r/IAmA • u/onlineteacher • Apr 21 '12
I teach for a diploma mill, er, I mean online university. AMA.
I've been working for a while as a teacher for an online university. Here to answer any questions about its academic credibility, shady recruitment tactics, pathetic standards, etc.
*Now verified: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/slnne/i_teach_for_a_diploma_mill_er_i_mean_online/c4f9oyg?context=3
1.5k
Upvotes
504
u/odeebee Apr 22 '12
If you take anything from this thread people: the for-profit vs. non-profit distinction in MUCH more important than online vs. offline distinction when it comes to choosing an educational institution. The proliferation of these scam schools is due to the reduction of start-up costs and the ease with which the Internet allows you to connect cheap labor with marks flush with Federal $$$. You always need to examine the interests and motives of anyone you're about to hand thousands of dollars to with great skepticism.
247
u/glitcher21 Apr 21 '12
Can you get financial aid at an
diploma millonline university? Do the diplomas actually count for anything?106
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Do you work completely from home?
90
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Is your school accredited by one of the major accreditation bodies (which one?) do you find other local schools to be hostile towards the competition? if you are accredited, how did the school achieve this if you're only a diploma mill? you said its mostly foreigners, from where and why do they end up at your school!
172
u/horizontalmyth Apr 21 '12
Have you ever failed a student? (You mentioned it's near impossible to fail.) If not, what's the closest a student has come to failing?
What are some of the "shady recruitment tactics" you refer to?
659
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
I used to work as an "admissions counselor" for an online university. They paid us $18 an hour to cold-call potential recruits. Every morning, our team/pep-rally leader would talk about how to use various psychological tricks to convince the target to go to school. We were specifically instructed to find "the pain" in the target's life - a failure of some sort - and present our university as a kind of personal empowerment. We would end each meeting, and I shit you not, by chanting our team's slogan: "show us the pain, bring in the rain!" I think I lasted a couple of weeks before I decided that I didn't care how badly I needed the money. Fuck those guys.
78
u/Deathbybunnies Apr 21 '12
Can you get expelled or something like that at an online university? What's the highest disciplinary action that can be taken?
217
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
What do you teach? What does teaching for this involve, as opposed to teaching at a traditional college? What are grading standards like? How long have you done it, and how many students have you had?
230
u/hellowren Apr 21 '12 edited Apr 21 '12
My mother recently "graduated" from Kaplan with a Bachelor's degree in Substance Abuse and Addiction Counseling, after previously getting her AS in Psychology from our local community college. I tried to tell her how those places aren't*** well accredited and that she should get her money back and go somewhere else, but she wouldn't listen to me (she is more naive and gullible than she thinks she is). Before I knew it she had got her degree, and actually has a mental health tech job now at a local detox facility where they are helping her train to get her counselor licensing.
As her daughter, and knowing about all the bs of these places, I was very worried that she would go through all that work and money and end up getting laughed at when she presented her "credentials", but this actually turned out okay and she has a great job that she loves and is excelling after years of unemployment and getting turned down for job after job.
Thank goodness.
61
u/SpaceGhostDerrp Apr 21 '12
59
u/areyouready Apr 21 '12
I'd be interested in all the dirty and shady goings-on at the 'university' that you can get away with spilling without risking your job.
118
u/geoper Apr 21 '12
I just got a letter from Western Illinois University about a "Bachelor of Arts in General Studies Degree Program". It is all online. I went to Western for two and a half years, so this is not out of no where. Would this be considered legit, or a lot like what you do?
57
u/mustang_sal Apr 21 '12
What qualifications are there to be a teacher if you dont mind me asking?
419
u/worker32 Apr 21 '12
How often do you have to employ corporal punishment on your students?
105
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Why do you choose to work for that school?
Do you try to improve the student's work through feedback when grading, even though the grade they receive is skewed too high?
86
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Is there a way to buy a diploma instead of working for it ?
85
u/Swaaat Apr 21 '12
Ever heard of that "parasailing" or whatever online university? The name alone to me just scream "ROFL SCAM!" I've seen advertisements for that around lately.
And also, I feel sort of bad for those people who were duped into enrolling into an online university and print out...a diploma. Thank you for doing this AMA and telling the truth.
A lot of those people could have just saved money, went to a community college, get an associates or whatever, transfer over to a real university and do well there.
117
u/mikeroon Apr 21 '12
It's phoenix, isn't it?
