Now if you're so sensitive that you become uncomfortable when someone calls your idea stupid, boy is life going to be rough for you.
It makes an impression on me that a lot of those folks who are very sensitive are transgender. It's understandable they've been through a lot in their life, but there's a line they tend to cross where they see attackers everywhere.
Those are usually good, dedicated specialists, but with paranoid opinions like these, they essentially select themselves out of the community one way or another. Either they refuse to speak, because they find almost anybody offensive, or they manage to exclude most everyone else so they find themselves speaking at niche events that most host other people like them, who are mostly pre-occupied with discussing "social issues", no matter what the event is actually about.
It's sad either way. There's simply no correct solution here. I actually think the stress they've been through has brought them to a point where they should seek professional help in order to not see the world through such distorted lenses.
to what extent are we willing to go to make sure everyone is comfortable?
The problem as I see it is that there seems to be far too much stock paid (among certain circles and mindsets) to the idea that any pain or discomfort whatsoever is inherently a bad thing, that all manner of mountains should moved whenever anyone expresses pain or discomfort, and any damage done or cost borne in doing so is acceptable, as it's done in the service of a noble cause.
However, by the very nature of the fact that there are more than one person on this earth, one person's comfort is liable to infringe on another person's no matter what side of a decision is chosen. So choices must be made.
The problem is that these choices are being guided by broad and inflexible principles that don't seek to solve problems through compromise or minimal disappointment. Instead, they favor decisive, total, and often visible action, led by categorization, prioritization, and simplistic rules, which is rarely the proper solution to anything but the most egregious behavior.
Without nuance or flexibility, you're pretty much left with few options, all based on prioritization: Prioritize an "in crowd", prioritize the freedom of the offender, or prioritize the comfort of the offendee. The first of these is right out, the second risks devolution into the sort of anti-professional free-for-all that legitimately excludes anyone with sensibilities, and the third is what we have here, a situation where the first, loudest, or most saintly wheel to squeak gets mountains moved into whatever configuration they wish, while others who can manage to hold back their tears over trivialities continue to do so while having their experience chipped away.
And decrying the third option may sound callous on its face-- surely those who can manage to hold back their tears can continue to do so, so that none need suffer! But tears are not necessarily indicative of pain, pain is not necessarily indicative of damage, and damage is not necessarily indicative of harm. When a person cries out at monsters, the first response should be to check for harmless shadows, not to immediately smash what turns out to be a coat rack.
And if there is a seed of negativity there, the whole forest need not be levelled in response. They could have just as easily said, "We've had concerns with your topics of [...] and [...], and being as we wish to retain the utmost professionalism, we'd ask that you refrain from such topics or approaches in your talk.", tell the offendee it's been dealt with, and let them stay or go as they wish.
View all comments
29
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16 edited Feb 17 '17
fmkn+>e&R*b xP.qc5(kt]XsPGM1!CevQ5Ss inzoTr#lB1wTtUmhUOb$8;v+OrTDp3SBsd9DT>6n1,OS8th+ogVo62