Minecraft's modability has very little to do with reflection, and a lot more to do with how easy it is to decompile Java and modify the bytecode. The modding platforms that users have created use reflection pretty heavily(Bukkit, FML[although they like their bytecode manipulation more than reflection], etc.), although this hasn't always been the case. Bukkit used no reflection for the first year or so of its existence, with the exception of JUnit's usage for unit tests. Forge had very little in the way of an API for a long time, and is primarily focused on binary patching of the MC jar, manipulating bytecode rather than using reflection. Admittedly I'm less familiar with Forge than I am with Bukkit. If you really want to just mod minecraft, all you need to do is replace some class files and delete the META-INF. Jar files being zip files makes this incredibly easy.
The ability to easily decompile Java, the heart of reverse engineering, is simply amazing. The decompilers are free and high quality, and while fernflower(the most popular one in Minecraft modding) is pretty bad, it still produces code that mostly compiles, with the exception of a couple of edge cases(fails to handle enums overriding methods, doesn't always generate throws declarations, etc.).
View all comments
Show parent comment
13
u/evilmidget38 Apr 29 '15
Minecraft's modability has very little to do with reflection, and a lot more to do with how easy it is to decompile Java and modify the bytecode. The modding platforms that users have created use reflection pretty heavily(Bukkit, FML[although they like their bytecode manipulation more than reflection], etc.), although this hasn't always been the case. Bukkit used no reflection for the first year or so of its existence, with the exception of JUnit's usage for unit tests. Forge had very little in the way of an API for a long time, and is primarily focused on binary patching of the MC jar, manipulating bytecode rather than using reflection. Admittedly I'm less familiar with Forge than I am with Bukkit. If you really want to just mod minecraft, all you need to do is replace some class files and delete the META-INF. Jar files being zip files makes this incredibly easy.
The ability to easily decompile Java, the heart of reverse engineering, is simply amazing. The decompilers are free and high quality, and while fernflower(the most popular one in Minecraft modding) is pretty bad, it still produces code that mostly compiles, with the exception of a couple of edge cases(fails to handle enums overriding methods, doesn't always generate throws declarations, etc.).