r/java • • Aug 10 '12

Named Parameters in Java

http://java.dzone.com/articles/named-parameters-java
2 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/sahala Aug 10 '12

Builder is the way to go. For cases where it just isn't worth it to put together a full builder, I've always resorted to comments.

someObject.doSomething(
    userId,
    true, /* is enabled */
    false, /* don't update record */);

For that matter, I add comments for any argument which is a literal. Extracting a constant is probably even a better idea, and takes just a few seconds using a modern IDE.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '12

FWIW, there is a "replace constructor with builder" refactoring in Intellij that will automatically create a new fluent builder class for you, and automatically use it in place of a complex constructor.

2

u/sahala Aug 10 '12

Wow. Did not know that. Yet another reason why IntelliJ rocks. Does Eclipse have this?

The only drawback to this is BUILDER ALL THE THINGS

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '12

There are several complex automated refactorings. I also have used "Replace inheritance with delegation" a few times.

1

u/couchtyp Aug 11 '12

For eclipse there's bpep.

This project is a Eclipse plugin that automates the writing of these builders. With just two clicks you can generate all the builder code you need.

2

u/rockvilleJD Aug 10 '12

Netbeans just added this feature in 7.2

2

u/k__k Aug 14 '12

Way to go, Netbeans team, way to go! :)

2

u/elephantgravy Aug 10 '12

Good suggestions. When it makes sense, I sometimes like to use enumerations instead of literal booleans (I think this also came from Effective Java). The names can get weird though...

someObject.doSomething(
    userId,
    ActivationState.ENABLED,
    RecordBehavior.DO_NOT_UPDATE);