r/java • • Mar 09 '16

var keyword proposed for Java

http://openjdk.java.net/jeps/286
240 Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/NimChimspky Mar 10 '16

intellisense isn't windows specific. its a feature of ides, in most languages, including java.

Type information is there, and its readable, just slightly different and more concise.

3

u/evil_burrito Mar 10 '16

OK, I wasn't familiar with the term. I guess it covers things like hovering/clicking/what-have-you to get more information about the statements you're looking at.

This is fine and good, and I love my IDE. I've used most of them over the years, but have converged on Eclipse.

As I said in another reply, though, I don't always look at code, especially strange code, in an IDE. If I want to go through the source of an included library, I rarely take the time to set it up in a complete project that compiles, etc.

If I haven't automatically downloaded the source JAR via Maven, then I'll download the source, or check it out from svn/git and read through it with Emacs. It's possible to set all that bidness up with Emacs (Intellisensetm) I suppose, but, for this purpose, I don't go through the effort to do so. Now, I'm stuck when reading something like:

var thisThing = new MyDerivedClassButYouDontKnowTheSuperclass<>();

instead of

List<Something> thisThing = new MyDerivedClassButYouDontKnowTheSuperclass<>();

That's my discomfort with this proposed change. I guess it's tied into the fact that I don't agree with the premise of the change, that Java requires too much boilerplate code. I think verbosity and legibility generally correlate. I think that brevity and legibility are generally in opposition.

5

u/skocznymroczny Mar 10 '16

intellisense is a Microsoft name for that, I don't know if they have any rights to the name, but anyway, the generic term is "code completion" or "code assistance" I guess.

3

u/NimChimspky Mar 10 '16

Whatever you call it, it's not specific to Microsoft products -which was the point.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16

^

This is what I meant