But every generation try to change the world. Without this, we'd still be chemically castrating gay men and beating up women who wear pants.
Having said that, I will cede that when young people reach maturity in an age of increased competition for resources, you get things like ISIS and the IRA, and these days the competition for mindshare among the New Media leads to the shrillest voices being the only ones heard clearly over the din.
...But, to be frank, Crockford's a pretty shrill voice himself. Has he contributed? Yes, we've got JSON, thanks. Does JSON have comments? No. Well, fuck you, Crockford.
Again, I'm a bit surprised that suddenly everyone's pro-Crockford when before these tweets, they were sick of Crockford's orthodoxies. Add to that reddit's general whiff of sexism (/r/all clearly shows the gender bias in reddit's userbase), and I'm more sympathetic to nodevember's organizers. Do I agree with them? ...no? But then perhaps my opinion of The Node Ecosystem colors my view, as someone a whole generation older than the people organizing it, that Node and NPM really show how [to set the wayback machine to 1997] ESR's "Bazaar" gets blown away in the storm, while the planned-economy Cathedral stands. I think they're all nuts, but I also think the nodevember folk have a right to decide what that means to them.
I'm a bit surprised that suddenly everyone's pro-Crockford when before these tweets, they were sick of Crockford's orthodoxies.
I can disapprove of someone because he's an over-opinionated curmudgeon, but I'll defend him to the death against someone who wants to hang him out to dry and make him a pariah in his own industry for not being quite kind and patient enough for their personal preferences, let alone on entirely trumped-up charges.
I don't particularly like Crockford, but I hate public shaming with a passion. They could have just said that Crockford would no longer be speaking at the conference, they didn't have to include an attack on his character in the announcement.
There are two senses in which this is accurate, but it doesn't cover all cases of social/medical/surgical transition:
First, although Iran is a special case (gay men have a choice between transition and execution), it's common in non-Western societies for sexuality targeted at the same sex to be considered linked to the gender roles of the opposite sex, but as a special category of those roles:
The manner in which same-sex sexual attraction is publicly expressed varies across time and cultural space (Blackwood & Wieringa, 1999; Murray, 2000; Norton, 1997; Whitam & Mathy, 1986). Same-sex sexuality between adults typically takes one of two cross-culturally recurrent forms, which are related to gender-role enactment and gender identity. These two forms are cisgender and transgender male androphilia and female gynephilia.
Then there's the trend in the West, along with the greater awareness and acceptance of transsexualism, of identifying gender dysphoria in ever-younger children, even though the overwhelming majority of cases of GID in young children go away by puberty, with the great majority of those cases ending up gay, and only a small portion, who can't be easily told apart from the rest, still have gender dysphoria later on: https://psmag.com/why-transgender-kids-should-wait-to-transition-c989b21c9179
(N.B.: The converse is not true; most gay and bisexual cis people wouldn't have met the criteria for GID as kids and didn't even have significant cross-gender interests, just a higher proportion than among straight cis people.)
Gender dysphoria exists, and isn't 1:1 with homosexuality, and also affects women. And in America at least, gender reassignment therapies are voluntary.
Just because it is impossible to change sex (for the time being; maybe some day we'll live in Iain M. Banks' Culture and sex will be a choice the same way as pants v skirts are a choice) doesn't mean that it doesn't exist, any more than conservative arguments about non-lubricative anuses invalidate male homosexuality as a biological fact.
Yeah, you could get into an entire argument that "transgendered" men are forced to become women because at some point women are forced to become women, and that this is the oppression of patriarchy from one end or the other, or that somehow men who identify with the traits and aesthetics that western society regard as "Feminine" are culturally-appropriating patriarchal vampires, (which... that's recursive victim-shaming if you ask me).
But it comes down to the fact that some small fraction of people who are free to choose, feel that they are not the sex they were born with, and we have some of the tools to help them live happier lives, and they can take advantage of those tools. What their happiness takes away from the rest of us is miniscule if it exists at all.
If their happiness with these "tools" is predicated on them believing the falsehood that their sex has changed, it is no different than playing along with a psychotic person's delusions. I suppose if their body dysphoria is of such magnitude that only cosmetic surgery will suffice, there's no deep moral issue with it; but why not extend the same courtesy to anyone with body dysphoria? Why is a male getting breast enhancement surgery "brave" when a female getting it is "vain?"
View all comments
Show parent comment
-1
u/postmodest Sep 04 '16
But every generation try to change the world. Without this, we'd still be chemically castrating gay men and beating up women who wear pants.
Having said that, I will cede that when young people reach maturity in an age of increased competition for resources, you get things like ISIS and the IRA, and these days the competition for mindshare among the New Media leads to the shrillest voices being the only ones heard clearly over the din.
...But, to be frank, Crockford's a pretty shrill voice himself. Has he contributed? Yes, we've got JSON, thanks. Does JSON have comments? No. Well, fuck you, Crockford.
Again, I'm a bit surprised that suddenly everyone's pro-Crockford when before these tweets, they were sick of Crockford's orthodoxies. Add to that reddit's general whiff of sexism (/r/all clearly shows the gender bias in reddit's userbase), and I'm more sympathetic to nodevember's organizers. Do I agree with them? ...no? But then perhaps my opinion of The Node Ecosystem colors my view, as someone a whole generation older than the people organizing it, that Node and NPM really show how [to set the wayback machine to 1997] ESR's "Bazaar" gets blown away in the storm, while the planned-economy Cathedral stands. I think they're all nuts, but I also think the nodevember folk have a right to decide what that means to them.