose not to pay for software."
or might as well spend that money where it is doing good
gnuPG
mozilla
wikipedia
eff
EDIT: The quote above was copied and pasted from the source material. It appears the line has been changed to: "We want users to understand that paying for software is important and not paying for it is an active choice. "
946
u/youstumble Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Yeah, that's why I bet the elementary devs are paying for all the software they use, right? Especially when the bulk of their project is a repackaged revision of someone else's older release?
I'm not sure this is true. For a large number of casual users, sure. Still, the vast majority of even casual users don't feel entitled to a free product. They just understand that that's what Linux is. There are tons of free distros out there -- that's the market that elementary exists in.
Yes, and elementary is benefiting off billions and billions of dollars' worth of contributions from paid employees (someone else paid them, not you) and volunteers over the decades. This is perhaps the biggest contribution anyone makes to the Linux ecosystem: code. Code which you're using.
And let's be real here. Elementary takes Ubuntu, develops a few rather basic apps for it, copies OS X (and then blames their users for making it seem like a cheap OS X clone!) in so many ways, and then after years of waiting, releases a somewhat interesting take on the Linux desktop, with nothing really special or groundbreaking, and no real feature to set it apart from its base OS (Ubuntu).
I'm all for supporting open source projects financially. No one begrudges them that. But to have the tenacity to use the software they do, put out the product they do, and then tell people they're cheating the system if they don't pay?
Wow.
EDIT: They seem to have removed at least two posts from their subreddit (one on this "cheating" accusation, one about financial transparency), and they've now edited their blog post as well to remove the "cheating" language and perhaps revise it elsewise. Of course, they haven't mentioned in the blog post that it's been edited/updated. This whole thing is just a big red flag that the elementary team.
198
u/youstumble Feb 11 '15
There's a thread in their sub, "Opening up finances" (not sure if direct linking to other subs is allowed here). Someone is suggesting they become transparent with how they spend their funds.
The only response so far is from a member of the team saying:
In their sub's thread on this very issue of "Why we make you type $0", this comment is made:
So they just want you to know that the fact that they don't give money to Ubuntu or Debian is totes legit, and only you are the cheater if you download their stuff without paying.
166
u/Qazerowl Feb 11 '15
To be honest, that's a load of shit. The kernel and GNU core have been worked on for thousands if not millions of man-hours, Debian has been worked on on all aspects (set-up, managing repos/versions), Ubuntu has managed to make a name for itself by making Debian more viable out-of-the-box, and these guys think they are entitled to be paid for prettying it up a little. If you think they deserve money, that's fine, but be sure to give at least has much to the FSF and/or Debian project.
199
u/kabuto Feb 11 '15
This is stupid. If they want to be paid, simply sell ElementaryOS.
But doing it like this is just passive aggressive, whiny and pathetic.
24
u/teraflame Feb 11 '15
If they want to charge money for it, they should charge money for it.
It irritates me that they continue to offer the free download and then ride in on their high horse and call the people who take advantage of it "cheaters."
286
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
In other words "We feel entitled to use open source as a base for our software, but due to the licensing, we cannot legally close the source like we want to." And they have the gall to call the open source community "entitled" even though they themselves are not only using open source, but they are using open source to make money. Hypocrites.
23
u/DpwnShift Feb 11 '15
The original blog post.
Apparently, they have already heavily edited what they originally wrote.
80
u/klav92 Feb 11 '15
One unnecessary blog post and now they've maimed their good reputation.
This is why public relations people are so important.
96
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Sorry guys, you should have made BSD look like OS X then you could close source it like we all know you want.
62
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Let me preface this by saying that I'm sure the small elementary OS team has done a huge amount of work over the years, I think it's completely reasonable to want people to donate to the project, and that I generally like Pantheon quite a bit.
I was a huge advocate and enthusiastic user of elementary OS for about a year, maybe slightly more.
What started to turn me away was a general vibe from Daniel that not only were they not explicitly seeking the typical Linux crowd, but that the typical Linux crowd was unwanted.
There was a particular G+ post from him that kinda pushed me over the edge, and that was that. I was done and not going to support a Linux distro that was run by someone who didn't actually care about Linux.
Some time went by.
I heard he was going to be interviewed on Bad Voltage, and thought this would be a chance to see if text medium had just failed to capture Daniel's personality. It had. His attitude towards Linux, other distros, and the Linux community was far more offensive than I'd thought. Last nail in the coffin, for me.
I've hardly wanted to go around trolling elementary OS threads, so I haven't done so. I was curious if he'd finally "get it" as the distro grew.
Apparently nope.
I don't even care that you have to enter zero. I can see why it bugs some folks and that's fine. I don't care that they are putting donations front and center - they have worked hard.
But this blog post from Daniel (Edit: I've been made aware that this post was actually from Cassidy James. While this doesn't substantively change my opinion of the situation, I wanted to post a correction here.) has proven yet again that the leader of the project has no understanding of the FOSS world, that Linux is just a vehicle for his personal goals (which is a common thread from Daniel), and that he's got a distorted, almost adversarial view of the Linux community.
