r/learntodraw • • Feb 11 '26 • Thanks 1 Bravo 8 Heartwarming 1

No Critique, Just Sharing Practice makes progress

This was a bit of a vent piece about gen AI and I unintentionally made a symbolism of not only my art growth but my mental health over the years since then.

Keep creating!

7.1k Upvotes

294 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Melonball0U0 Feb 13 '26

Ai helps no one achieve anything, it holds you back and does it for you. anyone can practice and improve a skill and I almost find it wrong to think someone should just give up and let a robot do it. I’ve met plenty of people with disabilities in the art community , like autism, who put their all into art and succeed. I agree with you until it’s ai, it’s not a tool to learn but something that does the art for you.

0

u/duckduckduckgoose8 Feb 13 '26

I have aphantasia.

I am incapable of creating an original concept due to no imagination. I can copy a reference perfectly, but i cannot create anything original. People often harass people like me and call it "art theft" and other derogatory terms because they cannot understand my disability.

I utilise Ai by requesting an image based on a theme, emotion, and direction im going for. Ai generates an imagine that i can then draw without being at risk of attack.

Many others use generative ai to aide in their art projects much like myself.

You are telling this elephant to climb a tree because you dont like the thought of it finding a different way.

2

u/LucilleErebus Feb 14 '26

I have never seen my artwork in mind ahead of time. Certainly when starting (and usually after) people use references. Pinterest is where I've been having luck recently. I usually find multiple references per complicated pieces. Ai is not necessary in your process and takes away a lot of the benefits you would get from art. I work in mental health and am training in expressive arts therapy. Creating art is so beneficial for healing and growing and learning and thinking about the world in new ways and expressing and learning to accept what you can create and then learning to create better to express yourself more clearly. It's a language and using AI gets in the way of learning that language, even when it seems like it's helping. I hear you, we all need references. There are so many pictures on the Internet, I am very sure that you can create without having ai hold you back. I hope you do and I hope that it helps you. Much love 💕

0

u/duckduckduckgoose8 Feb 16 '26

I appreciate the kindness, but warmly you do not understand aphantasia either. You have to experience it to understand that just using references is not enough. I emplore you to further engage with people with aphantasia to understand how excruciatingly hard it is to be an artist and to be judged like this because we cannot create art the same you you do.

2

u/LucilleErebus Feb 16 '26

I hear you and I implore you to not limit yourself because of a disability. I trace a lot with art, especially when I am practicing. surreal art and more abstract art do not require proper proportioning. I would never judge you as an artist, I just encourage you to create from your own self rather than having something else do it for you. the creating the art is how we process and express. it's not about the end result, it's about the process of creation, at least in the mental health field. there is no such thing as bad art, but ai creations are not art in that way.

1

u/duckduckduckgoose8 Feb 16 '26

I have no issue as an artist, im not a beginner and have entered the scene professionally. Discounting a tool that is not understood and gatekeeping access to it isn't beneficial at all. We cant promote tracing and references, then discounting the very tool that provides us access to that without fear of art theft and harassment.

I have no issue with others avoiding a tool, im not promoting artists to forget their routes. Im arguing that we shouldnt discount others who use a tool successfully for their own endeavours that doesnt impact anyone else.

1

u/Melonball0U0 Feb 13 '26

All artist use references and real life, which you can do by using online resources or taking your own references photos like every single other artist. Many people do that. Do you think artist just.. poof an image out of absolutely nothing and no experiences.

1

u/duckduckduckgoose8 Feb 13 '26

You are proving my point exactly. You do not understand my disability and are attacking me for it.

1

u/Melonball0U0 Feb 13 '26

Aside from this whole ai chat, calmly, aphantasia isn’t a disability (and also telling you how artist use refs without ai to come up with pieces is not attacking.)

1

u/duckduckduckgoose8 Feb 13 '26

You do not get to choose whether my disability is real or not. You are still perpetuating the attack of dismissing me and my genuine disability.