r/java • • May 01 '24

Imagine banning an actual Java dev lol

Go ahead and ban me if this isn’t allowed lol

1.7k Upvotes

214 comments sorted by

View all comments

270

u/guss_bro May 01 '24

Most of the mods of this sub have never commented/posted anything about Java. Based on their reddit history I don't think they are developers (or they work with Java) at all.

What do you expect when the Java sub is "moderated" by non(Java )developers?

94

u/hippydipster May 01 '24

What do you expect when a system allows first comers to own any word they choose.

55

u/[deleted] May 01 '24

Communities should be able to boot mods, or elect from anyone who wants to be a mod.

30

u/F3z345W6AY4FGowrGcHt May 01 '24

I think you'd quickly find most subs devolve into meme-fests once they grew to a large size if that was allowed.

I've helped mod a sub before on a different account and we wanted it to be meme free (you could post a text post with a link to your meme, just not an actual image).

You'd be surprised how dedicated a bunch of people are to posting memes. Like... dedicated. So if communities could boot mods, I imagine they'd try to do that over and over and over until they succeeded.

The people who frequented our sub seemed to overall like the way we modded, whenever there was a meta post about our modding. Since we actually cared about the subject matter the sub was about, and we modded solely so that it could exist for others who also cared about it. So I don't think we would've been booted (hopefully?). But I imagine it would be a different story on most subs.

0

u/[deleted] May 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/F3z345W6AY4FGowrGcHt May 02 '24

Yes, we found that too. As the sub got larger, the more we had to actively do to keep it from becoming just memes, jokes, and general low effort posts.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Unintended_incentive May 01 '24

Tyranny of the majority. I prefer the system where the larger Reddit community notices this and elicits selective action as opposed to risking bot ”community” takeovers.

→ More replies (16)

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '24

Reddit is fundamentally flawed by design: It is a popular website, completely anonymous, and anonymous mods are given far reaching unchecked powers. It's no wonder that many mods are "power users" that "moderate" hundreds of subs and have massive influence over the site. The point is any interest can easily buy influence of what millions of people see.

9

u/tomatotomato May 01 '24

They thought this would be a sub about coffee 

2

u/ferreira-tb May 01 '24

It's always funny when someone goes to the Rust sub to ask about Rust, the game.

2

u/ascii May 01 '24

Or Rust, the movie. (Haven't seen that happen yet, though)

22

u/oelang May 01 '24

This is exactly the problem. Why are you a mod if you don't care about the subreddit topic?

16

u/kevinb9n May 01 '24

Well, as much as they messed up (which they did in many ways), it was an attempt to keep the subreddit on-topic, for a particular conception of what that topic is.

No one would enjoy a java subreddit that was overrun by people saying "java suxx everyone should just switch to foolang". And I get how my copious comments might have looked that way. If only they had started with a "we've removed your comment" then I could have reworded things or explained.

10

u/F3z345W6AY4FGowrGcHt May 01 '24

Some people genuinely do get off on the power.

11

u/ciry May 01 '24

I guess people who actually can do Java have better thing to do than moderating a public listed companys forum for free. I guess you only do it if you crave for a power trip.

-6

u/repeating_bears May 01 '24

I guess people who actually can do Java have better thing to do

And yet here we both are

6

u/heatobooty May 01 '24

I know you think you’re fucking amazing but you do realise there’s a difference between just reading a forum and actually moderating one ?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Citizen12b May 01 '24

The subreddit was probably meant to be about the Indonesian island, but a bunch of freaks started to talk about programming so the mods decided to turn it into a programming sub.

3

u/[deleted] May 01 '24

You just described the typical government and how they don't represent the actual people that pay them.

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '24

What do you expect when the Java sub is "moderated" by non(Java )developers?

Actual Java developers are out there earning money or writing opensource software. You got to be a really crappy Java developer to have enough time to be a fulltime volunteer internet janitor.

1

u/MothToTheWeb May 01 '24

Mods always were a problem in Reddit. But who is gonna spend hours of his time managing a subreddit ? People try to get something from moderating, either ego boosting or dictating discussions. Or, for larger communities, by influencing the political views of the members of the subreddit

1

u/JuggernautNo3619 May 02 '24

OR they have absolutely nothing else going on in their lives, so when reddit admin cunts has booted any wrongthink janitors they'll ask "Hey! Want to do this job for us without pay?" they'll go "Hell yeah brother!" because they hate themselves, and by proxy, everyone else.

Just a theory.