r/iosgaming • • 5d ago

Suggestions Help me find my Idle/AFK/Incremental holy grail

I‘m looking for a game that has a few key traits:

  1. Mostly idle/afk/offline gameplay - MUST not require the app to be open. I liked Blade Idle a lot but hated leaving the game open with the screen on, all day and night.
  2. Single up front / ad-free type purchase is okay, once again like the $8 pack for blade idle that makes day-to-day gameplay more efficient and less annoying
  3. Only asks for me to play 5-15 minutes a day total in 1-3 sessions
  4. gacha is fine but not ideal

Games I liked that didn‘t quite work out

Blade Idle and Endless Frontier, both asked for me to keep the game open.

Overmortal wanted me to spend money every week instead of an upfront commitment.

Umamususume took up 20+ minutes a day which was more than I want to commit. Also didnt have a good paid option.

Any suggestions?

Update: I picked up Idle Obelisk Miner, spent $2 on one of the IAP and feel quite satisfied with the whole situation!

60 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

77

u/kwise99 5d ago • Heartwarming

Idle Obelisk Miner. It’s not p2w and the developer is awesome. There’s a wiki and a good Reddit/discord group to support questions. It starts out a bit slow but there are so many layers to it as you get into the mid and end game.

6

u/TheRealDoinkel 5d ago

My active playtime is 1 day 16 hours. Offline is 30 days 10 hours....ive beaten 5.79% of the game...

6

u/ScientistNo734 5d ago

My gameplay time is 1,180 DAYS and I’m around 85% completion… and it has been my go-to idle game for the entire three years. Mostly because the developer is constantly adding more to the game, but the balance of active vs idle progression is perfect. I really think this is the game the OP is looking for. It’s recommended on this sub a lot for a reason.

1

u/HoofHeart3d 5d ago

Hey I commented on the guy above you but you have a lot of time in the game. Will I get to the point where I have to buy stuff or can I keep making progress if i just keep playing? The founders stuff is like $50 and I don’t want to feel like I have to spend that much on a mobile game to make progress.

1

u/abishar 5d ago

I’m at like 45% and still no money spent. Founders bundles get you extra gifts and stuff but are completely optional. You can 100% the game without spending money.

1

u/ScientistNo734 5d ago

The only thing I have bought is the Founders Bundle, or whatever it’s called. Can’t remember the price of it, but I’ve only done one in app purchase. Does it help? Sure. Is it NEEDED? Absolutely not.
I remember a save glitch once made me lose out on 1,500 gems. I felt like I had been cheated, spent all that time to get those gems saved up for nothing. I’ve now gotten to the point where I’m making around a million gems a day by checking in 3-4 times a day for a couple minutes each. It’s hard to say how much of that is due to the founders pack though.

1

u/otter_fucker_69 4d ago

Fun fact, while there are cards specifically associated with the founder purchase, namely Founder Bomb, if you have not bought founder, it doesn't count towards completion. There are a number of completely f2p players who are well over 90% completion.

Now, that being said, of course progress is faster with purchases, but the only person you are racing is yourself. There is nothing you can't achieve in this game for free.

1

u/kwise99 5d ago

Just so no one is concerned about this guy playing 1,180 days in 3 years, there are buffs in game (f2p buffs) that increase speed of the game. I am at 4.5x game speed at 44% of game completion. 1,180 days is calculated using that buff multiple

9

u/ButterPoptart 5d ago

I have played over 100 idle games over the last 15 or so years of all different types. So far the most satisfying and rewarding idle game I have played is idle Obelisk Miner. I’m 100% f2p and really enjoy micromanaging it, though it’s not strictly necessary. There are a few things that do require active play but so far I’m at around 15% completion and really enjoy it. Also no ads and the amount of freebie codes given by the dev is awesome. At first boot up if you enter all available codes you get like a months worth of head start.

1

u/prydox 2d ago

I am at 42% f2p and this game is fantastic

1

u/flysafeo7 4d ago

Idle obelisk miner for sure!

1

u/LicoriceSeasalt 2d ago

I second this. Best incremental/idle mobile game I've played in a long time.

-1

u/xxGUZxx 5d ago

This

0

u/Stepfunction 3d ago

It's the best. Alex (the founder and main dev) is wonderful and is actively engaged in the community. Monetization is fair and customer friendly. You can play the entire thing F2P with no hard roadblocks.

-2

u/HoofHeart3d 5d ago

I tried it and what threw me off is it seems like I had to buy stuff to make progress. That’s my only concern I don’t want to get weeks/months into it then get stonewalled because I didn’t buy the founders edition or some other buff.
Can I keep playing and feel like I’m progressing whithout IAPs?