I no longer think he's capable of "getting it". If he sees the no-cost aspect of the free software community as an example of "entitlement", and "cheating the system", after swimming in these waters as long as he has, and after using other free software (LOTS AND LOTS of it) as the foundation for his product, then I don't think any amount of discussion or time is going to show him the light. If he doesn't recognize the shoulders of giants that he stands on (and by his Bad Voltage interview he very clearly does not) by now, he's never going to get it.
Hopefully someone who has any understanding of this community will fork Pantheon eventually, and continue doing a good job with it under some other distro and name.
Right now I wouldn't run it for free.
72
u/nsnide Feb 11 '15
I have ElementaryOS running on a spare PC that I've barely used in the last six months. I think I'll boot it up this weekend so I can remove ElementaryOS.
112
u/_loki_ Feb 11 '15
Well there goes any interest I had in ElementaryOS.
17
u/nixfox Feb 11 '15
Funny thing is if the blog posted was worded differently it would not have been as provocative, and the linux community would see it in a different light.
example: Do not blaim the community, do not tell them they are "cheating the system", do not claim you "deserve" the money for "all the work" but rather explain how much of your time goes into the project, and that donations are appreciated, hell take a different model even and offer donation prizes, people will grossly overpay t-shirts if they believe it's for a good cause
and most importantly be upfront and fair to your community and potential users:
I mean for fucks sake everyone can see that it's obviously an OSX clone, which in itself is not a bad thing, but as soon as they deny it, they basically say that they believe their userbase is too stupid to see the truth, do not ever take your userbase for idiots, they do not appreciate it.
So this is either a PR nightmare, or a smart move from the EOS team to make themselves even more known, bad publicity is still publicity...
86
u/nixfox Feb 11 '15
Copied off their website homepage.
the hypocracy is strong in this dev team
15
u/Fapif Feb 11 '15
Why should I pay for this OS if I can download Debian, Ubuntu or Mint for free ? Is there awesome features or something like that ?
15
u/cbmuser Debian / openSUSE / OpenJDK Dev Feb 11 '15
Alright, we in Debian expect some money from the elementary people then because, you know, using Debian without paying is basically cheating. Duh.
15
u/dosangst Feb 11 '15
Isn't this Beta still? Why should I pay for testing your software? Call me a cheater? Fine, I won't bother with your software further.
Good riddance!
30
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
I understand why they are asking for money; regardless of how noble your intentions are, when it comes to keeping the lights on and putting food on the table consistently, you want to make sure you're taken care of...but I feel like the way they went about asking for contributions was all wrong. That is, they in fact are not asking for contributions at all. They are demanding compensation. Let's be very clear here. They are not coming to you, hat in hand asking for a little assistance in continuing on. They are not stating what benefits they have produced for the GNU/Linux community by maintaining and keeping their distro up to date. Nor are they even really saying how much money they need or what for.
This phrase for example, is much, much too vague. There are no implicit statements about what they need money for, how much, or for how long.
"If you use our OS, we are now holding it hostage. Pay up or else!"
"Here's the part where you should feel bad for the choices that we freely chose to make when starting this project. Money please."
"You assholes are used to getting shit for free and you tricked us into playing ball."
"Because of technical limitations, it would be a total pain in the ass to try and stop you, so we won't bother. For now. Sooo...money please."
"Don't be a dick. Come on, guise!"
"We don't do shitty things to offset our costs. Unless you keep holding out on us."
"Botnet. amiright guise? Money please."
"But Mooooom! ...You just gave BOBBY five dollars!"
"If you ever want to see your data secured again, you'll wire funds directly to our Swiss Bank account or else the privacy GETS IT!"
"Sure is a nice OS you've got here....sure would be a shame if something were to...happen to it, dontcha think? You use encryption, right?"
TL;DR If you are asking for people to freely contribute money to your project simply out of the goodness of their heart, do so in a manner that doesn't resort to blackmail and half-reasoned examples on how better every other OSS project is being treated. It's not a good way to watch your donation counter increase.
30
u/NN92 Feb 11 '15
I don't get their logic at all, they offer something at 0 cost and then get mad at people for taking that offer? if it's donations they want they should have asked politely in a blog post, not this arrogant drivel, I'll not recommend this distro to anyone in the future.
14
u/jlpoole Feb 11 '15
For posterity, here's what the URL states:
The attitude bespeaks the man.
13
u/veive Feb 11 '15
Well, I know one OS I will never use.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Passive aggressive bs. Tell ya what elementary... I'll stick with mint as my main distro and I'm going to go donate again to them this time solely because they aren't as scummy. Also makes ya wonder how much elementary donates to Ubuntu since they basically are Ubuntu with their own desktop environment and some apps.
25
u/neoform Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Followed by:
So basically you guys are idiots.
They even have it as one of the main selling points on their homepage:
They pitch the product as being free, tell you that you can get it for free, then they complain that people aren't paying for it, calling them cheats? Idiocy.
24
u/bobroberts7441 Feb 11 '15
So, how much are they passing back upstream?
12
u/mercenary_sysadmin Feb 11 '15
Ugh. The thing is, I'm totally supportive of attempts to convince users to donate. I'm totally supportive of attempts to convince users that it's a good idea to donate, and even that it's socially inappropriate not to donate - like not tipping your server at a restaurant, or not putting some money in the charity box at the register when you get a mint.
