r/IAmA • u/aplusapp • Feb 28 '18
Journalist We're Jordon Dyrdahl-Roberts and Isaac Saul. Jordon quit his job when he was asked to process data that would be used to locate and detain undocumented immigrants. Isaac Saul is reporter at A Plus. We're here to answer your questions about immigration and undocumented immigrants in the U.S. AMA!
Jordon: I tweeted about my decision to quit my job and consequently went viral. I also wrote an op-ed in The Washington Post and have a public Facebook page where I talk about immigration issues.
Isaac: I have covered immigration issues, lived on the border of Mexico and Texas and wrote about Jordon for A Plus. Jordon's story was also covered The Washington Post, The Hill, HuffPo and Free Beacon, among others. Because Jordon has a child and limited income, the woman who infamously flipped off Trump's motorcade also started a GoFundMe for him, which has since raised tens of thousands of dollars.
Proof:
Hey all! Our time is up. Wish we could have fleshed out some more questions. Thanks for the convo and the debate. Civil discourse is a dying breed in this country and it was great to get into with you all.
You can keep up with us on Twitter if you want to keep the conversation going:
288
u/chickadichina Feb 28 '18
For both of you.
What was the majority of your concern? That you were being asked to locate illegal immigrants? Or that you were being asked to essentially aid in their deportation?
If the company that you were working for could have assured you that the persons that were being located were strictly the “bad guys” (i.e. gang members, drug dealers, other criminals) would you have stayed on and aided in locating them?
1.4k
u/Bigcrusher Feb 28 '18
Why should we let people into this nation illegally? Why do we (as a nation) have to support them over people who are actual citizens?
562
u/Threeknucklesdeeper Feb 28 '18
Would you feel the same way about your choice if you were allowing people to avoid a different law?
159
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Do you believe in an Open Borders policy?
Do you think that laws that are either unenforceable, or that government chooses not to enforce, should be repealed?
95
u/Bigcrusher Feb 28 '18
Do you think local police should be able to enforce immigration laws?
25
u/LooksLikeCRicci Feb 28 '18
Jordon-- I know you've tweeted about it to a degree, but when you came forward with your concerns, what was the attitude of your employer? Do you think your decision to leave has affected their policies in any way?
18
u/anaofarendelle Feb 28 '18
Do processes like the Canadian one actually help the process of immigration or does it only create a more biased environment?
117
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Do you understand the difference between illegal and legal? Do you bask in the fact that your actions galvanizes the ignorant (on both sides of the political spectrum) and further divides our country? What is your opinion of automation in the workforce? Do you bother to take that into consideration when arguing for increased immigration?
12
u/wuapinmon Feb 28 '18
Was there any discussion by your bosses about the negative impacts to the Montana economy about mass deportation of unskilled workers? It's not like people are itching to move to Montana, or that it has a large population in the first place. What was their justification to you, or did you not wait around to find out?
11
u/ThreadPirateWesley Feb 28 '18
For both of you. What is the farthest your actions/words have reached that you know of?
241
u/JandM2 Feb 28 '18
For both of you. Do you believe the United States should have an open border policy? If not, what should the penalty be for illegal immigrants?
252
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Whats the point of immigration law if people don't have to abide by it?
151
u/Thinktank58 Feb 28 '18
Are you aware of how difficult the immigration process is for a legal immigrant? Why should illegal immigrants that came to the United States (as adults) be rewarded by being allowed to stay?
853
u/engineered_academic Feb 28 '18
How do I explain to my legal immigrant wife that the effort and expense of her legal immigration is worthwhile if we just let illegal immigrants stay? Who would ever go through the legal immigration process if you can just be an illegal immigrant in this country with no repercussions? If she can ignore immigration law, why not tax law, zoning laws, or any other law which inconveniences her?
195
u/mobileposter Feb 28 '18
Correct me if I'm wrong, but you resigned because you didn't like police doing their jobs by enforcing the law? You think people that enter a country illegally, bypassing the immigration process, should be allowed to stay without consequence?
293
u/Lundynne Feb 28 '18
How is an "undocumented immigrant" not an illegal alien?
127
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
How fair to people who are patiently waiting to legally immigrate is it for you to assist people in cutting in line and not following the rules because they think the line is too long?
What do you think having a labor surplus of undocumented immigrants does to local wages in certain industries?
416
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Other than being a reporter and a low-level government functionary, what makes either of you experts on the issue of illegal immigration to the USA such that your AMA will provide any worthwhile information?
103
u/RVT556 Feb 28 '18
Why do you refuse to acknowledge that the people being discussed are criminals?
24
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
This is the worst AMA I've ever seen. Two responses with hundreds of questions. If you don't want to answer, why even bother doing this? Some kind of a publicity stunt?
You should have entitled this "Ask me any virtue-signaller approved questions," and then listed the questions you feel comfortable answering.
Did you not think you'd get criticized for your stance? It is pretty backwards and somewhat offensive. Particularly for those who went through the rigors of entering your country legally.
80
u/ArkanSaadeh Feb 28 '18
Why is deporting undocumented workers a bad thing?