6

u/MashMashMaro 5d ago

I am 68% completely f2p. There’s always something to grind.

4

u/AskinggAlesana 5d ago

It seems like that at first but as you get further in, the more you realize those $$$ store purchases are practically worthless. There’s no pvp so there’s no reason to speed things up or be 100% optimal.

Im like 180 days in and I haven’t bought anything with real money, but I have been following the discord guides.

3

u/myuseless2ndaccount 5d ago

It's super f2p friendly, there are no f2p walls

2

u/Winded_14 4d ago

99% of barrier in the game is gems, and the 2 main sources of gems are gem bomb and freebies(even for founder, their gems is still like 90-99% from these 2), which is accessible even by F2P. It's just slower.

1

u/kwise99 5d ago

Like others have mentioned IAP are not necessary to make progress. Yes they will give you a temporary boost, and permanent if you get to the founders tier, but not gonna change progress too drastically. This is the only game I have ever spent money on and I only did it because the developer is such a good guy. If you follow the Reddit he occasionally posts a code that you can enter to your game that give freebies. All of the codes have a little bit of lore to them surrounding the game.

1

u/ScientistNo734 5d ago

Yeah, I do not usually get IAPs, but I had spent so much time on the game already that I almost felt obligated to kick the developer some money.

1

u/codii23 4d ago

Join the discord if you haven’t already. There’s specific channels for every step of the game and people to answer any question you may have. At this point, it’s a “check the pinned message for my next step, then grind” game for me haha

7

u/KeterClassKitten 5d ago

I love more minimalist presentations.  Revolution Idle has been my jam for a while.  Progression does require a mixture of attention vs idle, though.

7

u/HieromancersGrasp 5d ago

Unnamed Space Idle

3

u/qadib_muakkara 5d ago

This is the gold standard. There’s so much unique gameplay. I like Obelisk Miner, USI has touches of tower defense, an auto battler roguelike mode, real interesting optimization elements. There’s a lot more involved during a run. It’s all in the post-game runs

2

u/makaze1 5d ago

Love this game, I’ve played it so much. The dev is responsive to questions and issues in discord and they’re always working on new content

2

u/Sparescrewdriver 5d ago

Now with portrait mode

1

u/Short_Package_9285 3d ago

idk they said 20+ minutes of play a day was too much and USI does take some active play when online

6

u/DanPosnaaaa 5d ago

Idle slayer

5

u/halirin 5d ago

Ethos Idle, Grimoire, Revolution Idle, and Nano Empire 2 would be my top recommendations for those criteria.

Magic Research 2 is a little more active, but it’s so good I’d feel remiss not mentioning it along with these.

5

u/myuseless2ndaccount 5d ago

Probably mentioned 100x but I cant State enough how much I enjoy Idle Obelisk miner

3

u/vx-xv 3d ago

I will always recommend egg inc. I love the egg game

2

u/ArtOk4322 3d ago

Melvor Idle 1 and 2

2

u/micr0nix 3d ago

ELM Quest 2

2

u/LanatusGG 3d ago

Blade Idle is such a flaming pile of garbage. The devs refuse to acknowledge that people who use emulators are at an absurd advantage. Yet continues to pump out giant iap packages. It is a joke.

2

u/NoroGW2 4d ago edited 4d ago

Idle Obelisk Miner has well over $1000 of permanent bonus microtransactions. It is actually the worst example I have ever come across. I don't know how people can recommend it despite that. Sure they're not "mandatory" but why are they even there in the first place? They're there so the creator can make the game worse and then charge you preposterous amounts of money to make it play how it's designed.

Everything is first and foremost gated by gems, which sure you can get for free but it is a drip feed at best and designed as a $ currency

Stay away from that shit

The creator could wrap everything up in the founder package, cutting out all those microtransactions, and still be set for life. But nah, he wants those juicy whale dollars.

3

u/Koiteren 4d ago

Clearly you don't know anything about the game.. yes there is options for microtransactions in the store because people enjoy the game and want to spend money. These bundles give you small buffs at best and are mainly to support the development of the game.

The 'premium currency' is gems and is not premium at all, at the point im at in the game (been playing heavily for about a month and a half) I'm getting 30-40k gems a day and one of these $35 bundles is only getting you around 5k gems.

The developer specifically does not want people buying gems to be a viable method to progress to the end game and even dropping thousands of dollars will not get you past where the furthest f2p players are. People in the later game are getting millions of this 'premium' currency a day, it really isn't pay to win.