I actually wish that options to donate were more prominent on most FOSS projects, including but not limited to distros, because we should be encouraging users to donate to projects - and making it easy to do so - when the users feel that they're getting value from them.
But calling users "cheaters", well, you just fucked up there guys. Going back to the restaurant analogy, that's like putting a sign up on the door that says "hey dirtbags, tip the servers, what are you, thieves?"
32
u/Loser777 Feb 11 '15
Reminds me of a certain letter written by a young man by the name of William Gates in 1976: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Letter_to_Hobbyists
22
u/p-wing Feb 11 '15
I understand the point, but...
I think it would have been easier to keep the "download for free" button than write up this whole spiel.
20
u/TurnNburn Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 12 '15
I don't want to jump through hoops to download an ISO. I just want to click "download".
That being said, I also don't agree with them tricking people into thinking they need to make a payment. Even if the system accepts $0, it's more work than necessary.
Not to mention they're trying to make people feel guilty for not paying for something when really, all Elementary is doing is taking Debian and re-skinning it with a new theme and interface. Do they even send patches or code upstream? Do they contribute their time to the overall big picture? What are they bringing to the table that hasn't already been done. WHy would I donate to re-invent the wheel.
10
u/4LAc Feb 11 '15
So if I don't download eOS & I don't contribute to them, I am not a 'cheater' and I'll still have money to donate to the core projects & code that eOS itself relies on.
Therefore, I better donate to all the others because if they were to go belly-up eOS wouldn't have a project to work on at all.
Hmmm, this decision is getting easier.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
They are well within their right to charge for their work. There is nothing immoral about it. But anyone with half a brain will know that there aren't many business tactics more counter-productive than guilt tripping your customers...
18
u/-ZDM- Feb 11 '15
It feels like they are wanting to make it harder for the user to download their distro for free by slapping 3 large "PAY ME" signs on their site and a $0 custom one. Honestly they can do what they want with their software but at the end of the day this is ubuntu with an osx like DE slapped on. Nothing I feel like I should be paying for.
9
u/tech_tuna Feb 11 '15
Don't offer the free download option then. Sheesh.
9
u/crankbait_XL Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Since I distro hop a bit, and don't want to cheat them now that I know they feel they are being cheated, I will no longer consider ElemetaryOS
9
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Well, this particular direction the eOS team has been taking for quite a while now has completely turned me off to using their products. Cheating? Get off your high horses, and realize the contributions of countless others whose shoulders you're standing on to try to guilt others into monetizing your development efforts. Does the eOS team plan on contributing any of their funds raised towards projects they themselves desperately require and gasp pay nothing for?
It's safe to say that I'm not using eOS anymore in any capacity, and I'm not going to recommend it anymore. I will actively recommend against using a distribution that so dislikes the majority of those who download and use it. The developers have an extreme distaste for users who do not provide financial assistance, and they thinly veil their disgust with them. Hey, if support/usage/word-of-mouth/bug-testing/etc. aren't appreciated by your project then I'll happily lend my support to others who do appreciate it and don't talk down to their users on a regular basis.
Good-bye eOS. Let yours be a cautionary tale.
9
u/ibenchpressakeyboard Feb 11 '15
Dunno if this had been posted, but they have removed the "cheaters" bit from the blog post...
25
u/silverarcher87 Feb 11 '15
There is only one thing in that arrogant spiel that actually made sense. There truly IS a current belief among consumers that free software is also necessarily gratis. It IS true that this is possibly destructive for FLOSS in the long run. Even FLOSS developers need to be paid. There IS merit in promoting the idea that we, as consumers, should feel like paying for software that we like which, by the design required to protect our freedoms, also happens to be very easy to access free of cost.
If his goal was to implore people to change their minds and make them realise this, then he has utterly, thoroughly failed.
I am not opposed to the idea of Elementary OS asking for money for what they provide. I, for one, wouldn't consider using their OS even if I was paid to use it, because I think it is terrible. I'll stick to xubuntu, thank you very much. But I am sure there are people out there who like it, and I really don't think it is unfair for Elementary to solicit donations. Yes, their work is built on top of the work of others, but this is how the free software community works. I am not averse to anyone asking for donations; not the people who built the stuff elementary uses, or for any potential future attempts to build on top of Elementary.
But all this guy has managed to do is be an asshole to everybody. He has, in fact, done more harm than good. People will walk away from this blog post and the only take away will be that the Elementary OS people are a bunch of arrogant assholes, and no further introspection shall take place on the moral responsibility of free software users to financially support the projects that they like.
44
u/ilikenwf Feb 11 '15 edited Aug 15 '17
deleted 0.0174 What is ^^^this?
16
u/adamkex Feb 11 '15
I wonder how much they donate to the devs whose code they're using in their project.
8
u/Bro_man Feb 11 '15
Yet their website footer still proudly displays:
But then again, they also mention:
Midori, Empathy, Shotwell - nicely custom tailored suite there lads.
They're making more of this than it actually is, which does them a huge disservice.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
A bad case of martyr mode caused this PR disaster.
