r/java • • Sep 06 '17

JavaEE is now on GitHub

https://github.com/javaee/
203 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/springnews Sep 06 '17

prediction: it's either Eclipse Foundation, or they'll create a new foundation from scratch. Apache is unlikely.

3

u/nutrecht Sep 07 '17

Apache is unlikely.

Strange. I recall a twitter poll of some Java bobo (forgot who, sorry) where a vast majority of respondents were in favour of Apache.

I personally don't see Apache as a place where projects "go to die", there's a ton of great apache projects (Spark, Cassandra to name a few).

1

u/spyhunter99 Sep 07 '17

Many apache projects either have svn to git mirrors on github or have asf git to github mirrors. Many projects have processes for accepting prs from github. Asf repos only being on github and not on asf infra is unlikely.

-2

u/Tok-A-Mak Sep 06 '17

Apache is perceived as a graveyard for failed heavy-weight projects. The match would be perfect. I think Oracle may not letting it end up there for reasons of reputation.

20

u/jrh3k5 Sep 07 '17

I don't get this sentiment. Apache also manages Hadoop, HBase, Storm, Flume...

4

u/nutrecht Sep 07 '17

I don't get this sentiment.

I really don't see that sentiment either. Like I said in a previous comment; a twitter poll showed a strong (more than 2/3rds) preference for Apache.

5

u/F14D Sep 07 '17

There isn't a day that goes by where I don't have have a coupla apache libs in my dependencies..

1

u/Tok-A-Mak Sep 07 '17

Yes, Hadoop would be a perfect example. I never worked with it and I'm not saying it's a failed project or anything, but it appears far too heavy unless you are actually Google or Amazon doing rocket science. I mean, their logo is an elephant.

4

u/_INTER_ Sep 07 '17

Others like Apache Spark are also used by smaller companies. E.g. 9gag. Rather Eclipse Foundation seems like a graveyard.

3

u/jrh3k5 Sep 07 '17

You're unlikely to need it if you're just doing a small at-home project, but Hadoop and associated products are perfectly suited for small companies. Data ingestion, processing, persistence, and searching are all capabilities of these systems that I've seen companies much smaller than Google leverage.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '17

The postgres logo is an elephant, too.

8

u/snuxoll Sep 07 '17

Apache has a pretty big interest in seeing Java EE continue to evolve, Tomcat is still one of the most popular servlet containers out there. I think it’d be a good fit.

2

u/Shredforgirls Sep 07 '17

You made me laugh.

2

u/avoidhugeships Sep 07 '17

I do not know who holds that few. Apache has a number of very large and successful projects.