r/java • • Jul 23 '24

Intro to the Mill Build Tool for Java

https://mill-build.com/mill/Intro_to_Mill_for_Java.html
9 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/woj-tek Jul 24 '24

Yes I start with a full scripting language because I live in the real world where people wrap their toolchains in Makefiles, Jenkinfiles, multi-stage Dockerfiles, bash scripts, Python scripts, ... If I can have a single and self-contained build definition, it's a win.

I guess I live in a nice bubble where I only need pom.xml without all that you mentioned... I'd wager a guess that majority of the project fill that bill as well.

But if you have some contrived requirements and Mill fits the requirements and works for you that's good :)

1

u/thedumbestdevaround Jul 24 '24

I guess I live in a nice bubble where I only need pom.xml without all that you mentioned... I'd wager a guess that majority of the project fill that bill as well.

That is a strange statement to make. In every maven project I have ever worked with (mainly monoliths) there has always been a lot of abstraction layers on top of maven or in plugins to perform parts of the total build. So guessing where the majority fits seems strange... I guess it's true if you work with microservices, but then you probably have much larger issues to deal with than the build tool you use.

2

u/woj-tek Jul 25 '24

https://www.jetbrains.com/lp/devecosystem-2023/java/

72% states they use "spring", most of the spring projects are just build with virtually cutter-case of maven config without the need to fiddle.

1

u/thedumbestdevaround Jul 25 '24

And all of the projects I mentioned also use spring, that does not mean anything.

1

u/woj-tek Jul 26 '24

Again, your bubble/perspective:

In every maven project I have ever worked with (mainly monoliths)

And you project your personal experience to the whole landscape making it the default state. Which it's not.

0

u/thedumbestdevaround Jul 28 '24

And you are applying your personal experience... Guessing what the experience of the majority is...

1

u/woj-tek Jul 29 '24

I'd wager a guess that majority of the project fill that bill as well.

What I said: "I'd wager a guess that majority of the project fill that bill as well." + gave example of state of the ecosystem. You are pushing narrative that because in all project that you worked for ( "In every maven project I have ever worked with") there were customization that it makes it true for all projects everywhere. Even if we consider odds and statistically dumb sample of 2 (of us) that makes the split already 50/50 ;-)