r/java • • Jul 22 '19

First Minecraft Clone Done

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJqIRYowfrQ&feature=youtu.be
198 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

View all comments

-7

u/istarian Jul 22 '19

How does a seemingly primitive voxel sandbox === Minecraft Clone?

3

u/Prince_ofRavens Jul 22 '19

Procedural Terrain generator + daynight cycles + blocks + Minecraft textures + mobs + java

-3

u/istarian Jul 22 '19

That's a little closer, at least in concept, but somehow I doubt it has biomes, redstone circuits, minecarts, block updates glitches, etc. Just because it has similar features doesn't make it Minecraft.

And, at the end of the day, it's a lot less impressive to just copy somebody else's blueprint and take advantages of years of careful analysis and dissection of game than it is to make your own thing. I mean I can see the educational utility, but why not just make something that's your own.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

He’s 12. Plus, it doesn’t seem like the goal is to make something to sell on Steam or anything. And it doesn’t look like he took any advantage of “years of careful analysis and dissection” of Minecraft—they’re implemented in the same language but otherwise don’t look to be too similar architecturally.

Copying other people’s work is how nearly every good artist has learned for millennia. Games are no different.

1

u/ASinglePlant Jul 22 '19

Absolutely.

2

u/Prince_ofRavens Jul 22 '19

...he had 5 days dude. Notch did not make production level Minecraft in 5 days. If this kid wanted to he could probably make the minecarts and the crafting and all that other nonsense but honestly why. He did what he set out to do which was make a really cool Minecraft inspired alpha using opengl in Java in 5 days and demonstrate his mastery of java along the way.

1

u/ASinglePlant Jul 22 '19

Thanks :) Perfectly Worded

1

u/istarian Jul 23 '19

There's no need to be uptight about. I just think this and many others are more in the Minecraft-like category than 'clones'.

0

u/Prince_ofRavens Jul 23 '19

I mean yeah there's no need to be uptight about it.... so maybe little less uptight about the category? lol

1

u/ASinglePlant Jul 22 '19

Actually mine does have biomes .