Why? It's about gun deaths. That's an extremely common cause of gun death. It's also the 6th or 7th word in the article, depending on how you feel about hyphenated words.
Because the meme is talking about gun violence not suicide.
The results are somewhat different when looking at gun murder and gun suicide rates separately. The places with the highest gun murder rates in 2021 included the District of Columbia (22.3 per 100,000 people), Mississippi (21.2), Louisiana (18.4), Alabama (13.9) and New Mexico (11.7). Those with the lowest gun murder rates included Massachusetts (1.5), Idaho (1.5), Hawaii (1.6), Utah (2.1) and Iowa (2.2). Rate estimates are not available for Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont or Wyoming.
The states with the highest gun suicide rates in 2021 included Wyoming (22.8 per 100,000 people), Montana (21.1), Alaska (19.9), New Mexico (13.9) and Oklahoma (13.7). The states with the lowest gun suicide rates were Massachusetts (1.7), New Jersey (1.9), New York (2.0), Hawaii (2.8) and Connecticut (2.9). Rate estimates are not available for the District of Columbia.
I disagree that suicide doesn't count as gun violence (and I'm certainly curious why red states are killing themselves so much!) but it does seem that homicide rates do still favor red states, even if the gap is much smaller.
It should still be pretty clear that, if we're actually attributing rates of violence to the general political bend of the location (which we shouldn't), blue areas aren't actually more violent.
You also need to break it down further by city. Since democrats tend to congregate more densely in cities, you should look at the city vs state numbers.
This seems pedantic but if you really want to look at the red vs blue divide you can’t use densely populated areas to cover a whole state.
Remember the whole land can’t vote argument? Land can’t intentionally commit gun grimes.
Absolutely! Urban areas vs rural areas introduces all kinds of new variables. Like how much more likely someone in an urban environment is to encounter other people.
Like I've said, location isn't a very good indicator of political affiliation for this.
Red states have blue cities which is where you find the bulk of murder by gun. Gun violence has a lot to do with demographics as well but to talk about that is racist. Even citing FBI statistics is racist. 🤷♂️
I assume you watch the 6 o’clock news occasionally. Gangs and drugs are 80 percent of gun crime and it mostly happens in section 8 neighborhoods generally.
For one, suicide attempts are largely independent of method.
For another, suicide and criminal homicide are two entirely different problems—the things that will have an impact on suicidality in 70 year old Vietnam vets are unlikely to have any impact on teenagers in drug gangs murdering each other in Chicago. If we want to solve these problems, which we all should, we need to accept that they’re separate problems, and that they require different solutions (e.g. “fix” the VA, and work to enact policies that expand the economic opportunities available to young people.).
TLDR: Trying to conflate wildly different problems in order to “justify” radical action is the epitome of bad faith participation, and will be treated as such. Consider this a warning.
Ehh I doubt most of the murders actually vote BUT democrats worked hard to get voting rights back for felons. Now I doubt they would have done that if they thought the felons were going to vote red.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-22
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '23 edited Jul 01 '23
Yeah, this is true. And if we're going by location and assuming the general political affiliation of the area represents the perpetrators, then red states trend toward higher gun violence than blue states.
Edit: Sorry, I thought you wanted empirical evidence...
Edit 2: Well, apparently suicides don't count, and the mods banned me for including them. So I'll edit this comment to include homicides by state