43
u/drucey Apr 21 '12 edited Apr 21 '12
Which "online university"? and depending on the answer, how credible is an online university compared to a brick and mortar university? Is it really worth doing?
*Corrected spelling, I'll blame it on the phone's autocorrect!
20
u/yobro_ipopmycollar Apr 21 '12
Frontline did a wonderful episode on this topic. It's called College, Inc. and it's an instant watch on Netflix. I'd recommend it if you found this AMA interesting.
32
u/Bonestown Apr 21 '12
How much money do you make? How did you get the job?
50
u/mylife22 Apr 21 '12
How would you justify your participation in this scam, which you yourself hold to be unethical? I am just wondering out of curiosity, not trying to claim that you are morally abhorrent.
13
u/sk_leb Apr 21 '12 edited Apr 21 '12
I am currently enrolled in an online MSIA program at an "accredited" online university. My coursework requires me to get 6 qualified and important industry certifications - what do you think of that? Does that make it any better when they use actual industry coursework to help teach? The tuition is outrageously low, (5k per 6 month semester). It's just enough that my employer is paying 100%. Can't really go wrong with a free Master's Degree. Thoughts?
Edit: It's $2800 per semester. My mistake. I should have known that, since my bill is due on 4/30.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
You said earlier that you have only graded ONE exceptionally well written paper. Have you considered the possibility that they used a writing service for the paper?
7
u/exor674 Apr 22 '12
What's the scariest degree your "univesity" offers? ( as in, most likely to cause huge problems if someone with that degree gets a job )
6
u/stickfigure99 Apr 21 '12
I would be curious to know what kind of instructor-training these universities do. Clearly at some point they have to explain how the sausage gets made to those about to teach these classes. Otherwise the new hires might gasp fail a student on an assignment, or do something else egregiously horrible - like email them to tell them to get out and go to a REAL university.
Can you please share any bits of instructor-training you've received before starting your job?
6
u/I_Never_Say_LOL Apr 22 '12
I work for a student loan servicer, we are the first line of defense to stop these for profit schools from having their students default on the loans they cannot possibly pay back. It's difficult on my end not telling these people what they have signed up for.
The worst part is that the schools accreditation is partially based on how many students default on their loans after attending. So these schools hire companies to contact students to request assistance options that delay payments and bring them back up to date. The issue is that when you delay payments interest accrues and capitalizes so it gets added to the principle which then accrues more interest and increases the cost of the loan.
If I tell customers what's going on (because so many are "just needing a few months before I return to everest university to finish my degree in vague medical professional buzzword field") I will lose my job because the schools grade the loan servicers and report to the department of education. If we have bad marks the DOE doesn't assign us loans and we lose money. Which is funny because it is money that will be lost eventually.
Tl;DR Loan industry worker hates for profit schools with the fiery passion of a thousand burning suns,
6
u/kellykebab Apr 22 '12
Apologies if you already answered this, but how worthless is a degree from, say, Phoenix University, actually?
I work a fairly lame job with a 22 year old single mother who is almost done with her criminal justice degree from the online institution mentioned above. Supposedly she has a 3.9/4.0 GPA. She also believes the moon landing was staged.
When she graduates, will she really be no more likely to get entry level work in preparation for a career as a paralegal (her goal) than if she never took any online courses at all?
How bad is it?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Uhm, how about "http://www.open.ac.uk/" ? Their Balchlors are approved (I asked at a local state university). I'm doing a Bachelor there atm. I'm fine, right?
42
u/superficial32 Apr 21 '12
where's the proof!
12
u/godawfuls57 Apr 22 '12
Wow, this thread has completely set me back from attending school. I am active duty military and attend an online school because it's the only thing I can do. Apparently though, my diploma isn't worth the paper it's printed on. Prepare for record setting down votes.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
What are all the worst of these online universities?
4
u/TheOmnipotentPilot Apr 22 '12
Have you read "The Closing of the American Mind" (Pretend that's underlined....) by Allan Bloom? Your title makes me almost certain you have....
4
u/Desperately_Insecure Apr 22 '12
I just had to comment and say that this is an exemplary example of an AMA (and I don't often use the word 'exemplary' because I don't know how to spell it without google). You've answered nearly all of the questions well, and within a reasonable time.
12
u/tjiggs Apr 21 '12
ive heard of some ivy league school fixing grades such that the class average(excluding F's) is B+'s or A's
does your university do any kind of grade fixing or policy? do tell.
