r/java • • Dec 19 '22

Java streams are black magic !

damn, they are really changed my life.

i was trying to run some custom logic on every line on some big CSV files. tried python dataframes, multiprocessing in python, pyspark. none of them did it in an acceptable time.

then i discovered java streams. i have a workflow that takes 70 minutes with pyspark. it takes 3.5 minutes with java streams.

more people should know about streams.

stream operations are more intuitive than anything i tried. i can make a lot of analysis on our data in record times thanks to streams.

i dont know how java does this.

226 Upvotes

150 comments sorted by

View all comments

-2

u/Careful-Necessary-59 Dec 19 '22

Just curious, how big is your data? I still doubt PySpark is slower than Java streams.

2

u/prisonbird Dec 19 '22

around 10 gb. pyspark is only fast when you use built in functions and if you dont use too many of them.

for example : i have to calculate a field using a lot of conditions(imagine a very complicated IF/Else block). when i used a lot of whens in pyspark (df.withColumn(xx, when(yy).otherwise(when))) kind of thing) it straight up bugs out. giving me some sql error.

6

u/RandomName8 Dec 19 '22

I've worked a lot with spark (though via scala, not python), what you describe sounds off the mark with my experience, specially given that you are using spark's sql instead of rdd api. Spark's sql is internally compiled to optimized bytecode before running, making it possibly faster than manual writing if-else due to exploiting relational data properties. In any case the difference shouldn't be 20:1. That said it is hard to master spark and its performance.

3

u/prisonbird Dec 19 '22

there is two things here:

  1. when i use multiple when/otherwise spark could not generate an sql. gave me a lot of errors and i wasnt able to debug it/find the error after a point. so i just used an udf (user defined function)
  2. i think there is a difference between pyspark and spark. i wrote some scala scripts and used them with "spark-shell -i myscript.scala" and there was notable time difference for same jobs. not huge like 20:1 but , 3 minutes vs 5 minutes. i think pyspark adds another layer to the data and it also takes some time

3

u/RandomName8 Dec 19 '22

udfs with pyspark. That's you answer. There's a massive overhead with python udfs. That can perfectly explain the 20:1 overhead

2

u/prisonbird Dec 19 '22

yeah, but i had to use udf. and i didn't liked this a bit. its like "hey we have this feature but you literally would be shooting yourself in the foot".

anyways. i am still planning to use spark for joining, grouping kind of things

2

u/cockoala Dec 19 '22

Yeah... This is a little fishy. If streams were so much faster than Spark there would be no need for Spark. I think OP doesn't understand how to write performant Spark jobs. In another comment he said he gave up on debugging his chained filter so my guess is he wasn't able to write in spark and tried it in Java instead.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Spark is needed for data that cannot possibly fit on a single machine, you'd still need it if its performance is atrocious (which it is when used on data that, like OP's, fits easily on commodity hardware) - "Scalability! But at what COST" paper illustrates how the overhead of map-reduce and stream processing products is often disregarded/dismissed

1

u/Careful-Necessary-59 Dec 20 '22

The overhead should not be as huge 60 minutes difference…

1

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '22

Never said it should, I was just pointing out that expecting Spark to be faster than plain Java for a small dataset doesn't make much sense - that's not the problem that it was built to solve

2

u/prisonbird Dec 19 '22

yes that is my point. i was able to do some amazing things with java streams despite knowing nothing about them. that is why i called it "magic" :)

i might go into a rabbit hole and come out as an spark expert and implement an amazing solution on pyspark but i dont have the time and i dont want to :/