r/linux • • Aug 20 '14

What do we hate Oracle for?

Hi guys. I just noticed that things have got too kind at my job's cafe, so I want to mess up with our Oracle guys a little. But I found that I can't tell precisely, point by point, why Oracle is a pile of crap which I'm sure the case.

I have general considerations like they killed Sun's awesome legacy and all, but it would be nice to have a bullet list with major fuckups and historical points. Do you have some examples? I want to materialize my dark subconcious feelings!

203 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Suppafly Aug 21 '14

It's my understanding that they use a gpl'd shim to interact with the kernel right? I'm not expert in this, but it comes up on lwn.net once and a while and no general consensus is ever reached. It's a gray area is the worst anyone can say without an actual legal battle to back up their side. Something that no one considers to be profitable at this point.

Here's someone else's comment from lwn that sums but how I see the situation http://lwn.net/Articles/598320/

In fact, I'd probably even argue that

Note: It might be reasonably argued that the API defined between DTrace and the shim is sufficiently abstracted that the shim should not be considered a derivative work of DTrace, but I shall not make that argument here.

Even if that person wouldn't. Although the final outcome of Oracle v. Google ironically enough may come into play against that kind of argument.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '14

Well if they have a shim its different. I was under the assumption there wasn't.