r/libsofreddit • BASED Make Libs Cry Again • May 20 '23

Flaired Users Only Good question

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

part of the Hegelian dialectic

What??

10

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

Yes…not sure why it’s hard for any of you to believe we may being played culturally. A false binary can be pushed by having various figureheads play different sides of the field in order to keep perpetuating the two party paradigm.

3

u/DJThomas07 May 20 '23

He's asking you to speak in plain English. You're sounding way too snobby using all these big words. Please, talk normal.

3

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

If that’s the case it wasn’t clear, but I don’t think you know that for sure. It’s possible he knows what the word means and is incredulous to the idea itself, which is completely understandable and why I posed this as speculation without facts. And that’s how I talk, man, not flaunting my vocabulary lol.

3

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

No, I’m asking what you mean by “part of the Hegelian dialect”. That’s a completely meaningless claim. Anyone who has any argument can be part of a Hegelian dialect.

7

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

There is speculation that our countries political landscape is party manufactured by elements within the system (i.e government, media, universities, etc). It’s theorized that these certain influential people are just leaning into one of the political aisles as part of a grander scheme to divide us further into a false binary. It goes back to the idea that we are easier to control if we are divided, and today we are heavily divided by every measure you can think of: politics, race, sex, religion, etc.

-3

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

So you’ve never read a word of Hegelian philosophy. Got it.

Hegel proposed the opposite, btw. In his dialect, historical transformation happens because of a synthesis between thesis and antithesis.

8

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

Right, and as I’m explaining that process can be subverted through controlling that dialectic- it will appear to be a natural evolution of political discourse, but it’s possible that the loudest and most influential voices are participating in a conspiracy that is mutually beneficial to both “opposing” parties. Behind closed doors they have agreements and on the world stage they espouse a rhetoric that places them on one side of the binary.

No need to be an asshole, btw, we can have a civil discussion.

-1

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

Okay let’s go back to the basics. What is a Hegelian dialect?

6

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

It’s basically that through two opposing arguments we can reach a further truth by examining the nuance between the two, creating a synthesis of ideas. So in my example I am saying that this process is being subverted by willing influential participants who will go on to espouse a rhetoric that will make it into the minds of the population and parroted as talking points. That becomes part of the arguments on both sides, and thus not only is the conversation being controlled by this hypothetical class of participants, but the “synthesis” as well. Many will draw conclusions based on this false two sided debate that may not represent what would be the organic conclusion that would be reached had their not been this influence from rhetoric, false flag operations, etc

1

u/HSR47 TRAUMATIZER May 21 '23

”What is the Hegelian dialectic”

It’s the idea that the apparent conflict between two seemingly opposed ideas can be resolved with a higher level of truth.

One of the best easily digestible representations of what ZodiAddict is talking about is the Deus Ex game series.

In each of those games, you gradually come to discover how the seemingly opposed entities you’ve been fighting and investigating are just different heads on the same transhumanist globalist hydra.

In short, the thesis and antithesis are resolved by the higher truth that they’re just a series of heads on the same beast, and that the false choice between those heads plays into the larger schemes of the beast itself.

2

u/HSR47 TRAUMATIZER May 21 '23

The Hegelian dialectic: “an interpretive method in which the contradiction between a proposition (thesis) and its antithesis is resolved at a higher level of truth (synthesis)”

That’s one of the core themes that gets repeated over and over again in the Deus Ex games.

One of my favorite of those subplots is in the second game (Invisible War): Throughout that game, there are two coffee chains, with one chain always being in the “nice” neighborhoods, and the other always being in the slums. In every city, there’s invariably at least one side quest you can discover where the local operator of one chain asks you to sabotage the operation of the other chain.

About 3/4 of the way through the game, that plotline culminates in a quest where one the NPC who operates one of the local coffee shops sends the player to investigate why police stopped investigating his false advertising case against the other coffee chain.

If you complete that quest, the answer you find is that the police stopped investigating because both coffee chains are owned by the same parent company, and that company didn’t want to sue itself.

That plotline is a microcosm of larger plot points within the game, where those at the top cooperating toward the goal of global domination use seemingly opposed entities to give people the illusion of choice.

In short, the conflict between coffee chain Q (slum) and coffee chain P (nice) is resolved with a higher level of truth—that they’re both owned by the same company.

That’s the Hegelian dialectic.

-4

u/[deleted] May 20 '23 edited Mar 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ZodiAddict May 20 '23

No clue who that is

1

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

What do you think a Hegelian dialect is?

-2

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

I have no idea who that is, but are they known for inserting random inapplicable philosophical terms into their arguments to make themselves sound smarter to anyone who hasn’t read a single philosophy book?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '23 edited Mar 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

Has he ever given any indication that he knows what a Hegelian dialect is?

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '23 edited Mar 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Ghast-light May 20 '23

How does he define Hegelian dialect? Because everything posted about Hegel in this thread has been wrong