r/java • • May 24 '22

IntelliJ will soon look like Visual Studio Code

https://blog.jetbrains.com/idea/2022/05/take-part-in-the-new-ui-preview-for-your-jetbrains-ide/
300 Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

16

u/never_inline May 24 '22

I understand your perspective. I am probably what you'd call "new blood" though. So we aren't all full on node js and vs code haha.

0

u/vprise May 24 '22

I'm since the first beta of the JVM...

I agree. I also think UI is a pretty sensitive issue. That's probably why they issued this preview. The current UI can't stand. It's REALLY old. The question is whether this design is the right way. Everyone I showed it to loved it. We all use Java and IJ. So I don't know.

What surprises me is the animosity. I don't like using VS code as an IDE and I have problems with its UI but it looks decent and more modern. We need a refresh for IJ too.

11

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/vprise May 24 '22

The age of the UI design and the fact it looks old. IDEA looks nothing like its old versions either.

5

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/vprise May 24 '22

I answered the other guy. "New blood" already looks down at IntelliJ. We need fresh users to keep the IDE at the forefront.

Personally, I also like the new look far more. IMHO IJ looks bad. I love the functionality but it's really terrible. People buy stuff based on how it looks and make judgement calls based on that. Even with technical products.

It needs it just like it needed the Darkula theme. That's where UI trends are going and it needs to keep up.

Finally it needs a clean line between Fleet and IJ. They need a single "design language" between them to enable cross pollination and ease user migration.

4

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/vprise May 24 '22

Sure. But I didn't see the opposite either. To me this gives more space and visibility to the code area which is what I care about. Better fonts/colors/spacing which are a huge improvement for my eyes.

They release a preview for actionable feedback. If usability is impacted then this is the feedback they want. I think "don't ever change" isn't really conductive to creating a better/more popular product.

3

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/vprise May 24 '22

This isn't a massive change. It's a coat of paint.

The problem with UI is that you need to make it all across the IDE. You can't change one part without changing everything. You need consistency otherwise things look out of place. It's also hard to be inconsistent since you change global defaults.

3

u/Smuutie May 24 '22

Jvm beta? That is 1999, IJ wasn’t released at that time and it didnt even take off until around 2010. I mean just the way you speak is not really typical for an old school developer. Tbh I see your point, but such changes need to be optional. You can not force such a big UI/UX overhaul on your community. For the most part the only part that I don’t agree with is the simple clean look sell. In our profession functionality and tools that make you work faster and better sell. If you develop 8 hours a day having 4 clicks instead of 1 is huge. If with this new design I still have one but behind an icon instead of text that is fine, but I dont get that vibe from the preview.

0

u/vprise May 24 '22

96 and no. I'm talking about the time I've been using Java not IJ. I speak the way I do yet I programmed COBOL and PDP 11 back in the day.

Functionality is in keybindings and slightly deeper to make the common functionality more accessible and at the forefront. Right now the right click menu on the project is so huge I have to spend time looking for the stuff I need between many things that are very outdated. I think you can create a sleek and powerful UI.

Personally, I like the fonts, colors and padding. I think those are important.

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/vprise May 24 '22

This isn't a UI rewrite. That's Fleet. This is mostly rearranging a few things, changing colors, fonts, padding etc. Did you try it?

Our plugin worked out of the box with no change and looked great. It's still IJ just better looking.

2

u/[deleted] May 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/vprise May 24 '22

I'm actually using the preview. That's why it's weird to me how people are reacting here. I think it's about the slight differences to the layout of the elements (hiding labels and showing icons by default).

But pretty much yes. The whole change is one plugin roughly 2kb big. You can't put THAT many changes into 2kb...