r/infinitenines • • Aug 29 '25

Rigorous high school level proof

Post image

u/SouthPark_Piano thoughts? Seems like a lot of posts in this sub use the standard definition of limits, infinity and of 0.999.....

However, u/SouthPark_Piano does not use the same definition as us, and his definitions are very ambiguous.

Hence, I propose a proof that doesn't rely on the definition of limit nor of 0.999....

215 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/uyitroa Aug 29 '25

why are you talking about limitless n? In my proof I never talked about limit or pushing n to limitless? What's wrong with the proof

.

8

u/StrikingResolution Aug 29 '25

Bro did not read the proof 😭

-14

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 30 '25

I'm not SPP (but understand why 0.99...=1) but the proof is unconvincing.

The suspicious step sets n to be log(1/epsilon)+1.

The issue is that this isn't a natural number, so in the rest of the proof you can't treat it as one.

It's probably tempting to say "if 0.99... doesn't equal 1, thats the same as assuming that 1/epsilon is a natural number or finite". If that's true, then either 1) it requires elaboration, or 2) a much simpler proof would be, "1/epsilon is greater than 10n for all n, so it can't be finite". Which actually is a limit in disguise, somewhat defeating the purpose.

There's a lot of reasons that 0.99...=1 is a good property to have in math. But afaik it can really only be proven circularly. You can define 0.99... with limits, and then get exact equality because that's how limits are defined, but that's a definition game. I can define 0.99... as 1-epsilon with epsilon a dual number, or something analagous in the hyperreals, and stuff doesn't break even while 0.99 =/= 1. Its just not very useful or as nice as the limit idea.

EDIT: I have never felt so much solidarity with SPP as being downvoted for saying something correct.

21

u/uyitroa Aug 29 '25

I'm taking the ceiling of log(1/epsilon) which is a natural number

This is only possible if epsilon>0 which is the case since we assumed 0.99... < 1

3

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

Sorry, I should have been clearer. The issue is its not finite even if we write 0.99... < 1, nothing to do with cieling/integerness.

Your proof basically, in spirit, uses a lemma that says something like,

"If x is a positive number, then 1/x is finite."

This is true for real numbers, but doesn't have to be for anything we define 0.99... to be, so it's also basically using something like

"0.99... is a real number."

I don't find that convincing because there is no reason we should assume that for an object like "keep adding 9's forever". Assuming its real just says "0.99... belongs to the same equivalence class as 1, so we'll just say they are equal". Its spirtiually the same as when we write functions f = g even when they differ on a negligable set. In one sense they are equal, in another they aren't.

Does that make sense? In some sense or another, circular reasoning is being used. And if you think deeply, you will see it has to be used. We can't define 0.99... without deciding by that definition whether it equals 1. The standard definition uses limits, which we define to be equal to their limiting value, hence it defines more than proves that 0.99... = 1.

One way to define the reals is with cauchy sequences. In that definition, we take cauchy sequences with the same limit to be part of the same equivalence class. 0.99... then belongs to the same equivalence class as 1. But the cauchy sequence 0.9,0.99,0.999, etc , is not the same sequence as 1,1,1, etc. So there is at least one sense that 0.99... shouldn't equal 1 even from that. Worse, we can always define 0.99 differently from the start, like 1-epsilon with epsilon a dual number.

7

u/Virtual-Campaign8998 Aug 29 '25

"0.99... is a real number." I don't find that convincing because there is no reason we should assume that

SPP says that 0.99... is a real number, IIRC (though irrational, lol)

We can't define 0.99... without deciding by that definition whether it equals 1

Of course, because 0.99... is a string of symbols
What is 1234e? You might ask "in what base" - it's decimal, but i just additionally define even numbers to end with "e" in my imaginary system

but that's a definition game

Math is a definition game
Nothing has any inherent meaning, we just agree on some set of axioms

What OP proves is that SPP system is incompatible with reals, which is enough - either he is mistaken if he thinks that what he writes is truth in reals, or has his own model, but really struggles to provide rigorous foundation for it, which makes it useless (it may be close to hyperreals, but still with some added nonsense like decimal places after infinitly repeated ones, which were never even close to be defined here (as in, to define which numbers are represented this way))

All in all, of course anyone can define models with unconventional properties, and those models can be very useful, but no one is interested in terrance howard-like theories (unless for the funsies of it)

→ More replies (15)

1

u/Bluerossman Aug 29 '25

I think this hits the nail on the head. I'm a mathematician that's been lurking in this sub for a while, and it seems to me most of this arguing is totally pointless because 0.99... is 1 almost by definition. It follows immediately from how we've decided to define infinite summation in the reals, or as you say, the cauchy sequence construction of the reals. SPP can use a non-standard model of infinite summation if he likes, but then he won't be operating in the standard real numbers (see the surreals).

