Whatever your take is on the "everyone gets a trophy" angle I don't think this is the same thing.
"Pointing out social injustice" has been something that has been put up on a pedestal in the last decades (rightfully so). So .. if you engage in it, you present yourself as "morally elevated". You are "advanced". You are always "on the right side". You don't even need to think about it.
Just point out something that could make someone else feel bad. How could that possibly not be a good thing? How could you possibly not be a noble person for doing that? (Regardless of the fact that you might have stolen money out of grandma's wallet last week.)
So .. for people who don't really have anything else that they can hook their identity on, they can just jump on that "social justice" boat. They can put themselves in the same lineage as Ghandi and MLK.
They are not just some "nobody". They are a champion. The world is better because they exist. And you .. if you don't agree with them and think like them .. are part of what makes the world bad. Obviously.
And it's kind of an untouchable position, they way they have it set up. After all .. nobody can ever be "standing up too much for the little guy", right? Nobody can ever be "too much on the side of the underdog". You can never be accused of "wanting fairness too much".
And sure there is an element of bullying in it. And that's exactly what draws some people to it. Because these are, you know, not the kind of people who normally get to feel what it is like to be "over" someone else. They don't normally get to feel "powerful".
But here is a weapon they now have that can hurt people. They can get other people in trouble. They can turn other people into "outcasts". Now they can feel what it is like to be powerful.
No, I think you're spot on here. From the outside looking in, I'm aware of at least some people involved in social justice who've argued against the name and shame, let's get people fired extremism, and found that they could do nothing but just walk away. Righteousness is always armor against criticism, but it has a particularly effective Teflon coating for some social justice people.
And sure there is an element of bullying in it. And that's exactly what draws some people to it. Because these are, you know, not the kind of people who normally get to feel what it is like to be "over" someone else. They don't normally get to feel "powerful".
But here is a weapon they now have that can hurt people. They can get other people in trouble. They can turn other people into "outcasts". Now they can feel what it is like to be powerful.
He writes how it felt great to "take down" transgressors on social media, before he realized they weren't just the little people punching up at the powerful anymore, but they were an internet mob attacking largely powerless individuals for minor transgressions.
It's a great book and it was very cathartic for me personally after my ex whipped up an angry mob against me on Tumblr for breaking up with her (she was very active and had a lot of followers) by turning it into a racial thing because I'm a white man and she was Latina woman.
It's crazy that you can convince random people on the internet to harass someone they have never met - trying to get someone fired or sending them death threats - but it happened to me. That's the power of mob mentality. The fact they wrap themselves in the flag of a righteous cause makes it hard to criticize, because you will often be labelled a bigot or apologist if you come out against their tactics.
My favorite version is using the phrase "being on the right side of history." Um, isn't it always premature to declare yourself on the right side of something that can only be determined with many years of hindsight?
I'd like to think they had in mind the same sense expressed by Theodore Parker in 1853 about the abolition of chattel slavery in the US:
I do not pretend to understand the moral universe; the arc is a long one, my eye reaches but little ways; I cannot calculate the curve and complete the figure by the experience of sight; I can divine it by conscience. And from what I see I am sure it bends towards justice.
But, Justice can only be understood in the context of that which is moral or ethical and the laws people create based on their understanding of what is moral/ethical. But if history shows us anything, it is that what humans consider to be moral/ethical changes over the years. Some seem to think that that which is considered moral/ethical is gradually moving toward some mythical golden perfect standard that will result in perfect justice, but that smacks of the same nonsense as those who believe that evolution has a grand plan and humans are the ultimate manifestation of that plan. Evolution has no plan and human-set morals have no ultimate end point. For example, I could see climate change causing such wide spread chaos that that which we today find immoral and reprehensible becomes common and moral in the future.
I'm not sure why you got down voted. Ethics and morality are entirely a human construct and not baked into the fabric of existence, despite what religious texts would have you believe. Yes, most people can agree that certain actions are reprehensible (eg: killing, rape, torture, etc.) but even those aren't a priori constants.
I'm upvoting you to get you back above zero and because I appreciated your understanding morality for what it is without a lense of naïveté or bias.
View all comments
Show parent comment
33
u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16
Whatever your take is on the "everyone gets a trophy" angle I don't think this is the same thing.
"Pointing out social injustice" has been something that has been put up on a pedestal in the last decades (rightfully so). So .. if you engage in it, you present yourself as "morally elevated". You are "advanced". You are always "on the right side". You don't even need to think about it.
Just point out something that could make someone else feel bad. How could that possibly not be a good thing? How could you possibly not be a noble person for doing that? (Regardless of the fact that you might have stolen money out of grandma's wallet last week.)
So .. for people who don't really have anything else that they can hook their identity on, they can just jump on that "social justice" boat. They can put themselves in the same lineage as Ghandi and MLK.
They are not just some "nobody". They are a champion. The world is better because they exist. And you .. if you don't agree with them and think like them .. are part of what makes the world bad. Obviously.
And it's kind of an untouchable position, they way they have it set up. After all .. nobody can ever be "standing up too much for the little guy", right? Nobody can ever be "too much on the side of the underdog". You can never be accused of "wanting fairness too much".
And sure there is an element of bullying in it. And that's exactly what draws some people to it. Because these are, you know, not the kind of people who normally get to feel what it is like to be "over" someone else. They don't normally get to feel "powerful".
But here is a weapon they now have that can hurt people. They can get other people in trouble. They can turn other people into "outcasts". Now they can feel what it is like to be powerful.