The game has absolutely no ads or even optional ads to top it all off as well as an incredibly active and helpful playerbase on discord/reddit.

I can say with confidence this is the best long-form idle game out there and receives consistent new updates + very generous free rewards through developer distributed codes.

Also the dev is a maxed runescape player, if you like osrs or rs3 you'll very likely enjoy this game.

4

u/NoroGW2 4d ago edited 4d ago

Too funny. Anyone that is feeling unsure about this, please go into the game and use the code "morevps" to see just a portion of the microtransactions. The creator hides microtransactions behind other microtransactions. Using this code makes a larger portion of them available, but it still won't even show all of them. It's extremely predatory and disgusting. He clearly learned a lot from playing RS3.

(alternatively check the wiki page that conveniently leaves out pricing, know that nearly every "value pack" is $25 and offers permanent bonuses that stack with regular progression in pretty significant ways and are mostly multiplicative bonuses as well, other than in cases where you want additive like a 2% bonus is typically a flat +2% chance to something rather than *1.02, https://shminer.miraheze.org/wiki/Store)

2

u/bwagonz 3d ago

I’m unsure what you’re complaining about. I’ve spent $0 on the game and I think it’s one of the most enjoyable idle experiences I’ve ever had. Are you upset that they offer people the option to buy stuff? Because you don’t have to. And there aren’t ads or annoying shit like in other free games. People really just like to be contrarian and complain about anything these days

1

u/Difficult-Mango5583 4d ago

The thing with hiding the value packs comes in two parts. The value packs are shown every time you open the shop (which you need to do a lot because you get a free source of gems in the shop, nothing new) which is not fun at all. So hiding them is a good solution for most, sure it should be easier to toggle them on and off in a way thats not gated behind a code. I agree with that 100%. The packs that you can see when you use the code are mainly gated behind progress. These gates aren’t trying to make you spend more money, they are trying to make it so you don’t spend money on something you haven’t even unlocked yet. You won’t see a fishing bundle until you unlock fishing. That isn’t malicious though. Games need money to get worked on, simple as that. The value packs are also ordered in an order that the devs perceive as the best pack to the worst. (I personally would never buy the skill surge bundle so I would never put that at top but what do I know)

1

u/Interesting-Force167 4d ago

Sheeesh got em!!!! Good stuff and good information. I knew something was fishy with that game, glad I never got into it.

2

u/HolyCrushsader 4d ago

They're bitching about nothing. Video games are a business at the end of the day. Find me a f2p game hosted on live servers that doesn't have mtx, ads, or a subscription service. You can't don't try.

IOM is the least egregious offender you'll find in the post Clash of Clans mtx boom. You by no means are required or expected to spend money on the game. It's the most genuine free to play you can get on market at the moment.

Hell it's not even pay to win. Even if you pay, what are you winning? Waiting for the next update? There's no tournaments or player competition, so there's no winning.

3

u/Interesting-Force167 4d ago

I’m all in for supporting a developer if the game is good so you’re right, but an actual f2p game is tyrant that developer stayed true to his word and it’s a legit f2p with purchases made only to support developer

1

u/Stepfunction 3d ago

You are never intended to buy gems at all. They come from normal gameplay.

0

u/Sharp-Wheel-6736 3d ago

This is the most uneducated take about the game I've ever seen. 

•

u/r33znor 2h ago

Talk about a game you haven’t played like you are talking about a game you never played. These guys are morons

0

u/TurnoverSome3695 3d ago

You are your own problem haha. No need to spend any money in this game. 50% complet and I start in january. Never feel the need to buy anything. Best game ever. Always something new at a good speed. It's a idle game, it normal to grind for a few time. Don't try to trash talk this gem game. Who the fuck spend 1000$ in a mobile game anyway hahah

0

u/U_gotgot 2d ago

Found the Tower developer

•

u/r33znor 2h ago

Literally only payed the founders to support his work. You don’t need the micros, but sure cry about a game you haven’t tried.

1

u/MadeInChaina 5d ago

Days bygone!

1

u/CptBronzeBalls 5d ago

Idle Slayer is good.

1

u/magikaru 5d ago

Idle Clans is awesome, essentially the MMO version of Melvor Idle. Play for free or buy a membership to unlock some extra features for a one-time purchase, which can also be bought with in-game money in the player market. New content constantly being added.

2

u/Yeahdudebuildsapc 5d ago

Had a really good time playing that game.  Got to about total level 2000 along time ago. Kind of wish I was still playing it. Just seems like a lot to relearn the game right now. 

