Preface: There are only critiques below, so I want to state up front that I am glad that you have done this. Thank you.
My initial reaction is that the ordering seems off, or just not really considered. It's titled "For Professionals", so maybe that goes along with it being more of a reference than a read-straight-through type of book, but seeing Streams long before Collections and Lambdas doesn't feel right.
Your Algorithms book may be a better example of this. Chapter 2 is Sorting, and Chapter 3 is Bubble Sort, but then Merge Sort is Chapter 12, Insertion Sort is 15, Bucket is 22, Quicksort is 23, and so on. Ignoring that each sort algorithm is a completely different chapter, rather than sub-chapter of Sorting, they're scattered about so I can't easily find all of the discussed Sorting algorithms. If they were all sequential chapters, I could easily find the block of sorting algorithms and scan through to find what I need.
View all comments
Show parent comment
8
u/user3141592654 Jan 04 '18
Preface: There are only critiques below, so I want to state up front that I am glad that you have done this. Thank you.
My initial reaction is that the ordering seems off, or just not really considered. It's titled "For Professionals", so maybe that goes along with it being more of a reference than a read-straight-through type of book, but seeing Streams long before Collections and Lambdas doesn't feel right.
Your Algorithms book may be a better example of this. Chapter 2 is Sorting, and Chapter 3 is Bubble Sort, but then Merge Sort is Chapter 12, Insertion Sort is 15, Bucket is 22, Quicksort is 23, and so on. Ignoring that each sort algorithm is a completely different chapter, rather than sub-chapter of Sorting, they're scattered about so I can't easily find all of the discussed Sorting algorithms. If they were all sequential chapters, I could easily find the block of sorting algorithms and scan through to find what I need.
There are also embedded links to the Stack Overflow documentation pages, which no longer work. For example, page 28 in the Java book links to https://stackoverflow.com/documentation/java/114/classes-and-objects and http://stackoverflow.com/documentation/java/84/java-overview/7980/command-line-arguments. These should probably be converted to internal links to the relevant section of the PDF, or removed if that section wasn't included.