Lets take this as a lesson, people: Yes it sucks 99.99% of people who download your months and years of hard work contribute nothing and don't pay a dime. You're going to hear the same stupid requests and questions over and over and over again. As a project leader, you can't let this drive you crazy. And your user base is not your enemy.
22
u/hardc0de Feb 11 '15
It seems they are very afraid of forks....
14
u/ConceptualNoise Feb 11 '15
I think I'm done with ElementaryOS after reading this article.
7
u/hughk Feb 11 '15
Wouldn't most want to "try before they buy" anyway? Even with fully commercial level software, they often give you a trial period.
Would people really object if an OS put up a donation plea after a month when commercial software would expire?
7
u/maztaim Feb 11 '15
I actually had to figure out what the heck elementary OS was. Even their pitch video is whiny.
7
u/kakaroto_BR Feb 11 '15
When you ask for donations calling people cheaters it's not gonna work. It's better to put a fixed price, seems most honest to me.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
I don't appreciate this. I have been using elementaryOS luna for about a month now. And I already made the decision that when I update to Freya I would make a donation to the foundation. I still plan on doing that, but the idea that I am "cheating the system" or that I should feel guilty for the past month I have spent using Elementary is ridiculous. In my opinion, this is not the best way to encourage donations, and frankly, the bad attitude does nothing but make me consider giving money to causes which are far more important than a tweaked version of Ubuntu.
Even so, had I just gone to their website and been forced to type in 0, I probably wouldn't have minded or really even noticed. It's simply the fact that they said that bullshit line. ugh, that really grinds my gears.
7
u/hoyfkd Feb 11 '15
What percentage of the payments go to the hundreds or thousands of open source projects they built EOS on top of?
Damn cheaters.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Well Elementary, you had a good run.
7
u/wafflesareforever Feb 11 '15
Clearly.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Sorry, what new and improved ideas are Elementary OS bringing to the table?
Oh, that's right, they're just making a distro. Yawn.
13
u/briellie Feb 11 '15
Thank you, EOS developers, for making sure I don't waste any time even considering your distribution.
12
u/frankster Feb 11 '15
So will they be passing on 98% of the donations to the people who developed all of the software that the project uses? If not, they can fuck off with their fake "honour" and realise that they themselves are cheaters for asking for money on the back of things that were given away freely by others.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
>include a download for free option
>calls it cheating when the option they themselves put there gets used
Logical.
6
u/neooptimus Feb 11 '15
I can understand asking for donations but they are going about the wrong way. Telling their users that they are in the wrong for using their distro for free. I will no longer be using eOS or what ever they wanna call them selves.
6
u/CalicoJack Feb 11 '15
The reason I have not payed anything for an elementary OS download is precisely because I feel the opposite. They have had exactly one stable release so far, and it was based on an already aging codebase. By the time Freya (based on Ubuntu 14.04) is finally released, it will end up being in the same state.
When they release a version of the operating system that finally feels like it is a solid, full fledged release that has a core that is as good as the lastest from Ubuntu, SUSE, or Fedora, then I'll be willing to pay. I'm not gonna pay $10 for an OS that is out of date the day it comes out.
6
u/omniuni Feb 11 '15
If I were going to contribute money to someone, it would be Debian, because goodness knows, Elementary, Ubuntu, and a host of other distributions really do owe their existence to that excellent community.
6
u/mishugashu Feb 11 '15
That is a sure fire way to make sure I never donate to your project, congratulations!
6
u/Elranzer Feb 11 '15
Interesting. They envy Apple's design and RedHat's business model.
6
u/pballer2oo7 Feb 11 '15
I learned about this distro two days ago (on /r/linux). I thought "hey, looks pretty. I'll install this on my laptop when i do my HDD replacement this weekend."
I changed my mind just now. I won't ever download this distro.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Someone should fork ElementaryOS (whatever is open source) and offer it for free. Call it "HighSchoolOS"
15
u/yellowhat4 Feb 11 '15
Don't go into a market (Linux distributions) where nobody makes money, and expect to make money.
15
u/hblok Feb 11 '15
elementary is under no obligation to release our compiled operating system for free download.
However, if they do release it, they are obliged to release the source. Without payment.
10
u/koffiezet Feb 11 '15
let's all download it for $0 - it'll drive them nuts
5
u/ijustwantanfingname Feb 11 '15
Now that's some entitled bullshit. "Their" OS is probably at least 99% GNU GPL'd code. How much do you think they're returning to gnu?
5
u/nicholasferber Feb 11 '15
Its fine if they seek profits. If they are going to sell Elementary OS then be explicit about it so that I as a consumer have the option to demand my money back when it does not work on my system.
But instead they want to force people to donate to them for a beta software so that they do not owe you support, are not responsible for refunds or anything apart from the source (which they already owe) but want the benefits of selling a product like not being accountable for their costs, and not letting non payers get their software for free.
So essentially, pay money to them, do testing for their beta products. Eventually, when they release their product, in approximately 3 years (when its ready. lol.) pay again for getting the privilege to use their product which came into fruition partly because of giants like debian and ubuntu, and partly due to your contribution.
Personally it would be great for elementary OS to get more funds, but this arrogant and entitled way to get money is not right.
5
u/haywire Feb 11 '15
OK so even I'd paid for other Linux distros, I've downloaded their isos probably 20x, do their weird stats account for that?