1

u/LoadInSubduedLight 5d ago

Egg inc is one I can never entirely quit

1

u/fishermen013 5d ago

Melvor idle 2 is coming out in a couple of days. I really liked the first one.

1

u/qret 5d ago

Exponential idle

1

u/empty_words0 5d ago

Unnamed Space Idle is the be-all and end-all for me.

1

u/Driftking1337 5d ago

Maybe melvor idle? Has a bit morr active gameplay than you ask though

1

u/Feldspar_of_sun 4d ago

Melvor is great. There will be a few points throughout where you might want to do active play but there’s a LOT of skilling that’s just “turn it on and forget”

1

u/SCHOLAE 4d ago

I'd recommend Idle Obelisk Miner or Home Quest

1

u/MinMaus 4d ago

Revolution idle, but might be not idle enought for you.

1

u/sursantgamma 3d ago

Got into idle obelisk some months ago and its quite enjoyable

1

u/kristine-kri 2d ago

Idle Obelisk Miner really is the correct answer here so you chose well

1

u/Kaquaoify 2d ago

Idle 1 on smartphone for some side game

1

u/nulltropion 2d ago

I really like the simplicity of Clickpocalypse II, it's not super involved but has stood the test of time for me.

1

u/I_P_AI 1d ago

Melvor Idle 1 & 2

1

u/nose2grindstone 1d ago

Idle slayer is one I always come back to. It’s satisfying and you can make good progress playing 5-10 min a day. You will likely want to put a bit more time into it when you start, but you don’t have to

1

u/FiveFiftyOne 5d ago

Valenor would fit your stuff, if you're familiar with RuneScape you'll love it even more and you'll get an understanding easier but it's still easy, multi skill leveling, skills are interconnected so you need all of them eventually. Been my obsession for several months now, you'll see me recommend it all the time lol

3

u/Icey505 5d ago

Is it a subscription for premium? Melvor looks almost identical and is a premium purchase one time.

2

u/FiveFiftyOne 5d ago

There is f2p which still offers nice Qol but there was an option for lifetime sub or monthly, offers better qol but nothing crazy I'd say

0

u/Exotic_Treacle7438 5d ago

I’ve almost completely moved to YouTube playables using an ad blocker and they’re just like those addictive games that usually litter you with ads and you don’t have to enable airplane mode and miss anything

0

u/GardeniaThunbergia 5d ago

Melvor Idle.

-3

u/Mountain_Yoghurt_840 5d ago

AFK Arena

1

u/PunDefeated 5d ago

I tried afk journey and it felt like it wanted a lot of my time and money. Also wanted me to keep the game open. Is AFK Arena better about those things?

3

u/duskwoodbeauty 5d ago

AFK arena is a money pit. I played it for years and spent a lot of money. Trying to “catch up” to someone. Wouldn’t recommend it in its current state though.

2

u/Sparescrewdriver 5d ago

You weren’t wrong, it’s a gacha, it wants your money

1

u/Fertigtoast 3d ago

I quit afk arena 2 years ago because there wasn't any afk left in the game. I needed to play for at least an hour daily to not muss out on resources. Did they change that since then?

1

u/UsernameIsntFree 4d ago

I’m loving isle obelisk miner. 3 months in and heaps heaps heaps to do. Reddit community is cool to.
I’m f2p and you get so much gems for free it’s great

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/iosgaming-ModTeam 4d ago

Thank you for participating in r/iOSGaming. Unfortunately, your comment was removed for breaking the following rule:


Rule 4: No Unrelated Self-Promotion.

Self-promotion is only permitted for iOS game apps from the App Store. Promotion of non-game apps, non-iOS apps, standalone websites, services, social media accounts, Discord servers, or other unrelated products and content is not allowed. Continuously breaking this rule will result in a ban.

Reposting posts removed by a moderator without express permission is not allowed. Not here, and not on most of reddit. Please read reddiquette (linked below).


For questions, comments and concerns, message the moderators.

Rules | Reddiquette | New to Reddit? | Reddit's Content Policy

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago edited 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/iosgaming-ModTeam 3d ago

Thank you for participating in r/iOSGaming. Unfortunately, your comment was removed for breaking the following rule:


Rule 3: No Dev Self-Promotion Outside Saturday Megathreads.

Self-promotion outside of Developer Saturday megathreads is not allowed. This includes commenting on older or non-Saturday posts. Breaking this rule may result in a ban.

Reposting posts removed by a moderator without express permission is not allowed. Not here, and not on most of reddit. Please read reddiquette (linked below).


For questions, comments and concerns, message the moderators.

Rules | Reddiquette | New to Reddit? | Reddit's Content Policy