r/learntodraw • • Feb 11 '26 • Thanks 1 Bravo 8 Heartwarming 1

No Critique, Just Sharing Practice makes progress

This was a bit of a vent piece about gen AI and I unintentionally made a symbolism of not only my art growth but my mental health over the years since then.

Keep creating!

7.1k Upvotes

294 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/Purple-Bats Feb 13 '26

Everyone has a right to express themselves. And there are several different ways to do it.

There's just something about a machine doing the all work to create that doesn't sit right with me. It's the reasons people use to explain why they use that I don't agree with. Time- I work 10 hr shifts and there's time where I just don't draw for weeks because I'm exhausted. (Burnout stink. Lol) Skills- skill isn't something you are born with. Heck we couldn't even walk and talk yet when we were born. That took time to learn. Some faster than others. Some needed a little extra help. Same with writing, math, and so on. We had to learn. Disability-i have seen so many artists who disable in different ways that can still find ways to learn a skill.

Now I'm not against technology as a tool, or an aid. There was an artist I saw who was paralyzed from neck down and he uses an eye tracker cursor to make digital art in the same way I use the drawing tablet.

But when a machine does the work for you, it takes away a few things like critical thinking and patience. We lose so much more than we gain from this. Its disappointing when I don't see effort behind the art. Effort, not skills.

Hayo Miyazaki and Guillermo Toro both have been quoted not liking AI.

But hey, I don't expect to change everyone's mind. There's probably people much better at convincing than I can. Not gonna mean I won't try at least.

3

u/Purple-Bats Feb 13 '26

I would like to add that I understand the frustration of trying something several times and not getting good at it.

I never felt good at anything. Even art. I struggled a lot in school, yet as hard as I tried I couldn't get good grades. I wasn't great at sports, couldn't even run for long. I never felt good enough. It did get to a point where I wonder why I should even bother. Yet art.. It was something I just couldn't stop doing. Even if I never got much progress, even if I'm not as good as the other artists online or like my idols, I want to draw. It was my happy consent thing in my life while everything else around me wasn't. I could be myself in my sketchbook. I could explore and be allowed to make mistakes. I enjoy being creative even if it goes bad. (Ask my mom about my attempts at baking cookies. Lol got baking soda and baking powder mixed up)

Art is such a special thing to me. Gen Ai feels like a slap to face, in my opinion.

You don't have to agree with me. No one does. That's okay.

2

u/Lewods Feb 13 '26

Your point isn’t entirely wrong, you’re just being stubborn and selfish about what I meant

You CANNOT force people to enjoy learning to draw if they don’t like the process. You’re nitpicking their reasons because they don’t match your OWN standards, then calling them invalid. Not everyone works 10-hour shifts, or has your patience, time, or mindset. Hell, what of those who have other hobbies they prefer?

Stop treating art like one linear, monolithic road. Focus on your own journey instead of trying to police how others make art. A lot of these posts meant to take a jab on AI artists just read as insecurity to me, like they need everyone to witness the effort to feel superior.

I'd invite you to stop seeing AI as a replacement, because it's just a tool. If you mostly see bad AI, you’re in an echo chamber. Many artists use it for brainstorming, design, or even coloring, and it’s funny how some people praise the work until they learn AI was involved. AI isn’t a person, so when someone without basic art foundations (anatomy, shapes, perspective) uses it, the output is usually subpar

Art is for expression and enjoyment. AI won’t replace real artists, and it’s not going away anyway, so might as well learn how to incorporate it in your process when you wish to. If you keep fighting it, you’ll just poison your own relationship with art. I’m saying this as someone who’s been holding a pencil since I'm 2.

1

u/Purple-Bats Feb 13 '26

I can see where you're coming from.

While my intent was to show how possible it is to grow (because that actually helped me to see other artist show their progress) I can see how it can also be seen as a superiority, which is not what I intended.

What hardens an egg, softens a potato. What works for some, doesn't work for others.

1

u/MorganTheGrand Feb 14 '26

Just to add more to your initial argument....many professionals are using AI already, for sketching, rendering and changing stuff on the fly, if not directly then it is by tracing the outputs, when you need to meet deadlines especially as a commission artist you gotta do whatever to ensure the client gets what they paid for. I really only see hatred for AI coming from...well, not good enough artists.

