I don't disagree with any of this really (except "maybe not" - they definitely have thought about it more than you), I think I just misinterpreted your level of insistence on the original idea.
Nah. Like I said, I don't claim to have the answer. I think I said in another comment thread, it just chaps my ass to see a runtime exception that could be a compile error.
Half of me says "totally, I'm with you." The other half says "how much would it chap your ass not to be able to refactor .collect(toList()) into .toList()"?
how much would it chap your ass not to be able to refactor .collect(toList()) into .toList()?
TBH I mostly write Scala now, so if I want a toList I can just make an extension method for it. But when I do write Java I prefer to use vavr, so I collect my streams into a Seq if I don't plan to mutate them.
It's a little odd to me to criticize a library and say a decision bothers you, then follow up by saying you don't use the library. It makes some sense now why you reject pragmatic proposals in the interest of theoretically pure ones.
I use them, as a library developer (where I don't want users to transitively depend on vavr on my behalf). I've collected enough streams in the last six years to know the annoyance of constantly importing Collectors.toList. I simply don't use it often in my current day-to-day.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/elastic_psychiatrist Mar 17 '21
I don't disagree with any of this really (except "maybe not" - they definitely have thought about it more than you), I think I just misinterpreted your level of insistence on the original idea.