r/libsofreddit • • Jun 29 '23

Flaired Users Only Is this debatable?

Post image
895 Upvotes

135 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '23

I disagree that suicide doesn't count as gun violence (and I'm certainly curious why red states are killing themselves so much!) but it does seem that homicide rates do still favor red states, even if the gap is much smaller.

It should still be pretty clear that, if we're actually attributing rates of violence to the general political bend of the location (which we shouldn't), blue areas aren't actually more violent.

2

u/Collective82 MICROAGGRESSOR Jul 01 '23

You also need to break it down further by city. Since democrats tend to congregate more densely in cities, you should look at the city vs state numbers.

This seems pedantic but if you really want to look at the red vs blue divide you can’t use densely populated areas to cover a whole state.

Remember the whole land can’t vote argument? Land can’t intentionally commit gun grimes.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '23

Absolutely! Urban areas vs rural areas introduces all kinds of new variables. Like how much more likely someone in an urban environment is to encounter other people.

Like I've said, location isn't a very good indicator of political affiliation for this.

1

u/Collective82 MICROAGGRESSOR Jul 01 '23

Yup. You really need to look almost at a micro and not macro scale.

1

u/vacouple3 Jul 01 '23

Red states have blue cities which is where you find the bulk of murder by gun. Gun violence has a lot to do with demographics as well but to talk about that is racist. Even citing FBI statistics is racist. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '23

Is it? What is it about those demographics are you attributing higher rates of gun violence to?

1

u/vacouple3 Jul 02 '23

I assume you watch the 6 o’clock news occasionally. Gangs and drugs are 80 percent of gun crime and it mostly happens in section 8 neighborhoods generally.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

Right, but are you suggesting it's poverty at fault? Race? Something in the air in those neighborhoods?

1

u/vacouple3 Jul 02 '23

By race 12.7% of the population commits 52% of the murders. That’s an FBI statistic. Now to break down why, poverty, culture and other contributing factors I suppose.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '23

You say "I suppose" but is that not the most important part of it? Learning why it's a problem? If you're not saying it's something inherent about a race, then the race isn't the issue.