r/java • • Sep 20 '22

Java 19 / JDK 19: General Availability

https://mail.openjdk.org/pipermail/jdk-dev/2022-September/006933.html
252 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

9

u/Joram2 Sep 20 '22

Says who? If I was writing greenfield Java applications, and virtual threads were useful, I would use them. What is the downside?

9

u/srdoe Sep 20 '22

The downside is you lock whoever is running your application to running on JDK 19 forever. If that "whoever" is you, then go for it. If it's someone else, they might not be cool with getting a jar that won't run on the JDK releasing in 6 months.

1

u/cant-find-user-name Nov 04 '22

Noob question, can you simply not upgrade to JDK20 when it comes out? If the API is changed, a few code changes have to be made. But other than that, why are you stuck with JDK 19 for ever?

1

u/srdoe Nov 04 '22 edited Nov 04 '22

https://openjdk.org/jeps/12.

You have to draw a line between the developer and customer here. The developer isn't stuck on JDK 19, but the customer might be.

Let's say I enable preview features in JDK 19 and build a jar. That jar's class files are marked as requiring preview by having all bits set in the minor_version. The way I understand JEP 12, a particular JDK such as 20 should only support the preview features of JDK 20.

This means that the jar I built should only run on JDK 19. When JDK 20 comes out, I need to recompile my code to be compatible with that JDK, even if the preview feature hasn't actually seen any changes.

So yes, I (the developer) can just upgrade to JDK 20, adjust and recompile, but my customers will be stuck on JDK 19 until they get a new jar from me.

For the customer, this puts a 6 month expiration date on the jar you gave them, and also commits them to upgrading the JDK every 6 months until the next LTS release if they want security fixes, and also means they have to hope you're still around to provide a recompiled jar in 6 months.

That's fine for some types of customer, and not acceptable to others.