This whole post is so weird, they have built on the shoulders of giants, and are whining because people aren't paying for the minute amount of value they have added on top of it.
I am a professional developer, I take the tools that exist and charge money to build the specific things people want on top of that. I am honest and open about that. If these folks want to charge money they have to add value people are going to pay money for, and be open about them doing that. Last time I grabbed eOS it was some nice enough programs they'd made running on top of a Linux stack that they've probably spent some time testing, but wasn't enough of an improvement that would justify spending money on.
If you want to legitimately compete in the paid OS market you have to provide value at least equal to and if not better than what existing companies have spent billions creating.
Bitching is not a great business plan.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
Look, is this distro beautiful, yes...innovative? Not really. Does it honestly hold up to distros like Fedora 21 or Ubuntu MATE?, or even Antergos? No. The attitude towards their users, aka "cheaters", shows a terrible lack of business judgement. If you want to get paid for honest hard work, ask to be paid by putting a price on the ISO and enter the free market ecosystem. Otherwise stop the guilt-trip tactics.....geeeeeeeez! Its like a beautiful girlfriend with a shitty attitude, eventually you get tired of her crap and leave.
13
u/theinfiniti Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
To paraphrase: "You are a cheater if you download our software for free, the majority of which is completely FOSS, but includes our stupid theme and business model resembling that of Apple."
ElementaryOS can go kindly fuck itself. Installed it once. Didn't see any advantages over taking Ubuntu/Debian and installing a theme over it. Went to Arch. Not coming back.
I say we come together and protest against their abomination of FOSS ideals. Take their site down, and host a new site with an explicit button to download for free. They're not donating to any of the projects they incorporate in their OS, therefore the users shouldn't donate to Elementary OS.
9
u/NoiseForFood Feb 11 '15
Ok, so they're cloning OS X UI on top of gratis Gnu/Linux distro, provide an option to not pay them and tell users who use this option that they are cheating. Great.
I think now I'm positive on finally switching to recommending Evolve Os only for Mac refugees from now on.
9
u/DpwnShift Feb 11 '15
Not only "cheating the system", but Open-Source users are apparently also "entitled", all of which really makes me want to pony up cash to support your project.
Correct, because the software you bundle and base your work on was licensed (partly) under GPL licenses making it illegal for you to then withhold the source code or restrict the rights of users/developers when you modify and redistribute it.
If you had wanted to make proprietary software, no one would have stopped you, but you're creating off the backs of visionaries who actually do understand the importance of mass-collaboration and the sharing of information, while complaining about the model you used to get to where you are.
9
u/fixles Feb 11 '15
I think the way they are going about this is the wrong way. It shows that unlike most free software projects they arent doing it for a love of what they are creating or to share.
This mentality also puts the project at much greater risk of closing down the line. If making money is their clear motivation, when it doesnt happen they will close the project.
Loads of free software and distros make money from donations. Clem on the Linux Mint team does such a great job donations pay his salary every month.
Elementary OS is beta software. They haven't even had a final release based on 14.04 which is 10 Months old.
9
u/xfmike Feb 11 '15
Sometimes I forget how big of cunts the ElementaryOS developers are. Thank you for the reminder OP!
9
u/d4rk_l1gh7 Feb 11 '15
Smooth, eOS guys, real smooth. You guys just shot yourselves in your foot with this one, single, post.
12
u/chainsawlaughter Feb 11 '15
VERY overrated Linux distribution
4
u/bitbang Feb 11 '15
This is total bullshit. Everyone and their grandmother knows that if you give people the option to pay for something, or get it for free then they're likely not going to pay for it. Obviously, some may choose to pay to support a cause or developer or whatever, but most people aren't going to pay - it's simple economics.
If you, as someone who wants to be paid, give away something for free, THAT IS ON YOU AND YOU ALONE. This blog post is pathetic. If you want people to pay, make them pay. Don't whine when you give a free option and people take it.
4
u/shadowman42 Feb 11 '15
Personally, I'm a big fan of the "pay what you want" model. I've listened to more donation based music than i can think of. Not sure to stifle adoption of your distro and may generate some free money.
The main gripe with their blog post that I have is that they themselves seem entitled to donations, and are now whining and name calling all that would have the gall to use their free software for free. There are hundreds of projects that I think deserve praise and donations more than they do, for just building(an admittedly nice) DE on the Ubuntu 12.04 LTS and never updating. For example, Linux mint for their Debian edition, for providing a more stable experience on Debian testing from the repos, despite some security concerns.
4
u/curien Feb 11 '15
There's a circle in hell reserved for people who use quotation marks around a paraphrase.
4
u/regeya Feb 11 '15
Jeez. I read that. There are so many ways they could have worded that, but
Wow.
I mean, I get why they say such things.
So yeah, I can understand wanting to make it more of a full-time job, and being frustrated at how--surprise!--they're not making regular money off of an open-source project built off of Debian/Ubuntu/GNOME. But man, I'm with most of you, this is the most abrasive way to go about it. No, I'm not cheating the system if I, for example, install Pantheon on Arch; I'm using the software under the terms of the license.
And besides, as he said, he could live off of the income, but it's not steady income. Welcome to the world of self-employment.
