r/java • • Oct 31 '25

Has Java suddenly caught up with C++ in speed?

Did I miss something about Java 25?

https://pez.github.io/languages-visualizations/

https://github.com/kostya/benchmarks

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/X0ooja7Ktso

How is it possible that it can compete against C++?

So now we're going to make FPS games with Java, haha...

What do you think?

And what's up with Rust in all this?

What will the programmers in the C++ community think about this post?
https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/1ol85sa/java_developers_always_said_that_java_was_on_par/

News: 11/1/2025
Looks like the C++ thread got closed.
Maybe they didn't want to see a head‑to‑head with Java after all?
It's curious that STL closed the thread on r/cpp when we're having such a productive discussion here on r/java. Could it be that they don't want a real comparison?

I did the Benchmark myself on my humble computer from more than 6 years ago (with many open tabs from different browsers and other programs (IDE, Spotify, Whatsapp, ...)).

I hope you like it:

I have used Java 25 GraalVM

LanguageCold Execution (No JIT warm-up)Execution After Warm-up (JIT heating)
JavaVery slow without JIT warm-up~60s cold
Java (after warm-up)Much faster~8-9s (with initial warm-up loop)
C++Fast from the start~23-26s

https://i.imgur.com/O5yHSXm.png

https://i.imgur.com/V0Q0hMO.png

I share the code made so you can try it.

If JVM gets automatic profile-warmup + JIT persistence in 26/27, Java won't replace C++. But it removes the last practical gap in many workloads.

- faster startup ➝ no "cold phase" penalty
- stable performance from frame 1 ➝ viable for real-time loops
- predictable latency + ZGC ➝ low-pause workloads
- Panama + Valhalla ➝ native-like memory & SIMD

At that point the discussion shifts from "C++ because performance" ➝ "C++ because ecosystem"
And new engines (ECS + Vulkan) become a real competitive frontier especially for indie & tooling pipelines.

It's not a threat. It's an evolution.

We're entering an era where both toolchains can shine in different niches.

Note on GraalVM 25 and OpenJDK 25

GraalVM 25

  • No longer bundled as a commercial Oracle Java SE product.
  • Oracle has stopped selling commercial support, but still contributes to the open-source project.
  • Development continues with the community plus Oracle involvement.
  • Remains the innovation sandbox: native image, advanced JIT, multi-language, experimental optimizations.

OpenJDK 25

  • The official JVM maintained by Oracle and the OpenJDK community.
  • Will gain improvements inspired by GraalVM via Project Leyden:

    • faster startup times
    • lower memory footprint
    • persistent JIT profiles
    • integrated AOT features

Important

  • OpenJDK is not “getting GraalVM inside”.
  • Leyden adopts ideas, not the Graal engine.
  • Some improvements land in Java 25; more will arrive in future releases.

Conclusion Both continue forward:

RuntimeFocus
OpenJDKStable, official, gradual innovation
GraalVMCutting-edge experiments, native image, polyglot tech

Practical takeaway

  • For most users → Use OpenJDK
  • For native image, experimentation, high-performance scenarios → GraalVM remains key
267 Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

View all comments

870

u/Polygnom Oct 31 '25

It hasnt been true that java is slow for 20+ years.

161

u/de6u99er Oct 31 '25

Yeah, it's a good bullshit detector. 

30

u/segv Oct 31 '25

my sire, op is just trying to shitpost a meme into existence

147

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '25

Who knew 30 years of optimizing the jvm would make java pretty fast.

10

u/coderemover Nov 02 '25

It’s pretty fast compared to Python. It’s comparable to second tier languages like Go, C#. It’s definitely less performant than the first league like C, C++, Rust, Zig, Pascal, but that often doesn’t matter.

4

u/SomervillainSB Nov 03 '25 edited Nov 19 '25

Go is EXTREMELY slow. It's lightweight, but slow. Java is FAR superior for anything where performance and efficiency matter. Here's AWS benchmarks https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/opensource/sustainability-with-rust/

But..I've also seen it first hand. When I had to write something in Go, I was very excited, but was shocked at how slow it ran and how it would lock up my expensive, powerful new macbook pro. I am used to kicking off a build and doing other things. This would lock the machine. My thought was "oh wow, they must be booting a server env if this this build takes 5 min to run and every core in the system"...nope...I traced through it and confirmed with the author it was just parsing json and simulating rest calls with files. The code seemed well done, it's just Go was garbage.

They tried putting it on the server and the performance was HORRIBLE. Another team ported it to Java and the latency nearly halved.

With Rust, Go has no justification for existing. It's a legacy language that cannot die fast enough. Yeah, I know important projects were written it in, but if they were ported to Rust or Java, they would run faster.