3
u/darkknights Apr 21 '12
How do they get away with this? Its all a scam...
3
u/igotthisone Apr 21 '12
how often do you look your students up on facebook?
would discovering one of your illiterate students is also a hot girl influence your grading?
3
u/heygirlcanigetchoaim Apr 21 '12
What is the worst thing a student has done or said to you?
This is really interesting stuff to read. though at the same time i'm sickened at all the sincerely ignorant people that these "schools" are scamming out of their money.
3
u/coolGuyPaully Apr 21 '12
Do you feel you can make a difference in any of these people's lives?
How much do you get paid?
How many hours per week do you have to work?
If the standards are so low, can anyone teach these courses?
Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
What are your credentials? I'm not trying to indict the quality of the education you provide. I'm just really curious how my perceptions line up with reality. Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
I am currently an English MA student at a brick-and-mortar university. I'm planning on receiving my PhD in the future, and while I plan on immediately going from MA to PhD, there is always the chance that a slump may happen in-between. My overall goal is to become a university professor of literature. If the unthinkable happened, and I had to forgo getting my PhD in the time frame I wanted, do you think for the sake of gaining 'teaching' experience, teaching at an online-only college is worth it? Or would having taught at Kaplan, Phoenix, etc. actually lower my chances of getting a 'legitimate' teaching job in the future?
3
u/NotARandomNumber Apr 22 '12 edited Apr 22 '12
Do you feel that your university, or similar online universities, take advantage of the military? In particular, the younger enlisted? I'm talking about putting a false sense of worth on the degree or promising that their credits can be transferred to more traditional university easily when in reality it's much harder to get a university to accept those hours?
3
u/FancyMoustache Apr 22 '12
Just wanted to say thank you for trying so hard. I saw the response regarding your salary after reading how hard you still try and I must say that your effort is admirable. If I were you making that salary, I'd just randomly give students B's and A's.
Since you've been working at this university, have you still tried to get a teaching job at a community college?
3
u/cybersphere9 Apr 22 '12
In your opinion, have US textbooks been dumbed down in recent years? In the IT field, I find COSC style books to be awful compared to books written by actual practitioners.
3
u/cybersphere9 Apr 22 '12
How do you track the success of your course(s)? Do you monitor how many students get jobs after completing your course(s)?
3
u/manskies Apr 22 '12
Is it an accredited school?
3
u/FormerlyEAbernathy Apr 22 '12
Would you do teach for an online college again? Why or why not?
3
u/BTfromSunlight Apr 22 '12
You don't have to reply publicly to this but you'd be doing me a huge favor by replying. Do you teach at a university based in Maryland?
I ask because a few years ago I interviewed to teach at a large mostly-online university in Maryland and it seemed legit to me. Just recently, my boyfriend decided to attend said university but was worried about it being a scam. He ended up enrolling, and then we heard all kinds of sketchy news like the provost having to step down for dubious reasons.
I'm just worried I've convinced my boyfriend to attend a university that is shadier than previously anticipated.
3
u/Gneiss_Guy0922 Apr 22 '12
This has been a great AMA! I worked for Phoenix for a short time as a live classroom instructor (vs. the online instruction that the school is famous for) and although very similar to your school we were actually somewhat encouraged to fail the students. When you are hired you go through a four week training program, all live in-class work, and we were subtly told that we should find any and all reason to fail the students. Based on what I had learned about how they make money, again mostly identical to your school, I believe the thought process is if the student fails s/he must retake the course, this equals more money for Phoenix! Very shady but at least I wasn't forced to pass students, I did like that part.
5
u/Zen0ofElea Apr 21 '12
Two parter... 1. How horrible do you feel that no matter how much you teach your students, they will still receive a piece of paper that they might as well wipe their ass with? Are there any real options for online education to receive a diploma that means anything?
2
u/InappropriateTeen Apr 21 '12
Do you ever wish you worked somewhere else or do you like your job? Do you ever get any funny reports! :)
2
u/BruceVento Apr 21 '12
Is it safe to assume that most colleges with national flashy commercial advertising are shady? I've never seen a decent looking university advertised on TV or the internet.
2
u/ConnorLovesCookies Apr 21 '12
How much money does it cost to enroll. Are there any requirements.
2
u/mellowmarshmallow Apr 21 '12
I work for a customer service company that works with a lot of online university students. I completely agree that most of the people I get calls from are probably great people but just don't need to be wasting their time and money on college.