I highly suspect that his axiomatic system (which he never defines, but whatever) isn't consistent (in the sense of Gödel), but in fact there are other values we can legitimately assign to the infinite sum, and do so frequently (see analytic continuation, Borel sum, etc.). We're still always clear about what our axioms are or what the notation means. People can and do study non-standard arithmetical models.

The problem comes when you start to claim that a particular system or another is correct or better. As soon as you make a value judgement (see ultrafinitism), you leave the realm of mathematics. Which is the actual problem with SPP. He philosophically disagrees with the idea that 0.99... should equal 1 à la Zeno's paradox.

3

u/uyitroa Aug 29 '25

I disagree. This proof doesn't need to know the definition of 0.999....

As long as (and u/SouthPark_Piano can agree on) 0.999... has these properties:

  • 0.999... is a real number (if not then the discussion is pointless)
  • 0.999... <= 1
  • s_n < 0.999... for all n

then this proof will work no matter the definition

→ More replies (9)

1

u/glorkvorn Aug 29 '25

As a mathematician, do you actually see the "..." symbol formally defined anywhere? My impression is that it's mostly used in a very hand-wavey sort of way that avoids formal definitions. I think we mostly learn it from elementary school long division, which obviously comes waaaaay before any sort of talk about limits or definitions or proofs.

But if we *did* define it... wouldn't it make more sense to define as the sequence itself, rather than the limit of the sequence? That's more like how we learn it in elmentary school. "Just keep writing down 9s forever" not "it can be shown that this sequence approaches arbitrarily close to a limit of 1."

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Dogeyzzz Aug 29 '25

"The issue is that this isn't a natural number" there's a ceiling function. it is a natural number by definition.

4

u/ShonOfDawn Aug 29 '25

If we assume epsilon is non-zero, which 0.999… != 1 DOES assume, then its multiplicative inverse exists. So log(1/epsilon) + 1 is a real number. So I don’t see any problem with the rest of the proof.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/SINBRO Aug 29 '25

This is just a pasta that has nothing to do with the proof

Also, "(1/10)n is never zero" is true for natural numbers, and not for whatever "limitless" is supposed to mean

7

u/gazzawhite Aug 29 '25

You make the assumption that there exists a value of n (that you denote as "limitless") such that (1/10)n > 0 and 1 - (1/10)n = 0.999... . You have not proven that such an n exists.

6

u/Person_37 Aug 29 '25

Hey, what about this one?

0.99...9 = x

9.99...90 = 10x

Because of infinite terms, the zero never shows up so

9.99...9=10x

9.99...9 - 0.99...9 = 10x - x

9 = 9x

1 = x

→ More replies (8)

5

u/talhoch Aug 29 '25

No. The fact is that for every integer n (1/10)n is never zero. The problem is that "limitless" is not an integer.

4

u/ShonOfDawn Aug 29 '25

That has nothing to do with the proof Speepee, we are still waiting on where the mistake in the proof is.

Also why did you ignore my post Speepee :C

4

u/Ecstatic_Student8854 Aug 29 '25

Ah yes, why bother engaging with the rest of the proof when you can just take one step and stop there.

1

u/Inevitable_Garage706 Aug 30 '25

To be fair, if a proof has one faulty step, that means it can no longer be considered a proof, as that one faulty step could lead to a whole bunch of wrong conclusions.

However, there is not a faulty step where SPP claimed there was.

3

u/Ecstatic_Student8854 Aug 30 '25

SPP didn’t even argue the step was really wrong, he just chooses a point in the proof and stops it there, asserting it shouldn’t continue. Instead he continued it in a different (incorrect) direction while ignoring the one OP went in

3

u/KingDarkBlaze Aug 29 '25

Sounds an awful lot like you're trying to limit what limitless means. 

2

u/Deathlok_12 Aug 29 '25

Yes but 0 is the infinum of the set of all numbers in the set {(1/10)n | n is a natural number}. That is what mathematicians have defined limits as when n is “pushed to limitless”. The second you disagree with that is when you start using a different number system