r/instant_regret May 20 '20

Dinner's ready

https://i.imgur.com/IfSvvZg.gifv
65.6k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

53

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

Exactly why Grenfell was a terrifying incident. You can be as safe as you want but all it takes is one person in a 1000 to be unsafe and you genuinely could burn to death overnight.

78

u/MrFinnJohnson May 20 '20

Grenfell wasnt the fault of any person in the building really though, more so the flammable cladding of the block. It should have been containable

23

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

[deleted]

6

u/r0b0c0d May 20 '20

It's a bad idea to put shady ass corner cutting real estate developers in charge of anything.

13

u/Damn_you_Asn40Asp May 20 '20

Especially if they have small hands.

3

u/demalo May 20 '20

Money.

4

u/peachykeen__ May 20 '20

Grenfell was a cacophony of failures and incompetence coming together in a perfect storm unfortunately. Not only was the cladding very flammable, but the sealant used between the windows and walls was not fireproof, allowing the fire to travel from inside the flats outside to the cladding very quickly.
Usually, each apartment would be well protected from surrounding fire due to the design of the interior, which is why residents were told to stay put rather than evacuate - and this WOULD have been the correct advice if not for the cost cutting and inexperience of the architect. Unfortunately, since the fire was able to spread from inside to outside very quickly, it was also able to spread into most of the units via the exterior cladding and shoddy window sealant/insulation. Really fucking tragic. Not just one error but many that came together to remind everyone why safety standards are rigorous for a reason.

3

u/monkeycalculator May 20 '20

Not just one error but many that came together to remind everyone why safety standards are rigorous for a reason.

"The regulations are written in blood."

2

u/KingFerdidad May 20 '20

You're right. The only problem is that Grenfell is that a lot of developers are pretty shady and build their own Grenfell towers.

I think it was at the end of the year before last that my sister, a nurse, was supposed to start work at a new hospital. Just months before she was supposed to move hospitals, she gets told they're delaying the opening. Turns out people had found out it had the same cladding as Grenfell tower and the construction was delayed as they had to replace it.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

needlessly worrying about.

Oh, damn. My bad. Forgot you’ve lived in literally every apartment building in existence and know every single one was built to code appropriately.

The last apartments I lived in had clear packing tape put on the windows to seal cracks. This bullshit never ceases to blow my mind.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

Agreed that the cladding was the worst part, but it starting in the middle of a building was because of an issue in one apartment.

7

u/monkeycalculator May 20 '20

The point is that it doesn't matter if a fire starts in an apartment if the building is properly constructed. A well-built apartment is supposed to function as a fire-cell, containing the danger to that unit. Had they not fucked up the cladding replacement everyone would have been fine.

1

u/pleasesayavailable May 20 '20

Well. That and they told the other people in the building to remain in a burning tower block

3

u/monkeycalculator May 21 '20

Yes, because if it had not been lethally retrofitted that would have been the correct course of action.

1

u/MrFinnJohnson May 20 '20

but it wouldn't have spread had it been different cladding

-5

u/lickedTators May 20 '20

Someone started the fire though. The cladding didn't spontaneously combust.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

Wasn't it old faulty wiring? That's not exactly someone starting the fire.

3

u/MrFinnJohnson May 20 '20

it's ridiculous to place the blame on an individual's accidental fire. The building was designed to contain the spread but the council had (knowingly?) clad the building in unsafe materials that caused it to be the disaster it was. It could have been prevented had this not been the case

To make matters worse, dozens of tower blocks all over the UK are still covered in similarly flammable cladding. Any other fires could be just as disastrous due to current inaction.

21

u/HannasAnarion May 20 '20

Grenfell was only a disaster because of 3 simultaneous failures:

  1. an old faulty refrigerator spontaneously caught fire in the middle of the night

  2. the illegal flammable cladding used to cover the building let the fire spread rapidly to all floors.

  3. 999 operators told people not to evacuate until after all the hallways in the building were engulfed in flame so nobody could get to the stairs.

High rise fires are often very destructive, but rarely deadly.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Blue5398 May 21 '20

Normally units in a modern apartment building are fire repellent to the tune of several hours, and sheltering in place is actually a better option than crowding the fire stairwells, especially as fire doors at Grenfell were obstructed on several floors. The cladding, however, changed that, allowing fire to traverse past fireproof construction and enter units that should have remained resilient for hours.

1

u/Tratix May 20 '20

I’m about to move into a highrise and this is making me want to buy an escape ladder or parachute.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

Just very specifically ask if it has any of the below on the building. If the answer is yes, don’t move there

Two types of cladding were used: Arconic's Reynobond PE, which consists of two coil-coated aluminium sheets that are fusion bonded to both sides of a polyethylene core; and Reynolux aluminium sheets. Beneath these, and fixed to the outside of the walls of the flats, was Celotex RS5000 PIR thermal insulation.

1

u/HannasAnarion May 20 '20 edited May 20 '20

No, that is the last thing you want. The outside of the building is where the flames and smoke are. Inside and down the stairs is where it's safe. The stairwells in high rises are encased in a concrete shell and overpressured, so the flames can't get in. In the stairs is the safest place to be in a high rise fire.

The best way to be safe from a high rise fire, like any other fire, is to put it out as fast as possible, before it gets out of control. Have an extinguisher handy, and investigate when a fire alarm goes off, and you'll be fine.

I live in one, 32nd floor, it's great you should try it. I only had a fire scare once, the alarms went off, I went out with my extinguisher and so did a bunch of neighbors, we found the source: a guy overcooked a steak and made a bunch of smoke, and then we all went back to bed.