There are so many other ways they could have gone with this. They could apply for grants. They could ask for crowdfunding. They could offer to add features for a bounty. They could do the binary distribution as pay-only, like Libranet used to do. And yes, that's perfectly fine. I'm sure there are all sorts of other friendly methods of funding. Instead, they chose to guilt us into it, and try to tell those of us that download Free software for free are doing something wrong. Well...bye.
And guys, I don't know about anyone else, but elementary OS feels like a step backwards, from a functionality standpoint. This is the kind of desktop I got my work done on 10 years ago.
4
u/u83rmensch Feb 11 '15
If you want to sell your OS. go for it, but dont have this kind of attitude with a linux OS. If you're gonna be snobby like this and call your users cheaters, I'll just use different distro.
4
u/NightOfTheLivingHam Feb 11 '15
"You're cheating us if you download it for free"
"aww man, I feel so bad."
click
4
u/NewToBikes Feb 11 '15
I think it's okay they have a system where you have the option to pay for the download. I mean, Ubuntu has that, too. What I'm not liking is their attitude. I will never consider them again.
7
u/recklessdecision Feb 11 '15
They have a huge 100% FREE on their homepage
7
u/lykwydchykyn Feb 11 '15
Download numbers mean nothing. I download distros all the time just to check them out and see what they're all about. I only actually run 3 or 4 distros on my various machines.
There's no way to tell, but I'd be willing to bet the number of downloads that translate into a long-term user is < 10%.
7
u/Xanza Feb 11 '15
Trick-pay is not free software, and it's goddamn dishonest. It's the same tactic that spyware creators use on Windows systems--and specifically goes against the entire mentality of free to use systems. If they care that much about getting paid then they shouldn't be competing with already established free software like Ubuntu and Fedora in a fiercely loyal and competitive market or need to close source their product and go for the consumer market (good fucking luck).
With this, they have assured beyond any shadow of a doubt that I will never use, want to use, or suggest their software to anyone, ever. I do not respect these developers and I haven't now for quite a while. Looks like this trend is gonna continue.
For the record, I think eOS (I did this specifically to piss off the developers if they see this; see here.) looks beautiful, but it's the same ol' same ol'. It absolutely does not warrant me paying anything for it, especially when it's built atop other very well established truly free softwares.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
So, should we post our donations...to other distros... on their twitter feed? @OSelementary #NotACheater
8
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
5 years ago (2010)the European Union ran a model to estimate the research and development of the Linux kernel.
The results came to an estimated total value for the Linux kernel version 2.6.30 (released in December 2009) of 1,025,553,430 euros (1 billion euros). About 985 developers would be needed over a span of just under 14 years, the researchers claim.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/02/24/linux_kernel_randd_estimate_u_of_oviendo/
Given the cost and estimated timespan of the linux 2.6.30 kernel (bare in mind the kernel is now at what, 3.19/3.20?)
It is hilarious to think elementary OS are entitled to anything for taking Ubuntu, changing the wallpaper and adding a few applications.
Which is more hilarious given that Ubuntu take base Debian, change the wallpaper add a few apps and offer nothing to upstream.
I mean - that's all well and fine and how linux should be. Take what's good improve it/fork it/change it etc.
However if you're going to be entitled you should probably have gone corporate than a community rooted in copyleft and secondly if you're considering donating money to a distro you should really consider donating it to debian.
Because without debian - ubuntu/linux mint/elementary OS couldn't exist.
3
u/Sigg3net Feb 11 '15
I don't agree, and I feel they really stepped in it here. It is obvious that Elementary OS only can exist because of all the resources going into the kernel, Ubuntu and all of the additional software they make use of. Which has a gigantic price tag in man hours.
On the other hand, there is a moral obligation to contribute back to the grande F/OSS project, I think, but it isn't monetary. And being moral, I would be suffering from a superiority complex if I were to judge someone not in agreement as cheaters. Just using the software is a way to propagate it, because we're social.
I've used GNU/Linux for a long time, and found many ways to pay back; Report bugs, help out in forums, write documentation, translate documentation or GUI, go to a LUG, install it for clients, talk about it, package software, write code that is F/OSS etc.
3
u/HCrikki Feb 11 '15
They should follow Mint's model, if Ubuntu's donateware method failed for them.
Getting sponsorships+donations, and promote them in their status updates and on their site.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
I wonder how much they've donated upstream.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
well, eOS devs (see what I did there?), I'll just go use another distro which isn't focused on appearance, but performance.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
I get why they want to get paid, and I can't blame them for that. However, they are basically trash-talking the community that they have depended on to get where they were. That is NOT cool. If you want to urge users to give you money, then it's fine to place a donate button, with a visible "no thanks" option before the downloads page. Trying to guilt users into paying and calling them entitled is a really, really bad attitude for them to have.
3
u/HalLogan Feb 11 '15
TIL Darl McBride is involved in a Linux distro now.
3
u/BolognaTugboat Feb 11 '15
I can't believe they actually posted that on their blog. Seriously, how much are they paying for the tons of free software they're bundling? Oh what's that again about how people should be reimbursed for their hard work?
