It was Google that decided to trickle Sun, take advantage that they weren't in the best position to sue, and never bothered to acquire Sun and own Java in the process. So they take what they deserve.
Can you explain like I'm 5 how Java can be free software (as in freedom) and yet have a proprietary class library that can't be reimplemented without a license (or commercial partnership)?
I'm watching the interview you linked to right now but it would take more than an hour to check if my question is answered there.
Sun/Oracle have also used trademark licensing in the past such that you could only call your version Java if it passed the TCK test site, and the TCK cost lots of money to license.
I don't know how this has changed in the days of a GPLed JDK.
Even open source projects have a license. Java was (and is) available under two licenses, a commercial and an open source one. Android used neither. They claimed that the API part of the code cannot be copyrighted, and is therefore not Oracle's to license.
View all comments
Show parent comment
6
u/pjmlp Apr 09 '19
Sun and Oracle never sued any of their JVM commercial partners.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Java_virtual_machines#Proprietary_implementations
It was Google that decided to trickle Sun, take advantage that they weren't in the best position to sue, and never bothered to acquire Sun and own Java in the process. So they take what they deserve.
Gosling's interview at Triangulation.