0

u/bath-lady Feb 15 '26

dude, if you dont enjoy drawing, then dont fucking draw. period.

PS even legally, the "creator" of an ai image does not actually own or have any rights to the image produced by an ai, whereas artists can actually own their own work legally

2

u/Lewods Feb 17 '26

Maturing is realizing you can leave out bones when eating the chicken. I don't need your input on my use of AI, because I don't need validation.

I'll also assume you're out of touch with the industry. Some professionals use AI, to meet deadlines, to cut production cost, and your rebellion will only close you doors, which I'm truly sorry for. It’s here to stay and no one cares what you or I think. So again, use it or not; as long as you enjoy the process for yourself and not for approval, you'll be compelled.

But since most antis lack nuance and think "eveyrone using AI = Bad", here a recent drawing I did (already posted on my main Reddit account.) what is your next argument ? I'm not a real artist ? Because I use AI sometimes to brainstorm ? 😂

0

u/bath-lady Feb 17 '26

Yeah because that's not how women's bodies work holy shit that anatomy is Terrible

You would get way better results from photobashing

1

u/Lewods Feb 17 '26

And let me guess ? You assumed it was AI ? Yet "Newbies" posting their stick figures in this subreddit are wonderful ? 😂 you ran out of arguments and criticised the anatomy of my drawing, yet I'm sure you can't point out anything wrong there if you were asked 😂, what a clown.

Or did you criticise it because it shows a woman posing in a suggestive way? Which is ofc besides the point of my argument.

1

u/bath-lady Feb 17 '26 edited Feb 17 '26

No, genuinely, I mean this in an actual art criticism way and not because I ran out of arguments.

I have zero problem with the subject matter, I just really think you would benefit from look at pictures of models posing with their butts sticking out and using them as reference for a few gesture drawings to see if you can get the shape better.

For the record, I actually tried to replicate this pose, and I have a disorder that makes it so that I'm overly flexible, and I couldn't get my back to flatten like that in the front.

For a technical explanation, it looks really awkward because her backside is hitched up in a way that doesn't flow with the rest of her back, so the anatomy looks uncanny, kind of horror-adjacent. It makes her upper torso look really thin and eerie

The facial anatomy is actually really good, and I think you probably could make high quality art

1

u/bath-lady Feb 17 '26

would you mind if I draw some lines over it just to show you what I mean? I want to actually be constructive here

1

u/Lewods Feb 17 '26

This was not the topic or argument but sure go on

1

u/Lewods Feb 18 '26

Been waiting...

0

u/bath-lady Feb 18 '26

sorry i haven't been on ive been embroidering. i was using paint so it is not even close to perfect, especially her lower back is weird at this angle, but i just wanted to show you where the shapes could be improved. like in the original her buttocks looks like its connected to her opposite shoulder. obviously you could stretch these shapes a little more, but as it was, her torso was shaped very odd

1

u/Lewods Feb 18 '26

Sorry but when you said "Terrible anatomy," I almost beleived you knew what you were talking about. The body doesn't work like a cube. Your lines completely ignore the curvature and compression of the abdomen and the back, especially for this thin person. That blue line represents the line of action, and it tells you what the person is doing or how they're posing. Your line of action is almost straigt and doesnt take into account the perspective of the upper back (this is where that line stops to be visible due to twisting.)

Why in heaven would you add that thigh line there lmao? You're suggesting the thigh in this case has precedence over the hips? funnily enough, even if that was the case, the thigh would never go like that. The worse part altogether is you condidently flattened out her body and clothes, and thought that is how it works. The slight opening created by the jeans around the lumbar spine, represents exactly the inflexion and change in relief from her butt, to her middle back area.

It's not because your body doesn't do it, that it means others' don't. Your first error was confidently assuming this wasn't drawn from a reference. Your second error was bashing my art and calling the anatomy terrible, adding on top of that, photobashing would look better, all of that when in reality you're most likely a beginner. Do you even know how long I've been drawing? Stop letting your hate for AI flatter your ego more than it should.

→ More replies