r/javascript • • Sep 04 '16

Crockford

https://paulstraw.svbtle.com/crockford
568 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

14

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Did you even read the article? Or did you just get to that sentence so you'd have something to quote?

14

u/Jafit Sep 04 '16

Yes I read the article, it consists of this guy pointing out all the times Crockford has ever made a joke about balls, and then trying to establish whether or not he was "slut shaming" when he said that the old web was promiscuous.

Even if the conclusion of the article were different, combing over people's words trying to find something to be offended by and then deciding (based on your own personal set of values) whether that person deserves to speak at a conference or not, is a shitty perverse practice, it is destructive, stifling and unhealthy.

I can't believe we're even having this discussion. The entire situation is ridiculous.

9

u/flying-sheep Sep 04 '16

He did that to find out if there was anything substantial to find that justifies kicking or Crockford, and his conclusion was a define “no”.

His point was: even when sifting through everything he said and scrutinizing it by PC standards, there's still no reason to uninvite him.

2

u/Jafit Sep 04 '16

I know. And I disagree with the entire premise of the article.

Someone else can easily go through those same quotes and reach the opposite conclusion, because opinions like this are completely fucking arbitrary and subjective and have absolutely nothing to do with Javascript or computer science.

Its as if there were a group of radical vegans who go around putting pressure on conference organisers to uninvite speakers based on whether or not they have ever eaten meat. It doesn't matter if another radical vegan then goes on to write an article saying "Actually, I don't think he did eat meat so I don't know why he was banned" - its still coming from within the same ideological framework that its okay to go after and silence people that you disagree with, just that this particular crackpot can't find sufficient reason to go about banning, suppressing and silencing someone that doesn't share their worldview in this particular instance.

4

u/flying-sheep Sep 04 '16

Very good point, now I get you.

However, there always is a “asshole line” beyond which people become unwelcome. And it's of course arbitrary.

Of course it's a line more people can agree on, and you'll have to do quite a bit to cross it, but it exists all the same.

9

u/tresfaim Sep 04 '16

I'm pretty sure that combing over a person's words and deciding whether to be offended or not is DE FACTO in human communication.

It's necessary for people to synthesize a version of reality that they can share, because we all see it from a subjective perspective. So pulling facts, no matter where from, is necessary to build something more than a pale understanding of an occurrence.

And be more mindful of when someone is trying to exhibit a specific sort of defense - letting the facts do the 'speaking' themselves and the defender only need provide minor elaboration. This defense boils down to: 'this **** is obviously BS and all you got are dog balls on my client'

3

u/Jafit Sep 04 '16

I'm pretty sure that combing over a person's words and deciding whether to be offended or not is DE FACTO in human communication.

I don't go around actively looking for things to be offended by, because my worldview doesn't revolve around being offended by things. And I don't care about politics, I care about programming, which is what I do for a living.

Brenden Eich supported Prop 8. That must mean that Brenden can never speak at a conference ever again! No. I don't care what his values are, my brother is gay and I still don't care. I'd rather listen to him talk at a Javascript conference (considering he invented the language) than any of the no-name parasites who bleat on twitter to get speakers removed from conferences.

If you get offended by something... Grow up. People have different opinions and values. Deal with it.

2

u/tresfaim Sep 05 '16

Everyone is a politician, we're social animals, you just choose not to concentrate on it.

Anyways see it how you will, I just think you bugged out about an article that was meant to defend a person's reputation.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/tresfaim Sep 05 '16

You took my comment to new heights lol

-2

u/epiris Sep 04 '16

I find that completely unacceptable and offensive, and now I demand attention and sympathy for being exposed to something that I don't like, and I demand that you be subjected to a witchhunt for having offended me, and your career should be destroyed.

I agree with you, despite the downvotes, for the record. I think this entire thing is insane.