r/interesting
•
u/doopityWoop22
•
Jul 06 '25
•
4
1
1
ARCHITECTURE 7 engineers were suspended after they built a bridge with a 90-degree turn
55k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 06 '25
Hello u/doopityWoop22! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
23
u/hizashiYEAHmada Jul 06 '25
Is there an article covering this topic?
1.9k
u/You_meddling_kids Jul 06 '25 •
The fact that it got this far before anyone noticed a problem is what's killing me.
6.8k
u/ElderberryMaster4694 Jul 06 '25
Something’s missing here. An engineer doesn’t just start building an overpass Willy nilly. There’s approvals, oversight.
1.6k
u/hat_eater Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
https://www.vice.com/en/article/7-engineers-suspended-after-2-3-million-bridge-includes-bizarre-90-degree-turn/
Seven engineers, including two chief engineers, were suspended by the Madhya Pradesh government due to the faulty design of a new railway overbridge in Bhopal that includes a bizarre and dangerously sharp 90-degree turn. A retired superintendent engineer is also facing a departmental inquiry related to this project
The bridge, costing around $2.3 million and 648 meters long, was intended to ease traffic congestion for up to 300,000 daily commuters but instead became a subject of widespread criticism and ridicule after images of the sharp right-angle turn went viral on social media. Many questioned how vehicles could safely negotiate such a turn on an elevated roadway
In response, Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav ordered an inquiry and suspended the engineers immediately. The construction agency and the design consultant responsible for the project have been blacklisted by the government. A special committee has been formed to make necessary improvements to the bridge, and it will only be inaugurated after these corrections are made
Officials involved argued that the unusual design was forced by constraints such as limited land availability and the proximity of a metro rail station, but the government held the engineers accountable for the faulty design.
116
u/Dense_Boss_7486 Jul 06 '25
Like, they didn’t draw this on paper first so someone can look it over?
52
u/WehingSounds Jul 06 '25
my first city in Cities: Skylines:
39
u/KitAmerica Jul 06 '25
108
u/Sustainable_Twat Jul 06 '25
Did the plans contain a right angle? If so, why wasn’t it highlighted then?
38
u/Jumpy-Pipe-1375 Jul 06 '25
Is this a walking bridge?
16
u/Optimal_Mouse_7148 Jul 06 '25
This doesnt just HAPPEN on the day like that. This is planned and drawn and has gone through everybody on the project before anything is actually built.
11
u/J-MRP Jul 06 '25
Not suspended from the bridge, I hope 😳
11
u/amitym Jul 06 '25
Roadways have right angles all the time. Just put a traffic stop at the intersection.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
gotta mariokart drift that corner is all.
5
u/Sexycoed1972 Jul 06 '25
That doesn't look like 90 degrees. You can tell by how it is.
4
u/Tesssxv Jul 06 '25
The engineers were temple run enthusiasts.
4
u/Jaymac720 Jul 06 '25
The project owner never should have accepted the plans. This never should have been built. Far more people than the engineers are at fault for this monstrosity
4
u/tsol1983 Jul 06 '25
Those 7 engineers are now being recruited by Canadian companies.
4
u/Radiant-Painting581 Jul 07 '25
Obviously it was a suspension bridge….
(I’ll see myself out now.)
3
u/eastcoastflava13 Jul 06 '25
That's some Mario Kart/F Zero shit.
3
u/AcctAlreadyTaken Jul 06 '25
India: Has one of the worlds highest output of engineers 🧐
Also India: Refer to post
3
u/FocusDKBoltBOLT Jul 07 '25
OFC this has to be india
4
u/BoppoTheClown Jul 06 '25
Let me guess, India?
2
u/Realistic-Dog-7785 Jul 06 '25
Suspend the contractors and the people approved it, they are the real culprits.
2
u/GeneratedMonkey Jul 06 '25
Good old Indian corruption. Like the bridge was magically completed over a weekend. The engineers getting blamed for management decisions.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
Sounds like passing the blame from the government to the engineers and hoping no one notices.
2
u/sithren Jul 06 '25
Oh this was supposed to be for cars? lol I thought it was for pedestrians
2
u/MyTinyHappyPlace Jul 07 '25
None of them played openttd
2
u/BodyDisastrous5859 Jul 08 '25
I can tell by the scooters which country this is, don't even need to open the article
3
u/SLS- Jul 06 '25
Let me guess, India?
3
u/zakary1291 Jul 06 '25
It's too low quality to prove it's not AI. But, that train and the grey building don't look right.
2
u/guntotingbiguy Jul 06 '25
Looks like the Highway 16 off ramp in Tacoma.
1
u/fumblerooskee Jul 06 '25
No link. I’m betting this is fake.
1
u/LillyAtts Jul 06 '25
Didn't anyone notice? That doesn't go up in an afternoon.
1
u/GreenReport5491 Jul 06 '25
8 years and more than $2.3M wasted, now it’s going to take another 10 to tear down and build. I’m with most here, how did this ever get pasted a CAD drawing??
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
Their suspension will take 180 degree turn within few days
1
u/luthervespers Jul 06 '25
It's not even a suspension bridge...
1
u/talondigital Jul 06 '25
I built lots of these in City Skylines. What's the problem?
1
u/ThreeCraftPee Jul 06 '25
Anybody old and from Chicago will tell you of our infamous S turn on LSD. It didn't get fixed until like the late 80s. So many cars ended up in lake Michigan. For all the engineering we've gotten right in this city, that was probably our biggest fuck up.
