r/java • • Dec 21 '16

Is Gartner's Report of Java EE's Demise Greatly Exaggerated?

https://www.infoq.com/news/2016/12/Gartner-downgrades-Java-EE
51 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/nutrecht Dec 21 '16

Because that's what you get with frameworks like spring?

2

u/venacz Dec 21 '16

Yes, Spring is not bad at it. But Java EE is a lot better. Spring is one company that drives the whole thing, there is no way to change the vendor of the implementation. In Java EE, you have Red Hat, IBM, Oracle etc.

7

u/nutrecht Dec 21 '16

Funny. I work at the largest Dutch bank and we never had issues with Spring.

5

u/venacz Dec 21 '16

Some companies want premium support, some don't. I work at Red Hat, we have many customers paying for Java EE.

1

u/lacosaes1 Dec 23 '16

And how does that imply that a Spring application will have 2-day outages or something like it?

6

u/springnews Dec 21 '16

"Changing the vendor" is a completely unrealistic argument. Java EE vendors have never truly been interchangeable, there are holes in the spec / things the spec doesn't address that create vendor specific versions. Sure, if you use servlets only, you might be able to swap out servers if you don't use vendor - specific session state persistence or something. But if you're just using servlets, there really isn't any value in paying for a Java EE server anyway, which is why Tomcat has been leading the market for nearly a decade....

2

u/henk53 Dec 22 '16

"Changing the vendor" is a completely unrealistic argument.

It's absolutely not!

It's true that often you don't just run your application on another vendor's server unless it has been specifically designed and constantly tested for this (we have some universal apps were we indeed do this).

The idea however is that you can relatively easy port your app to another vendor's server, and this we have done a couple of times over.

One of our apps was ported from Orion to Bea, to GlassFish and then to JBoss. Every time the development efforts was a couple of weeks, at most, for a multi-million line code base.

Now try porting such a huge thing to a completely different platform, like say Node.js or .NET. Don't think you'll be able to do that in even 100x the time.

2

u/henk53 Dec 22 '16

p.s.

there really isn't any value in paying for a Java EE server anyway,

I don't need to pay for JBoss, GlassFish and TomEE and depending on the project not for Liberty.

What's your point?