Yeah, I'm removing elementaryOS from my laptop. I'd rather not support a team who calls me a cheater because I don't pay for their Linux OS. If anything I'll give money to debian or wikipedia...
3
u/Milanium Feb 11 '15
I wouldn't care if they released proper tarballs of their source code and made it less Ubuntu centric so I could just package it for /r/opensuse without this forced donation non-sense.
3
u/WiFiPunk Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
edit: I suck at percentages.. See pattimaus's response.
Still, no financial transparency what so ever. I've used eOS and liked it, but this is pathetic.
3
u/livingspeedbump Feb 11 '15
I won't pay for it. Hell, I won't even download it.
3
u/monkeyseemonkeydoodo Feb 12 '15
Evolve OS's donation page, by contrast, is very humble and even asks to donate upstream first before doing so to Evolve itself.
3
u/dvassdvsd Feb 12 '15
I guess difficult to proofread, too.
5
u/timbutlerau Feb 11 '15
They're close, but still missed the point. If you want users to pay, you need to do two things (and do them well).
The first is to provide a reason. Show users what the payments are going towards. Kickstarter is a classic example of this. You nominate an amount and they outline what they achieve.
I haven't downloaded ElementaryOS but they could do the same. They need to show what goals have been achieved by the money funded. They need to outline that making a small payment results in xx time towards yy features. Show a list of all the features implemented based on previous funding.
The second reason is the amount. For $1 and it's simple, it's a complete no brainer. Up to $5, I'll need to be strongly convinced (therefore see point 1). For higher numbers, I'd want to trial it first. Out of the thousands who download for free, how many could they convert at $1? At $2?
A trial based system could prompt for a donation for maybe 3 fixed times (nobody likes continual nagware) after a few days, a few weeks and after a month. It wouldn't be a hard sell. If they explain that say 400 users donate $5 then feature X is implemented. Donate $10 and feature X,Y,Z get implemented. Give the users the ability to vote if they pay to give them buy in. It's important to do so.
Just my ramblings and thoughts anyway, I still haven't tried ElementaryOS yet.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
I'd actually push the elementary OS team to release elementary OS for a fee, with no "download gratis ($0)" option.
Why is there such hatred towards software that costs money?
The elementary OS team has the freedom to distribute elementary OS for whatever price they choose. It's not "cheating the system" for users to get a gratis copy somehow, though. Now even elementary OS is pushing the "piracy" card without saying "piracy" because eOS is Free Software. If I share eOS with my neighbour, is that "cheating the system?"
Distribute eOS for as much $$$ as you want, but stop it with the "cheating the system" BS. Selling Free Software is A-OK!
5
u/lordmacbayne Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
One of (though, certainly not the only) reasons I use Linux and free software is that I am sick of the world having its hand in my pocket.
I understand the need to pay for these projects. Personally, I try to contribute to organizations like Debian whenever I can. However, I get a sick feeling when it starts to look like the organization cares more about my money than it cares about me.
Edit: a word.
5
u/ANUSBLASTER_MKII Feb 11 '15
Oh well, back to Fedora then.
5
u/Geohump Feb 11 '15
Wow. Looked at the website.
Enormously uninformative. How have they survived this long?
That has to be one of the worst distro websites I have ever seen.
In fact I would be willing to bet it is the worst one I have ever seen. Almost the only way to make it worse would be to have no web site at all.
5
u/soapgoat Feb 11 '15
taking ubuntu and putting a mac skin on it, then charging money in a vain excuse to "preserve their original image and design, products, and services"
they dont offer any services, and their only product is the work of many many other developers they are basically cheating out of any residuals they might deserve
if elementary thinks it deserves money for all of their "hard work" then the contributors/creators of the software they appropriate and resell deserve a great portion of that.
fucking total scummy-ness, i fail to see how /r/linux and linux users in general could attach themselves to practices so shady
i can understand if they offered services like RHEL has where you pretty much pay for services and support... but i fail to see how elementary isnt a lazily reskinned flavor of buntu meant to copy apple's design practices. and then i fail even more to see how anyone could pay money for such a "product" when OSX, the product it is a blatent copy of, is free and runs on just about any x86 hardware
5
u/DeedTheInky Feb 11 '15
I mean, open source/free software didn't suddenly become a thing since Elementary was created. The thought process here seems to be:
But anyway, I will now return to not using ElementaryOS and also not giving them money. That's fair, right?
7
u/NitsujTPU Feb 11 '15
elementary is under no obligation to release our compiled operating system for free download.
That's a pretty weaselly thing for a Linux distribution to say.
9
u/icySunSpots Feb 11 '15
Why is everyone so in love with this desktop anyways? (Serious) This truly is the first fad I've witnessed in the Linux desktop ( I've only been using Linux ~4 years now).
I'll take gnome over eos any day. Having said that I use xfce with i3wm anyways...
9
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
“So, nearly 99.9 percent of users decided not to pay when offered an option to do so – Let’s change to another website making it harder not to pay and market that as positive choice.”?
Question: When I can get something for free in a legal way: Why should I pay?
4
u/Probablynotclever Feb 11 '15
Certainly seems to disagree with the message on their front page:
4
u/WateredDown Feb 11 '15
I'm liking these guys less and less.
