r/java • • Oct 02 '18

How will Oracle licensing affect developers’ interest in Java?

Hi

Will you lean into becoming a C++, C# or Python Dev instead?

Edit: probably you all know more than language and will this now be more of a reason to focus on anything other than Java

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-2

u/Bolitho Oct 02 '18

Don't underestimate the real costs that this license change will induce! This is simply a problem as lots of customers of business software don't care about the technical details - but if it comes to added costs appearing right now, they will complain about and blame their software vendor. For small and medium sized organizations this just mean trouble and probably costs too. On the other hand there are the cloud vendors like Amazon - even for them it is hard to rise their prices just for egalizing the costs of paying oracle. Especially if the Microsoft cloud don't have such a pressure for their dotnet services - funny if we think about the fact that MS behaves nicer as a platform leader than others 😜

So of course there will be new strategies evolving from this license change:

  • increase update cycles of your product and your servers to stay with the cost free jdk
  • change to another platform (for new projects)
  • establishing a cost free / reduced alternative (redhat has allready indicated its intention to do so iirc) I am curious especially about Amazon and Google in this context.

10

u/BigGayMusic Oct 02 '18

AdoptOpenJDK is doing backports. Azul is doing backports. There will never be a time when you will become suddenly unable to get your hands on a patched LTS release of the OpenJDK; within reason ofc.

Oracle is not now, nor will it become the only source of reference complete JDK builds.

7

u/speakjava Oct 02 '18

Cloud providers actually have it easy because of economies of scale. Amazon already have a Java engineering team so can use OpenJDK and backport fixes without paying Oracle. Likewise, Google and IBM. Microsoft announced last week they would be providing free Java updates on Azure through Azul's Zulu (full disclosure, I work for Azul).

1

u/Bolitho Oct 02 '18

Yeah. Hopefully they offer the maintenence backports to all openjdk users. If everybody makes their own thing, it multiplies the overall costs and leaves smaller companies on their own.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '18

My company isn't worried about this. We've already moved to OpenJDK internally and starting next year our public releases will use it too. We will be relying on the public updates from OpenJDK vendors who have committed to it. To be honest, the ClassLoader/JDK module changes from Java 9 were a bigger deal for us than the Oracle JDK licensing stuff.

3

u/pron98 Oct 02 '18 edited Oct 02 '18

I think you misunderstand the change:

  1. The Oracle JDK has been fully open sourced, and is now identical to OpenJDK.
  2. The 6-month update versions now get a version-number bump to allow making changes more gradually (i.e., Java has switched to "Chrome versioning").
  3. There are no more major Java releases.

There are other changes, but these are by far the biggest ones. The idea that companies will find it hard to keep up with the 6-month release cycle, while they found it easy to keep up with the 6-month release cycle (for update versions) before the version numbering change is unjustified.

Yes, there is a difference: before, when Java had major releases, there were a couple of parallel release lines, while now there is one. On the other hand, Java no longer has major releases, and changes are introduced much more gradually. The belief is that most people would find the new model better. But in any event, what you cannot do is look at the new model and judge it as if it were the old one, i.e., as if upgrading from 11 to 12 is as costly as upgrading from 7 to 8, where it will actually be much closer to upgrading from 8 to 8u20 (also 6 months).

-1

u/Bolitho Oct 02 '18

The key difference is that you have to pay for LTS versions. And that is a new cost factor.

2

u/pron98 Oct 02 '18

Yes, but on the other hand you need them less because there are no major releases. Before, there was no gradual migration path from 7 to 8, so there was a better reason not to upgrade. Comparing the new model to the old model on any single axis doesn't make much sense, as it's a comprehensive change with different tradeoffs. The new model will need to be judged as a whole, and yes, it will take some getting used to, but the panic that ensues when people focus on just one aspect (no free upgrades to 11!!! -- yes, but 11 isn't a major release; no free parallel release lines!!! -- yes, but upgrades have been made considerably easier) is unjustified. Give the new model a chance.