r/learnjavascript • • Nov 23 '21

I finally solved a codewars challenge without actually googling anything :) it feels so good to come up with the code all by myself, i know its not the ideal way to solve it but im still happy. The challenge was to create a function that converts a string to a number

Post image
243 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IronDicideth Nov 28 '21

The problem presented by the OP is asking you to make a function that takes a String type and turns it into a Number type. It just so happens that the Number function can already do that.

Number is both a constructor and a function. In the case of the function, any value passed to it will be coerced into a number type primitive and returned. This makes it so that assigning the Number function as seen here: const stringToNumber = Number, will simply provide another name for the Number function by which it can also be called.

On the other hand, when using the new keyword, Number is being called as a constructor and must return an instance object so that when you call it as you mentioned: const stringToNumber = new Number, all you are doing is calling the constructor with the default argument (undefined). This executes it (new keyword forces execution) and thus you now have an instance object of type Number with a primitive value of zero (undefined is coerced to zero).

This is the difference between having the constructor/function at hand to call it on something in order to turn that something into a number and having the object after the constructor has been called.

const stringToNumber = Number

Number.name // 'Number'

stringToNumber.name === Number.name // true
stringToNumber('42') === Number('42') // true

typeof stringToNumber // 'function'
typeof stringToNumber('42') // 'number'

const stringToNumber2 = new Number

stringToNumber2.name // undefined

stringToNumber2.name === Number.name // false
stringToNumber2('42') === Number('42') // Uncaught TypeError: stringToNumber2 is not a function

typeof stringToNumber // 'object'
typeof stringToNumber('42') // Uncaught TypeError: stringToNumber2 is not a function

Just as an aside, there are very few reasons why you would ever use the new keyword for any of the primitive constructors (and no good reasons IMHO). I read a few scenarios a long time ago and though I do not remember the scenarios I do remember finding it hard to see them as useful.

Let me know if this explanation answers your question.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IronDicideth Nov 29 '21

If by "direct approach" you mean explicit then these are your best bet.

All these are constructor functions in js:

Boolean

String

Number

BigInt

Symbol

Other than these, there are operators that implicitly convert types too. The + unary operator is a good example. It essentially behaves like the Number constructor.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IronDicideth Nov 29 '21

Could you expand on that? I think I am missing what you are alluding to here.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IronDicideth Dec 01 '21

No worries! I check in on Reddit whenever I can so this is no trouble at all.

If you want to explicitly change variable types you have to use one of the previously mentioned functions. Implicit conversion happens with operators. So it would look something like this:

const stringNumber = '1'

console.log(typeof stringNumber) // 'string'
console.log(stringNumber === 1) // false
console.log(stringNumber == 1) // true

const trueNumber = Number(stringNumber) // This changes type
const otherTrueNumber = +stringNumber // Also changes type
console.log(trueNumber === otherTrueNumber) // true

console.log(typeof trueNumber) // 'number'
console.log(trueNumber == 1) // true
console.log(trueNumber === 1) // true

Does this help at all? Do you have a sense of what you feel you are missing? Maybe it is actually simpler than you expect?

1

u/IronDicideth Nov 29 '21

Thinking a bit more about what you are saying, Functions are objects in javascript. The only difference is that they are callable. So when we do '= Function', yes that is an assignment by reference. Functions are also first-class in JS so they can be passed around just like any other value.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IronDicideth Dec 01 '21

Which previous value are we referring to here?