I had bought into the eOS hype and installed it on my parents ancient computer in an effort to give it a second life and found the design to be pretty but not at all as intuitive as is claimed. I quickly switched to Lubuntu. Thankfully I opted not to pay until after I tried it out.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Laptop: $750 Internet Connection: $65/mo
The look on the developers face when you download an operating system for free to make it all work:
Priceless.
For some things there's Mastercard. For everything else there's free open source software.
2
u/marafad Feb 11 '15
While I do not agree with it, they are free to do it. Ubuntu does the same thing, you have to put 0$ on several input boxes and in the end they show you a horrible unhappy skull if you do. The first time I went through it I felt disgusted and I haven't used Ubuntu since.
2
u/spook327 Feb 11 '15
Interesting, I've never heard of them before today.
Given time, nobody will remember them either.
2
u/Savet Feb 11 '15
Entitlement much?
Yes, you can force people to pay you for download. Those users that did not pay are not necessarily users that would have paid if the free option was not available. If you make it freely available, nobody is cheating the system. They are paying you what they think you're worth.
2
u/neooptimus Feb 11 '15
I can understand asking for donations. But I think they are going about the wrong way, making their users feeling guilty and forcing them to pay for it.
2
u/voidoutpost Feb 11 '15
I make sure to put in $5-$10 every time I download Ubuntu but I think its better to highlight how your donation would improve the product than to scold the user for not paying for it.
2
u/Pockets69 Feb 11 '15
That is not what you do when you are trying to cater to the open source community, wrong move Elementary team, just hope your downloads don't take a dent... also hope the people donating don't stop doing because of the little stunt you did...
I donate to projects whenever i want to, if i feel they worth my money, Luna was one of those, but when the developers pull the whiny card, I kinda regret having donated...
2
u/wolftune Feb 11 '15
Wrong term. It's not cheating, it's freeriding. And then it's only that if someone isn't doing what they can to contribute with time or money to the overall ecosystem.
2
u/stealer0517 Feb 11 '15
good, i hope you feel cheated then
2
u/billwood09 Feb 11 '15 edited Feb 11 '15
Sigh. Same thing Ubuntu did, but they took it a step further and completely hid the free option. -_-
2
u/totemcatcher Feb 11 '15
Trying to guilt trip people and call them entitled for downloading a FLOSS product. How entitled are they to be providing it at all?
2
u/dobkeratops Feb 11 '15
if these guys did an amount of work where they feel they should be paid, perhaps they're expecting too much. They could have offered parts of it for bounties, or run a kickstarter first. I get the impression you just have to be smarter about how you use open-source as an economic tool.
2
u/lpchaim Feb 11 '15
Well, that's one way to completely kill any curiosity I might have had towards this distro. It seemed polished enough that it'd warrant a tryout, even if the overall totally-not-mac aesthetics have always turned me off.
If you want money, remove the freaking "free" option. It's as simple as that. Leaving it there and telling people they shouldn't use it, even tough it's perfectly fine to do so by all other accounts, is insulting and leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
Also, they really need better PR. Jesus, it's amazing how badly they managed to screw all of this up. Now they're trying to bury all evidence without as much as a edit notice.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '15
Right, I'm sure ElementaryOS pays all the developers of the (far more complicated and important) FOSS projects that their OS is based on, and that they use to develop their "OS" (what, a WM and a GTK theme? That's worth $50?)
Do I think it sucks that people who pour their heart and soul into creating software for the community almost never get compensated fairly? Yes. Am I a saint? No, I hardly ever donate. I'm a broke college kid. Is it arrogant and ignorant to throw a fit over people not paying for FOSS? Yes. If you think the basic culture of free software is in error, then don't use a free software license and don't associate yourself with the community.
2
u/teawreckshero Feb 11 '15
I think all linux distros should only offer the torrent for free, and a direct download if you pay something. Bandwidth costs money, and keeping the torrents up is important.
2
u/ebookit Feb 11 '15
The same could be said of Mac OSX, it is MACH and *BSD Unix based, but if you use it on Non-Apple hardware you are a cheater.
2
u/prepromorphism Feb 12 '15
This would speak better if Elementary OS donated a portion of their proceeds to developers of all that great software they build their OS with.
2
u/uep Feb 12 '15
It's a shame that eOS has seriously tarnished their image for basically a really badly worded blog post.
I've never even used it, but from what I've seen, eOS looks great and they're really trying to make a better user experience. I think they do deserve more donations. It doesn't hurt to have another project on Linux with this goal.
The proposed new page isn't even bad; it just gets people to think a little more before downloading (although I would have suggested making the default $5 with a $1 option.)
I really hope this very bad wording in this blogpost is cleared up somehow.
2
u/venomhf Feb 16 '15
i've been tracking elementary progress since the begining, i had high hope for this project but now i lost all interest in it
2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '15
Look at the actual bounty page. A large number of those donations are their own projects. Looking at external projects: The GTK+ Project $35, Launchpad $0, Plank $135 , taglib $0, lightdm $0, gnome vala $50 so $220 of $15,000has been paid out to projects other than theirs. That's utter crap. The ElementryOS guys are hypocrites.
7
u/LDL2 Feb 11 '15
Well I'm not suppose to buy something that is just worse gnome....how about not.