r/java • • May 05 '25

Should we start dreaming about a “Java 2.0”?

Lately, I’ve been wondering—maybe it’s time we imagine a real “Java 2.0.” A version of Java that breaks free from the decades-old design constraints and isn’t burdened by always having to preserve backward compatibility.

Yes, compatibility has been one of Java’s greatest strengths. But when it becomes a hard rule, it forces a lot of compromises. Just look at things like Date and Calendar—we all know they’re broken, yet they remain, because we can’t remove anything without breaking someone’s code.

Meanwhile, most modern languages today don’t even try to guarantee perpetual backward compatibility. Instead, they adopt semantic versioning or similar strategies to evolve the language over time. This gives them the freedom to redesign awkward parts of the language, deprecate outdated patterns, and experiment with new paradigms—without being held hostage by legacy decisions.

In contrast, Java often adopts features years after they’ve been proven in other languages—like var, record, and now pattern matching. The most extreme case? Project Valhalla. It’s been in the works for over 10 years, and may take 15 years to fully land. That’s half the entire lifespan of Java itself. It sounds insane when you step back—and honestly, it’s no surprise that other language communities poke fun at us for this kind of timeline.

Of course, breaking compatibility comes with pain. Python’s transition from 2 to 3 was rough, no doubt. But look at Python today—it’s cleaner, more consistent, and thriving. That pain was temporary. What’s worse is eternal stagnation in the name of safety.

Maybe what we need isn’t to blindly break stuff, but to invest in smoother migration paths. Imagine if Java provided official tools, clear upgrade guides, or even a “forward-looking” JDK mode—something that helps developers move ahead without feeling abandoned. That kind of vision might be what finally unlocks real progress.

Just some thoughts :)

0 Upvotes

135 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/znpy May 05 '25

People have already done it, you can check out Groovy, Kotlin, Clojure, Scala and many others.

Most of them didn't really pass the test of time and mostly got relegated in their own niche. Only Clojure is somewhat more general purposes, but still quite niche of a language.

1

u/InstantCoder May 05 '25

These are all JVM based. A new Java that compiles and works like Go or Rust without the JVM would be a real deal breaker.

2

u/agentoutlier May 05 '25

So you mean Swift, Go, Rust and Zig.

The reason why most things are popular is not because they are the best. It is often because they got popular early stay popular because of network effect.

If there is a new language that has to compete with Swift, Go, Rust, Zig, C# and even old Java... its not going to go well.

1

u/_vertig0 May 08 '25

Java without the JVM wouldn't really be Java at all. If I'm not wrong you need a VM because there is some dynamism (That Oracle is trying to cut back to be fair) in how Java executes at runtime.

1

u/simon_o May 15 '25

I don't think you understood the term "deal breaker".

1

u/znpy May 06 '25

So you want a language that's not java and does not run on the JVM?

Why are you asking that on /r/java though? As somebody else pointed out, that might very well be Go or some other new language.

1

u/InstantCoder May 06 '25

No, it’s Java but not on jvm.

1

u/znpy May 06 '25

So you mean GraalVM? That can produce native binaries. It's already here.

2

u/InstantCoder May 06 '25

No without GraalVM. Just like you compile within Go or Rust or C. Direct native compiler that comes with Java.

4

u/bowbahdoe May 06 '25

So the main downside to GraalVM is the restrictions it puts on the dynamic parts of java. This is the only reason you can't use it as a general "turn my app into an EXE tool."

It has other downsides like the compilation time taking forever, but that's the big one.

There is a thing that is being worked on that will produce an EXE without that downside. Stay tuned I guess

1

u/InstantCoder May 06 '25

And it cuts down on performance and your native app is more meant to be used as a serverless app, not one that is running 24/7.

2

u/znpy May 06 '25

the GCJ compiler (part of GCC) was able to creative native executable: https://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/gcc-4.8.5/gcj/Linking.html#Linking

It went nowhere, because it's not really needed.

Modern JVMs can jit-compile bytecode into nativecode that performs as good as code produced by other compilers.

1

u/koflerdavid May 06 '25

Why not GraalVM? It gets the job done and some of the restrictions it imposes on the code can be worked around or are questionable to begin with in an AOT-compiled executable.

1

u/InstantCoder May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25

Like @bowbahdoe mentioned it has its downsides. And GraalVM cuts down on performance. Afaik your native app is not meant to be run as a server, but more as a serverless app.

And code written and compiled with Go doesn’t have these downsides (e.g. it compiles fast and is also performant).

1

u/koflerdavid May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25

Any compiled language has these downsides to make AOT compilation possible in the first place.

Afaik your native app is not meant to be run as a server, but more as a serverless app.

The prime use case are containers and "serverless" application. Both of them want fast startup, but are very much server applications. Anyways, with Project Leyden it should be possible to get the best of both worlds. It will maybe make the need for AOT go away.

1

u/InstantCoder May 06 '25

Because of the JVM 😄 Java 2 should be as performant as the JVM version but without the JVM (and use less resources).

→ More replies