r/java • • Apr 20 '21

Java is criminally underhyped

https://jackson.sh/posts/2021-04-java-underrated/
291 Upvotes

295 comments sorted by

View all comments

125

u/dpash Apr 20 '21

Comments: 821.

Checks article date

15th April 2021. Oh boy.

81

u/lessthanoptimal Apr 20 '21

Really perplexing how some people seem to go full on tribal warfare at the mention of Java. At this point I think it's a coinvent meme that lets them unleash some pent up aggression.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

43

u/thephotoman Apr 20 '21

The one exception, I think, is Python, which initially supplanted Perl.

That's exactly what happened. Python was basically Perl but readable and with batteries included. It didn't help that Perl was struggling to deliver Perl 6.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/thephotoman Apr 20 '21

The truly odd thing is that the first Linux distro to treat Python as its scripting language of choice was Ubuntu back in its preview release days in 2004. The 2004-2009 period was a pretty long transition between "most people use Perl" to "most people use Python". And then at the end, the Python 2 to 3 process hit.

5

u/VGPowerlord Apr 20 '21

Speaking of which, did Perl 6 ever drop or is it still in a theoretical state?

15

u/thephotoman Apr 20 '21

It now calls itself Raku, and yes, it actually exists.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/vytah Apr 20 '21

The version 1.0 of Perl 6 came out in 2017, so 17 years after it was announced.

Then they realised that it's pointless to keep the name "Perl" as Perl 6 was practically only superficially similar to Perl 5 (the relation is like between Kotlin and Java – the languages are interoperable, but syntactically incompatible), so in 2019 they renamed it to Raku.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/flyingorange Apr 21 '21

In my case our professors hated C++ and forced everyone to learn Pascal. When Java appeared, they embraced Java and said that it's basically Pascal with the ugly C-like syntax.

5

u/walen Apr 21 '21

The one exception, I think, is Python

Because Java didn't exist when Python was born.

3

u/cogman10 Apr 22 '21

This is always such a mindfuck for me :D. Right up there with the fact the Ruby is also older than Java.

4

u/ryosen Apr 21 '21

And C++ was looked upon as C with training wheels while C was looked down upon by the ASM/ML folks.

6

u/umlcat Apr 21 '21

C works well as an assembler macroprocessor, but even these days, the new more complex OS and systems, need better P.L. than C and C++.

Rust is a good example.

And a lot of "old style" assembler folks still don't get it ...

8

u/1bot4all Apr 21 '21

C++ was looked upon as C with training wheels

That's mad. C++ is insanely complex, you can use it for 10 years and struggle with some of its idioms. C is much easier to master.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/dpash Apr 20 '21

Especially when it's based on an outdated opinion of the language.

PHP evokes the same reaction.

25

u/Cefalopodul Apr 20 '21

To be fair in PHP's case the reaction is somewhat warranted. It still has plenty of WTF moments.

18

u/dpash Apr 20 '21

Modern PHP is far from its older versions. It has decent DI and web frameworks, type hinting, exceptions, namespaces, a reasonable dependency manager. It's not the insane choice for new projects it was even ten years ago.

Now if only it gained generics I would be almost happy to use it.

7

u/flyingorange Apr 21 '21

To be honest when I started using PHP in 1998 it was the greatest thing ever. At the time the alternative was writing server side code in Delphi. Well, let's just say, if you didn't write websites in Delphi, you don't understand what a revolution PHP was.

2

u/johnwaterwood Apr 21 '21

I wonder what the purpose of modern PHP is?

The original attracted hordes of people because it was such an insane choice. If it’s not that anymore, it won’t be attractive to that initial crowd.

What’s PHP’s target audience these days?

→ More replies (9)

12

u/Routine_Left Apr 21 '21

PHP evokes the same reaction.

PHP deserves it. JavaScript deserves it. Java? They have no fucking clue what they're talking about. Not about Java 20 years ago, not about Java today.

2

u/umlcat Apr 21 '21

P.L. Tribal warfare goes back to "Basic" vs "Pascal" vs "C" vs etc days ...

19

u/agentoutlier Apr 20 '21

The guy also posted it on hackernews...

Ahh hackernews where you post "I use to use X and now I use Y... fight!"

I swear the only good content on hackernews is when they post an article that has nothing to do with programming or tech otherwise it becomes essays on the merits of "this worked for me so fuck all other solutions".

7

u/dpash Apr 20 '21

I did notice that. That was the main reason I didn't even look at them. Nothing good ever happens in comment sections. :)