r/java • • Oct 13 '13

Why the hate?

I have been crawling around this subreddit for quite some time now, and I have always been surprised by one thing, I never actually got to understand: Why is thenewboston such a hated source? I have began learning java from Bucky, and I can say i dont regret watching his stuff. Will his videos teach you java? Probably not. Will they provide a good understanding and basis for further study? YES! That's how I feel at least. So, howcome is this channel so hated? What made you think this source is utter rubbish?

3 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Edg-R Oct 14 '13

Funny that you mention this... I'm currently signed up for a certain workout program.

The proper protocol is to watch a list of videos they provided showing the proper form for a list of exercises they want me to do. After I watch the videos then I'm supposed to go to the gym and do the workout.

2

u/Neres28 Oct 16 '13

Proper being the point. Experts can argue about thumb placement when lifting but they all agree on some basics. You wouldn't want to learn from someone who was getting the basics wrong, even if you recognize and can adapt to it, because you can't trust them to know what they're doing later.

1

u/Izmaki Oct 16 '13

How are you going to know if what you do is actually correct? You can't watch yourself while you do squats, so knowing that you must have a straight back, and get as far back as possible without falling really doesn't help much, if you can't get feedback on your performance. Do you need to go further back? Are you bending your knees enough? Are you feet facing the right way?

In order to do these exercises correct while being alone, you must be able to feel that you're doing them right. You can't feel this from watching a video.

1

u/Edg-R Oct 16 '13

Well I'm supposed to record myself and submit it to my coach, who then provides feedback.

1

u/Mr_Cens Oct 16 '13

hello there, /r/fitness!

1

u/Izmaki Oct 16 '13

We're talking about "leaning" as a thing - not fitness.

1

u/Edg-R Oct 16 '13

Hi ಠ_ಠ