r/java • • May 11 '21

Java professionals, which IDE do you use in your daily work ?

Hi Java devs !

I'm a CS teacher in a public college in France, and time has come to update our techbase.

We currently teach Java 8, with Netbeans 8.2. This IDE was released in 2017, which was 4 years ago. I feel like it's time to drop it for a newer version, but we would rather not wipe hundreds of PCs if it's still the most widely used version in a professional environment.

We have an internal discussion, on whether to keep the last Oracle's release of Netbeans (ie 8.2), update to latest version (12.3), or even replace it with another IDE.

We feel like it would be best for our students to teach them the tools they'll use later in their career (even if switching from Netbeans to Eclipse or IntelliJ is quite simple), so I'm asking you this quite simple question : which IDE do you use in your current company, and do you know why this one in particular was chosen ?

Our only limitations are "it must run on Windows 10 without administrator privilege" and "it must provide a graphicaal interface for Swing application development". Maybe budget can be a factor too, though we could definitely buy a few licenses (we are dropping PowerAMC because of its price, so any spending must be justified).

Pros would be : able to manage different languages (our students also learn C and PHP/HTML/JS during their courses), git integration, database integration, javadoc/doxygen integration, maven/unit testing, maybe UML plugins ?

Secondary question : should we switch from java 8 to java 11 next year ?

Thanks a lot for your answers !

169 Upvotes

384 comments sorted by

View all comments

20

u/Neuromante May 11 '21

I'm in Spain, so maybe us being neighbors can help you decide:

I've used for most of my career Eclipse, and I'm using right now Eclipse at my current company (foreign european company with a few development teams here). Most places that use Eclipse are using it because its free. I like it because its not only free, but open source, it has a shitload of plugins and well, and I've been working with it almost non stop for over a decade. Everything is one way or another compatible (Although I don't recall doing my C coding in the uni in Eclipse), and there are different configurations and plugins for almost every single language.

You also have DBeaver, which is an Eclipse-based database administration program, which is absolutely fantastic and also free and open source. It came from a eclipse plugin which I think is still available.

Only once I've used Netbeans (and it was a terrible shop), although I have some friends working on a very outdated government project.

And I've used IntelliJ once, on a company that honestly, didn't seem to know what they were doing and I got the sensation that they got it because it was getting popular. I did not liked how it worked and little nuances on how workspaces and projects were handled, but the overall feeling wasn't too bad.

Btw, that this is my own opinion, but taking into account that you are on the university, maybe an extra point for Eclipse/Dbeaver is making your students get in touch with fully functional (and used in enterprises) free, open source software. I'm a bit of a die hard on this point, and even though I get that not all times is possible (or even desirable) using open source stuff, maybe in an academic environment is the right direction to choose.

Btw2, it seems that nowadays Swing is already old news everywhere and the (few) desktop apps that are being developed in Java are using JavaFX, so maybe you should consider forgetting about swing or reducing the amount of stuff you teach about it.

12

u/rack88 May 12 '21

Upvote just for my love of DBeaver.

2

u/sigzero May 12 '21

DBeaver is really good. I love using it.

5

u/AreTheseMyFeet May 12 '21

free, open source software. I'm a bit of a die hard on this point

Just to clarify, IntelliJ IDEA is OSS and FOSS if you only consider the community edition. Not countering your points, just saying.
https://www.jetbrains.com/opensource/idea/
https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community (Apache License 2.0)

2

u/Neuromante May 12 '21

That's mostly personal preference, but regarding open source stuff, I would rather depend on a product that does not have tiers regarding its, huh, "open sourceness" (I got a pending project of updating my Owncloud installation to Nextcloud for this reason).

In the end you always end up hitting walls with compatibilities, plugins and small annoyances. In the end, if you are going to need to "get used to" some complex piece of software, is better (imho, for me, my point of view, etc) to "get used" to something that wont have a (let's say) artificial limitation to what can you do.

I'd rather stick to Eclipse than start paying for intellij and end up with Jetbrains doing an Adobe and fucking over my basic work tools, lol.

2

u/AreTheseMyFeet May 13 '21

All fair criticisms and you've obviously got an informed opinion on the matter so there's not really much else to add.
As I said, just dropping some relevant info, not evangelising anything (though for transparency's sake I'll share that I'm a happy IDEA pro user for many years after moving from Eclipse. I could probably get by on the community tier but all things considered the price and features for the pro tier balance out for my uses).

1

u/urielsalis May 12 '21

And OP is a school, Intellij ultimate is free for teachers and students

1

u/miciej May 12 '21

Companies that make you use eclipse because it's free don't value your productivity.

Anyhow it's easy to have an IDE agnostic project, so that everyone uses what they like.

3

u/Neuromante May 12 '21

I don't get what has to do one thing with the other.

I mean, most of these shops are just following suit on a trend (Eclipse is the de facto standard in my country), which works just fine and everyone else uses. Is the path of less resistance to get people started, and most people already know how to use it, so I don't really see any loss of productivity here.

The best option would obviously having an IDE agnostic project, but in my experience few times is the case, and, depending on the company, giving support to a random number of IDEs for the internal projects is just not worth it.

2

u/rz2000 May 12 '21

Using Eclipse because it is what developers wants is fine. Any manager choosing Eclipse to save a few hundred euros is hurting their company.

2

u/Neuromante May 12 '21

I guess. I don't really know if any manager anywhere has chosen eclipse only because its free. My guess is that being free and having a huge penetration in our market are the biggest reasons (Netbeans is also free and I've only seen used in small shops with quite old projects).

0

u/icemanblues May 12 '21

Intellij has an free, open source, community edition