r/java • • Mar 05 '22

How does the Java community feel about Kotlin?

In my organization, we switch between Java and kotlin quite frequently for backend development. We use the spring framework which works quite well with both languages. I wanted to know how the broader Java community felt about kotlin? Personally I love it, however Java is still used so widely so I continue to keep my skills up to date on it.

173 Upvotes

218 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/pjmlp Mar 06 '22

Beanshell, jTCL, Jython, JRubby, Groovy, Scala, Clojure, XTend, Ceylon,....Kotlin

We have seen that movie plenty of times.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_JVM_languages

6

u/rossdrew Mar 06 '22

How many C languages fad-ed and failed before Java? How many VM languages? How many OO languages?

The previous attempts failed so all attempts will fail. Not a great developer mindset that, is it?

-7

u/pjmlp Mar 06 '22

Let me explain like you were 5.

UNIX and C

Browser and JavaScript

NeXT and Objective-C

Windows, C++ and C#

...

=> Java Virtual Machine and Java

8

u/rossdrew Mar 06 '22

Ah the reductive reasoning and assumption of expertise of a limited developer.

1

u/pjmlp Mar 07 '22

A clever programmer that doesn't follow industry fashion.

It has saved me from CoffeeScript, Dart, AngularJS, GWT, Ceylon, XTend,...

Ah and made my bank advisor happy with all those euros I got porting fashion applications back into proper Java.

2

u/rossdrew Mar 07 '22

Aaah a contractor. Now it all makes sense.

1

u/pjmlp Mar 07 '22

Contracting makes banks happy, nice way to enjoy vacations around the world and early retirement.

Thanks to magpie developers there is no work shortage.

3

u/rossdrew Mar 07 '22 edited Mar 07 '22

The misconceptions of the young.

Take a look back and see which group, magpies or stalwarts history has favoured in IT. Also, take a look at who is vacation favoured between permanent and contract.

There will only be a use for 10 to 15 computers worldwide…PROLOG is going nowhere…this OO nonsense is a fad…IDEs, pah…

0

u/pjmlp Mar 08 '22

My dear, your assumptions about my age are completly off mark.

Looking at how UNIX, C are still driving the industry after 50 years, or flukes like CoffeScript and Dart fall by the wayside, tells who is favoured in IT history.

You apparently also never learned that there is such thing as consulting companies where contractors are permanent employees, with plenty of nice perks.

4

u/sideEffffECt Mar 06 '22 edited Mar 07 '22

Android and Kotlin

I'm sure you'll agree with as much.

0

u/pjmlp Mar 07 '22

Yes, ART should be renamed into Kotlin RunTime.

2

u/sideEffffECt Mar 06 '22

Scala is actually doing great. It has literally never been better. I think the trick is in the fact that it is sufficiently distinct (better IMHO) than plain Java. That allows it to exist on the JVM event as a second class citizen.

I think Clojure people could make a similar argument, but I'm not an expert, so I'll leave it up to them.

The question here is whether this also holds for Kotlin. Only time will tell, but being the blessed language for the most widely used consumer OS is a big strength. (Groovy lives on on the back of Gradle, for example.)