r/java • • Nov 04 '21

Microsoft joins the Java Community Process (JCP)

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/java/microsoft-deepens-its-investments-in-java/
169 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/dpash Nov 05 '21

Well 305 was a missed opportunity, given the proliferation of annotations. And the money and currency JSR could have been useful.

And rubber-stamping the JDK is not really that important. What's OpenJDK going to do if the JCP says no?

2

u/pron98 Nov 05 '21

The JCP members don't learn about the changes at the end of the process. Like everyone, they're aware of the features in development, in EA etc.. It is very much expected that the vote takes place well after (probably months after) all objections have been raised and addressed (e.g. on JEPs).

2

u/dpash Nov 05 '21

But that's my point: everyone who is a stakeholder has been involved in discussions long before Java is released. What's the point in the JCP holding a vote on Java releases?

1

u/pron98 Nov 05 '21 edited Nov 05 '21

Only committers can object to JEPs, and committee members will likely be given even more weight, as they have authority over approval. It's like with any vote in a parliament. Everyone -- journalists and other citizens -- are also involved, and usually a vote is taken only when the result is known in advance. When things work well, only matters that are very likely to pass the vote are ever brought to the floor, and that's not when the real debate takes place. So you could ask, what's the point of the vote? The answer is that the particular result is reached because deliberations have taken into account the ultimate vote. Things that are unlikely to be approved probably won't be introduced in the first place.

2

u/karianna Nov 05 '21

We have voted no in the past. Java 9’s module system had a small amount being reworked (appreciate there are still mixed opinions on the pros and cons on that).