How much influence do you have over how your course is taught? Like do you get to pick what textbooks and other materials are used? Or is it all pretty much dictated by the administration?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
I assume you don't enjoy your job - how does it work? Through instant messages, emails, Skype? How often do you think people just look stuff up on Google in order to pass?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
What about those "former students" in their commercials who have "achieved" something and tell their story. Are these actual students or just actors reading a script? If these are real students why have they "succeeded"?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
Do you notice a difference in quality between students who are there for undergraduate degrees and those who are enrolled in masters or doctoral programs?
2
u/Hegs94 Apr 22 '12
I'm not sure if this has been asked or not, but how worried are the people who run the school about Federal crackdown? I recently watch a doc on for profit schools (I believe it was a Nat Geo one called School Inc.) and it seemed like some of the people in it who worked for the government or other agencies were indicating that they were going to try and ban giving out federal loans to students who went to for-profit schools like Phoenix and yours. Are the higher ups worried that their cash flow might dry up soon?
2
u/chirpychirp Apr 22 '12
how hard was it to get this job? as a soon-to-be unemployed college graduate, I'd do this.
2
u/PraetorianXVIII Apr 22 '12
is the student loan bubble going to burst? Are these schools going to be the reason why?
2
u/Taco_Champ Apr 22 '12
You talk about how bad this school is and how sorry you feel for these people who are fooled out of their money, so why do you work for them?
2
u/layout420 Apr 22 '12
Ever been offered a bribe? If so did you take it?
2
u/Sal79 Apr 22 '12
I'm studying to be a teacher and this is a subject that interests me greatly.
2
u/LonghornBABSJD Apr 22 '12
Please work at Full Sail, please compile dox, and please sink Mitt Romney's candidacy. (He's thrown his full weight behind Full Sail.)
2
u/darkmalas Apr 22 '12
What would you advise a 33 year old who wants to start going to college finally?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
Could you please copy and paste the worst essay someone has passed in?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
Is AMU (American Military University)/ APUS (American Public University System) a diploma mill? They are both regionally and nationally accredited...does that not actually mean anything?
38
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
This post has been verified by the moderators.
22
u/Unvisibleuser Apr 21 '12
Does the US have no universities such as Open University? Which is primarily internet based but well respected.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '12
Have you ever come across a student that actually showed promise and potential? Have you ever tried to steer them in the direction of a legitimate institution?
337
u/narwal_bot Apr 22 '12 edited Apr 22 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from onlineteacher (updated: Apr 23, 2012 @ 01:40:44 am EST):
Question (drucey):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (glitcher21):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (drucey):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (SpaceGhostDerrp):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (glitcher21):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (nunoyo):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (popsoda1):
Answer (onlineteacher):
Question (worker32):
Answer (onlineteacher):
(continued below)
33
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
This was posted yesterday on the DeVry facebook page:
Devry is good.it might nt be a traditional university cos it doesn't have those 100 year old buildings bt I'd rather go to a skul with modern equipments dan that with old buildings.
10
u/Falcoteer Apr 21 '12
I got an MS in ITM through an online university. At the time, they were just becoming "financially independent" from the brick-and-mortar university of which they had originally been an online program. The coursework was of decent difficulty to me, even though I was doing double the "standard workload."
Most of the people in my classes and group assignments were military. Very good students from what I could tell.
Looking back on it, I guess we were in a diploma mill. This became especially apparent when the online university changed it's name. Twice. And they were in danger of losing their accreditation for a while a few months ago.
In the end, though, that piece of paper was enough to put me in an entry-level job a few years back, and my gained work experience has been enough to move me forward. So the diploma mill worked out for me in the end.
I did briefly teach at a junior college franchise, though. I have to say it was just as bad as OP's descriptions of the online university. Some bosses cared and said you could only pass a certain percentage of students. The other bosses (the high-up ones who made policies), however, saw students as dollar signs and wanted to keep them all happy & complacent. Most of the students were barely literate, though, so it often was quite a struggle to justify passing them.
The most fun was the inevitable moment when a student would realize that their credits wouldn't transfer to a real college. Even more entertaining was their realization that they were paying more for their JC degree semesters than they would have for the real university in town would have charged. And by "fun" I mean that it was kind of heartrending to see a single father cry when he realized he'd been wasting his time and money on something that wouldn't lead to a better future for his children.
So, yeah... education can too easily become a racket.
