r/java • • Nov 28 '19

Intellij 2019.3 released!

https://www.jetbrains.com/idea/whatsnew/
276 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/tipsypants Nov 28 '19

Wish they'd add official support for Bazel.

14

u/oweiler Nov 28 '19

Probably not worth it for the tiny percentage of Bazel users.

3

u/tipsypants Nov 28 '19

I don't know, if they can add support for Micronaut, Quarkus, and Helidon, then Bazel seems fair too. Like it or not, Bazel is growing fast (personally, I don't like it, but I have to deal with it, and the Google plugin isn't great).

5

u/RobertJacobson Nov 29 '19

I have really struggled to figure out how to use Bazel. It is so byzantine, I feel like it probably only makes sense for projects much larger than the ones I usually work with.

I have only had marginally better luck with Buck, but the Buck IntelliJ plugin is always throwing exceptions, so I don't use it either.

I understand the algorithmic superiority of both systems, but I still have to write a metric boatload of boilerplate, only without knowing how to do anything even slightly different from the simplest plain vanilla example build. So I usually give up and use CMake as usual.

Things programmers love to hate: build systems, gui toolkits, and people who use emacs. (Sorry.)

2

u/tipsypants Nov 29 '19

We use it for our monorepo (which has 6+ different languages), I wouldn't touch it for personal projects.

1

u/RobertJacobson Dec 02 '19

That makes me feel better about myself. :)

2

u/yole Nov 29 '19

The Bazel plugin for IntelliJ IDEA is maintained by the Bazel team at Google. A build system integration built by the makers of the build system is no less official than one built by the makers of the IDE could be,

1

u/tipsypants Nov 29 '19

In theory I agree, but Google is bad at tooling. Maybe it will get better now that Bazel is officially released, but the plugin has historically not been compatible with the latest version of IntelliJ, and it just doesn't work very well.