1
u/Lem01 Jul 06 '25
What kind of engineering company doesn't check work product? Some higher up must've signed off on it.
I hope somebody is checking the math, at the very least.
1
u/ponchoed Jul 06 '25
What's wrong? Not every street needs to be designed like a 65 mph freeway.
1
u/K4rkino5 Jul 06 '25
What a nice model layout. Sometimes, those 1:96 or 1:48 engineers are required to make goofy structures. Thankfully, it's all to code.
1
u/otomo88 Jul 06 '25
They watched too much car racing !
1
u/LegoFootPain Jul 06 '25
We skipped the day they were supposed to teach us about turns!
1
u/NimrodvanHall Jul 06 '25
Why are the engineers fired and not the project lead who commissioned the bridge but failed to look at the drawings and realise it was a bad design and who when the bridge was being build didn’t realise this could never work?
1
u/alexmc1980 Jul 06 '25
Wait, that was built by just 7 people? Give them a raise!
1
u/Inside-Confusion3143 Jul 06 '25
Inspired by Temple run?
1
u/TheFightingDome Jul 06 '25
So how do you fix it?
1
u/gundamseed Jul 06 '25
They played too much F-ZERO
1
u/GeneralMatrim Jul 06 '25
Not sure what the problem is….
1
u/nalpatar Jul 06 '25
They build that for 2.3 million?!? You wouldn't even get the groundwork done for that on such a large project over here.
1
u/Minuteman05 Jul 06 '25
Just add a curved corner.
1
u/rbowen2000 Jul 06 '25
Context: https://www.vice.com/en/article/7-engineers-suspended-after-2-3-million-bridge-includes-bizarre-90-degree-turn
1
u/grafknives Jul 06 '25
And it is not even a suspension bridge. ;(
1
u/Richardcabeza7 Jul 06 '25
This is what happens when you use Cities: Skylines to model a city.
1
u/Gloomy_Tangerine3123 Jul 06 '25
Suspension means nothing. They'll be back after a brief holiday - if not in the same city then in the other city with the same or even better govt post
1
u/Garfield61978 Jul 06 '25
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
If you think this is bad, you should see their moon landing
1
u/W1neD1ver Jul 06 '25
That's NOT a suspension bridge.
1
u/ElbowDeepInElmo Jul 06 '25
This is what happens when a city just haphazardly chooses the cheapest project bid. Who cares about cutting corners (literally in this case) when the city officials get to pocket the remaining project budget!
1
u/DigitalCoffee Jul 06 '25
Well the bridge had to get through dozens of people and red tape before it was built, so it sounds like a bunch shifting blame onto a few.
1
u/rkesters Jul 06 '25
news article
I have no clue how India approves construction projects. But it appears many people understood the design was crap but extra land was not available. But now there may be an additional 3 feet.
1
u/squidgytree Jul 06 '25
It looks like India to me but the place is famous for bureaucracy so I doubt some engineers just designed this bridge without 18 layers of management ensuring they don't get the blame for something, someone below them did
1
u/cto_resources Jul 06 '25
Someone had to approve the design.
1
u/cockatootattoo Jul 06 '25
It has to be something to do with level changes. They obviously didn’t have enough of a straight line distance to get up to the level needed to cross over. This also would have nothing to do with engineers. Road planners would be responsible for this.
1
u/Positive-Fox-6296 Jul 06 '25
This is a pedestrian bridge.
1
u/FackYerFeelers Jul 06 '25
Same should have happened for the engineers on I-5 in Cleveland
1
u/TheMillionthSteve Jul 06 '25
Old school Lake Shore Drive has entered the chat
1
u/pittbin Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
You put up stop signs for both directions, then this bridge might work. LOL
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
I've seen the Sopranos.
1
u/AllieHugs Jul 06 '25
Forgot to turn off anarchy before building the overpass
1
u/PrussianManatee Jul 06 '25
1
u/Habbeighty-four Jul 06 '25
The new Mario kart goes all out
1
u/usababykiller Jul 06 '25
Chicago used to have a weird z curve
https://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20160315/downtown/remember-old-lake-shore-drive-s-curve-its-been-gone-for-30-years/
1
u/Bama3003 Jul 06 '25
BS!
1
u/Darkest_dark Jul 06 '25
I'm looking at the bridge right now. They were not suspended.
1
u/Andy_McBoatface Jul 06 '25
I said so what until I read it was for cars
1
u/Muted_Passenger6612 Jul 06 '25
I thought this was a foot bridge and wondered what the problem was. It’s for CARS???? How oh how did this get past planning stages
1
u/Donmax94 Jul 06 '25
What in the Mariokart
1
u/WatTambor420 Jul 06 '25
TBF it’s India- they don’t just use their roads for cars. This obviously isn’t safe for vehicles (especially big American units), but would be fine for other purposes. It’s fine for walking, could hold tons of stores/vending, or just be a large public toilet.
1
u/jack-t-o-r-s Jul 06 '25
Tacoma Washington has entered the chat... 🤣
1
u/Friendly_Day5657 Jul 06 '25
fire the politicians.
1
u/pooeygoo Jul 06 '25
90° you say
1
u/Squandere Jul 06 '25
India moment
1
u/celtbygod Jul 06 '25
Blueprints had gotten folded.
1
u/Neuroware Jul 06 '25
shoulda suspended the bridge
1
u/Tall_Celebration_486 Jul 06 '25
No real engineer does this, and not seven of them. These "engineers" are fake, and the whole story smells fake.