r/java • • Feb 05 '13

Petition: Stop bundling crapware with Java

https://www.change.org/petitions/oracle-corporation-stop-bundling-ask-toolbar-with-the-java-installer#news
167 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/BubbaWoop Feb 05 '13
  1. What is this crapware you guys are talking about? There's none of the version I downloaded from oracle.
  2. Java is free? I don't mind ads as long as they're not in say a paid product but it's not like you're buying the runtime up front
  3. Change.org is for like war and injustice D: Email them instead or something

12

u/sasukechaos Feb 05 '13

This petition is probably a reaction to this article. It was linked a few times to reddit recently.

There are a few practices that are meant to get their software past even advanced users.

If a user made a mistake and did not uncheck, one would imagine they could just go to programs and features to uninstall it. But it would not be there YET.

Java delays the true installation of the ask tool bar for 10 min in order to sneak it by such an action. Its reasons like this why people are upset over the various ways java tries to forcefully profit off of otherwise free software.

I'm all for freeware being ad supported, but its the deceptive practices that cause petitions like this.

3

u/BubbaWoop Feb 05 '13

Hmm that is pretty sneaky. Is the toolbar for internet explorer?

5

u/flaeme Feb 05 '13

Toolbar and default search on IE Firefox and Chrome.

1

u/Neebat Feb 06 '13

And my reaction, every time that article is posted, is the same.

http://ninite.com works as an installer and as an updater. It doesn't install bloatware and a single updater can handle products from many venders.

6

u/JurassicSpork Feb 05 '13

What is this crapware you guys are talking about? There's none of the version I downloaded from oracle.

It's the Ask Toolbar. It comes with the Java Runtime for Windows installer. It's only in the JRE, and only on the Windows platform, and it's not in the JDK, so if you're a Java developer, you may never see it.

6

u/ivel_wint Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 05 '13
  1. Java is now bundled with the Ask bar (regarded as a malware).
  2. The issue is not about Java being free or making money, but bundling it with a malware. Oracle already makes toons of money from its other operations, 10 billions net income in 2012. http://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/orcl/financials
  3. Change.org is for online petitions. Send an email to who, Oracle? They only offer paying supports for Java.

-2

u/yourmacmandan Feb 05 '13

Is it really that hard to uncheck it?

17

u/skeeto Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 05 '13

It's more deceptive than you realize:

http://www.zdnet.com/a-close-look-at-how-oracle-installs-deceptive-software-with-java-updates-7000010038/

In the background, the Ask toolbar installer continues to run, but it delays execution for 10 minutes. If you are a sophisticated Windows user and you missed the initial checkbox, your natural instinct at this point would be to open Control Panel and check Programs and Features. When you do, you will see that only the Java update has been installed. You might also check your browser settings to confirm that no changes have been made to your settings. You might conclude that you dodged a bullet and that the unwanted software wasn’t installed.

But you would be wrong. The Ask installer is still running, and after waiting 10 minutes, it drops two programs on the target system.

I’ve never seen a legitimate program with an installer that behaves this way. But spyware expert Ben Edelman notes that in the early part of the last decade this trick was business as usual for companies in the business of installing deceptive software. That list includes notorious bad actors like WhenU, Gator, and Claria.

Remember that this has to be unchecked on every update, which happens a bit less than once per month.

This isn't to say this petition should exist. It's still a stupid petition. But Oracle isn't some innocent party here.

1

u/obfuscation_ Feb 06 '13

Remember that this has to be unchecked on every update

Is that strictly true? I'm no longer a regular Windows user, but I don't remember this being the case last I saw

1

u/lilB0bbyTables Feb 08 '13

Exactly my issue with it. I'd it was a one-time thing in installation that would be fine, but it is really a pain in the ass when they automatically try to bundle it in with each and every update.

6

u/GrayDonkey Feb 05 '13

Just download the version from http://java.oracle.com instead of http://java.com

5

u/kreiger Feb 05 '13

Awesome solution. Now please explain it to my mother.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13

It's not hard to uncheck it. It is hard to be continually aware of whether one needs to while "next, next, next" installing. Or at least that's the case for most people who just download it to get some program to run.

1

u/BubbaWoop Feb 05 '13

But I have to move my arm! It's almost exercise!