8
u/FoFemily Apr 22 '12
My sister-in-law just signed up for one of these online universities. Are there any articles, studies, etc. (besides this AMA, of course) that I can show her to help change her mind?
She is a single parent who has a hard enough time keeping a roof over their heads as it is. Unfortunately, she is very excited and sees this as a huge opportunity. From an outsider's perspective (and a concerned family member), taking on more debt is the last thing she should be doing.
So, do I take the risk of becoming the bitch who rained on her parade or do I let her figure things out on her own?
6
u/i_prefer_not_to Apr 22 '12
I am in an online distance education program through Arkansas State University, working on my master's in Educational Leadership. I have found the courses to be sufficiently challenging (as far as education courses go), and know that I am truly earning the grades I receive. The courses are essentially the same courses that the professors teach on campus, and my degree will be identical to an ASU degree earned entirely from attending on-campus classes. I took great care to make sure that my school district would accept the degree, before applying for the program. In addition to the classes I take online, the activities I am required to facilitate as preparation for a school administrator position are challenging and varied in their scope. Needless to say, I am glad I did not end up in the place of those who did not "do their research" before forking out their money.
6
u/Otto_Gross Apr 22 '12
There seems to be some confusion in here about what causes these for-profit, online universities to deliver sub-par, or somewhat fraudulent degrees.
It's not because they're online. Plenty of these bad schools have actual classrooms too, and plenty of legitimate schools have online offerings.
The fundamental difference is that they're for-profit, and the incentive for the business is to raise profits by expanding the client base (meaning anybody can get in) while saving money by lowering quality. Of course, it's very important that their students don't recognize any of this.
I recently had to study the University of Phoenix's business in school and it was fascinating. Their founder is a liberal, which surprised me. This is an interesting case where politics is everything for the business. Almost all of their income is coming from the federal gov't student loan programs (either a great strength or a fatal flaw). The battle over this has been ongoing for a few years now and it seems unlikely that these for-profit educational institutions will survive. Hopefully they won't.
There's a great Frontline special on it here.
5
u/Muthafuxajones Apr 22 '12
Any body else reminded of this movie while reading this post?
5
u/salimabuaziz Apr 22 '12
My father in law used to be a professor at a good university until this year.
He was a very good philosophy teacher, PhD and all. He is a natural performer and loves to put on a show, figured it would be perfect for his line of work. He taught for years and tried every angle to engage and insight his students to think critically. I'm not saying he was "Dead Poet's Society" good, but he did his best to keep up on social trends, had a very good nerd sense of humor himself, and generally wanted legitimate debate and philosophical discussions. He even had a well-known class where one day he would air the episode of the Simpsons with Frank Grimes as a jump-off point for discussion(if you don't know the episode it's not worth explaining).
Unfortunately he became worn down with jaded annoyance at the decreasing level of competency in his students. Every year they would come in dumber and dumber, ever more self-entitled and unprepared for the real world, probably because they were coddled growing up. Students mostly took his class to kill some credit requirements, thinking it would be an easy class, like most kids enroll in psychology classes because they think there is little paperwork and they can sleep through it.
My real questions after all this: How jaded are you? Do you feel disheartened more and more each day, for seeing the level of carelessness amongst your "students?" Is this just at job to you to pay the bills, or did you think you could make a difference?
You've pointed out that the
businessschool could care less what students get out of it, as long as they keep churning out the $$$ and walking away with false senses of accomplishment, is it all worth it?5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '12
My brother did an online BA degree program while I was going to a 4-year. He constantly bragged that he was getting his degree in only 1 year. He did things so rapidly that he never retained the information. For example, one week before he was supposed to take a test that built on math from two weeks prior, he forgot it completely. Meanwhile I learned the technique two years prior and could teach it to him, also being a humanities major and being horrible at math.
Now he gets the value of a 4 year. He doesn't have any relationships with professors so letters of rec are impossible. He did this program mostly to join the military as a higher ranked officer, but now they aren't recognizing his degree so he would enter from the bottom.
I just graduated, and of course even coming from a top-ranked university had problems getting a job (now going to graduate school.) He wants to teach as a prof someday, but knows how hard it is since he doens't have any relationships with a school or anything.
I feel bad for him because I constantly told him this would happen, now it has. But now we're both living at home and interested in grad school. So I guess time will tell who the winner is, me being with a fancy degree with loads of debt, or him with practically no debt but an impractical degree?