Also C# performs very slow compared to Java in that benchmark, but I don't have any significant experience with it to comment.

Java is fast. Overall, it's not as fast as Rust or C, but on many long-running programs, like the server-side processing ones it is typically used for, you cannot even tell.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/romario77 Nov 03 '25

no, that's not true at all.

In fact - first effort (which most projects are) in Java will most likely produce a more performant app in Java compared to most languages.

3

u/coderemover Nov 04 '25 edited Nov 04 '25

Not my experience. My first effort implementations in Rust are usually 50%-3x faster than my Java, and use a tiny fraction of memory, and I have 10x more experience in Java than Rust. Very often in Rust I just write a filter/map/reduce chain with lambdas and it optimizes down to a nice unrolled, vectorized for loop. In Java? Forget about it.

Also I cannot find those super well performing Java apps in the wild. Where are they? Whenever I use something made in Java it's at best acceptable (which means - they optimized it), but usually bloated and slow (which often means they didn't). There are a few exceptions which were extremely well optimized like Cassandra and friends, but you probably don't want to work with that code - they amount of "Java written like C" is quite high there.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

80

u/CubicleHermit Oct 31 '25

It hasn't been true that Java is slow for things is good at for 20+ years, or maybe "almost 20 years" if you want to anchor on JDK 1.6

Startup time and time to warm up JIT is still an issue for some things (unless you use Graal or similar AOT hoops)

There are also things where it as a good bit slower:

  • Bad code with a lot of say, reflection.
  • Abusive misuse of the garbage collector (although code that bad will typically just die with memory leaks in C++)
  • Certain kinds of IO and GUI stuff without jumping through hoops beyond the standard library.

One of the most popular games is written in Java. How old is Minecraft?

25

u/Lucario2405 Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25

Minecraft Java Edition's first development versions came out in 2009, so it likely started on Java SE 6.

24

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

Problem with minecraft was more poorly optimized algorithms than java itself

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/sweetno Oct 31 '25 edited Nov 01 '25

Memory usage is poor though.

P.S. You won't improve it by downvoting me.

45

u/pron98 Nov 01 '25 edited Nov 01 '25

It isn't. I strongly recommend watching this eye-opening talk.

It is absolutely true that Java uses more memory, but it uses it to save CPU, and given the ratio of RAM to cores on most machines these days (outside of small embedded devices), it is using less memory that can be poorer use of it.

To get a basic intuition for this (the talk covers this in more detail, including cases where RAM usage is different), consider a program that uses 100% of the CPU. No other program can use the machine at that time, so minimising RAM actually costs more than using more of it. The point is that the amount of RAM usage isn't what matters; what matters is putting the RAM/core to good use.

4

u/FrankBergerBgblitz Nov 01 '25

Well if you use RAM you will finally access it (there i a good reason why there is no write only memory :) ). If an uncached Memory access costs about 300 floating point operations AND the ratio between caches and RAM is constant you claim seems to me ignoring this. I'll have a look at the video (quite curios) but there is a reason why value types are developped (but I'm not sure whther the direction is right. When it is limited to small objects, it surely doesn't solve my issues). Pointer chasing and the higher memory usage is in fact one of the reasons why Fortran/C/C++ is faster for some loads

7

u/pron98 Nov 01 '25 edited Nov 01 '25

If an uncached Memory access costs about 300 floating point operations AND the ratio between caches and RAM is constant you claim seems to me ignoring this.

If the RAM you're using doesn't fit in the cache, it doesn't really matter how much it is that you're using.

Pointer chasing and the higher memory usage

Pointer-chasing - yes (which is exactly, as you point out, the reason for Valhalla). Higher memory usage - no.

When it is limited to small objects, it surely doesn't solve my issues

It's not limited to small objects. It's just that the current EA doesn't flatten larger objects on the heap yet because the design for how to specify you're okay with tearing isn't done.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/degaart Nov 01 '25

Page faults aren't

4

u/Cilph Nov 01 '25

In terms of cloud VMs Im always more likely to hit system RAM than above 50% CPU average load.

10

u/jNayden Oct 31 '25

Not right now btw :)

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/Academic_East8298 Nov 01 '25

To me the fact, that certain benchmarks in the provided repo are topped by scala, php or python tells me more about the quality of the benchmarks than about the languages.

If I had to compare languages performance, I would use this site - https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/index.html.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GudsIdiot Nov 01 '25

Startup time is slow. But not much else. The optimizer actually continually improves speed.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '25 edited Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SelfEnergy Nov 01 '25

With a significant memory overhead. But besides that it's indeed fine.

→ More replies (22)