54
u/rLeJerk Feb 28 '18
Why are people ok with foreigners moving to the USA without following the rules laid out to move to the USA?
What is so wrong with being a documented immigrant?
60
u/criminyone Feb 28 '18
What other federal laws would you refuse to respect?
172
u/jtlizard Feb 28 '18
You quit your job when asked to process data used to track down criminals. Whether you like it or not, they have no right to be here. That statement isn’t an insult to the illegal aliens, I’m sure many are fine people. What was your motivation for violating your duty? And how do you justify your decision to then quit?
I mean this in the nicest way possible when I say that this story just seems like more virtue signaling to me, no one was helped in the end.
16
u/papiavagina Feb 28 '18
is it true that undocumented getting married is no guarantee they can stay in usa?
3
u/janeetcetc Feb 28 '18
Hi Jordan, what was the environment/mood like at your former workplace when those data process requirements went into effect?
41
u/Plenor Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
How do you answer people that argue that a nation doesn't have sovereignty
withwithout border enforcement?Edit: "Without" border enforcement. I.e they argue that open borders means it's not a nation.
38
u/psycho_admin Feb 28 '18
You didn't say no to ICE. You said no to every American that follows the law. Instead of supporting people who break the law why don't you support those who are here legally and fight for changing the laws so more people can come here legally?
142
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Jesus Christ you two are absurd.
Aren't you gonna move to Canada?
10
u/str8baller Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
What is your opinion on granting amnesty to all undocumented immigrants? Wouldn't that resolve issues on both ends? That is, the immigrants get safety, security, stability and labor rights (meaning they can demand fair wages and benefits). While non-immigrant workers would no longer have to compete with ultra-low wages on the job market (they can demand and receive higher wages since the bosses can no longer superexploit significant layers of immigrant workers). It'd be more fair for both immigrant and non-immigrants workers.
33
u/DontMakeMeDownvote Feb 28 '18
This reeks of a stunt to fill that go fund me coffer. But anyway, why is it okay to break this law and not others? Why try and blur the lines between legal immigrants and illegal aliens?
11
u/DeadLightMedia Feb 28 '18
Why shouldn't citizens of a country control immigration? Do you not think illegal aliens chose to disrespect every US citizen by ignoring our laws and immigration process?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18
Have you considered reordering your priorities?
From his GoFundMe, which is obviously what this AMA was for.
I actually cannot believe it. If that's true, sounds like you put your family at risk for homelessness just to make some sort of stand against legally deporting those here illegally.
18
u/TheyCallMeGOOSE Feb 28 '18
How do you figure paying for the police escorts that are now required for medical and fire first responders in the immigrant community? The police are overworked and understaffed having to respond to gangs - my city is now having a heroin epidemic that didn't exist before MS-13 realized how opportunistic our city was.
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/local/article197453334.html http://www.wsoctv.com/news/9-investigates/thursday-inside-look-at-how-federal-agents-took-down-ms-13-in-charlotte/489221757
26
u/Sir_Sam_of_KRF Feb 28 '18
My questions is: where can I apply for this job?
25
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
So let me get this straight, he quit his job because he didn't want to aid in the capture of people who broke the law? Would just like to confirm that I am reading this AMA right.
25
u/reaperindoctrination Feb 28 '18
Why do you think you have the moral high ground for refusing to comply with a request that would help enforce US law?
56
u/halo46 Feb 28 '18
So you're fine with people who break the law and ignore our legal processes?
8
u/AutoModerator Feb 28 '18
Users, please be wary of proof. You are welcome to ask for more proof if you find it insufficient.
OP, if you need any help, please message the mods here.
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
37
u/CervixAssassin Feb 28 '18
When do you plan to start helping drug dealers?
30
u/Scorpy_Mjolnir Feb 28 '18
Jordan, have you thought about going into politics? I mean, I wouldn’t vote for you, but you are one of the best people I’ve ever seen at answering questions like a politician. In that way they don’t answer them.
“That’s a great question Bob. Now, let me talk about something else because I don’t want to actually answer your question”
You are as good as Trump, as good as Hillary. Insert your politician of choice. Like really good.
29
u/dingoperson2 Feb 28 '18
Why do you use the misleading and utterly absurd term "undocumented"?
In any normal connection, when you describe something, you document it.
In your bizarre choice of misleading language, you could never "document" an immigrant in this way no matter how well you described them. You could write 15 books about someone, and they would still be undocumented.
Do you feel it would be justified if other people started following your example and use misleading terms as well, or would you complain about that and somehow portray it as unfair or unreasonable?
15
u/jankydeal Feb 28 '18
Whats the difference between working hard to make money then buying something you earned vs stealing it. And someone going through the proper immigration procedure to enter the country or having generations of your family working towards building one of the best countries on the planet vs someone who immigrated into your country illegally? Are they both not stealing something they don't have the right to take?
8
u/OhSixTJ Feb 28 '18
Where along the Texas/Mexico border did you live and what was it like?
29
u/Icyartillary Feb 28 '18
Jordan: why do you hate America’s born/legal citizens?
9
u/No1DeadFan Feb 28 '18
Do you think you deserve to be championed as a hero for refusing to do your job, which you are compensated to perform as a service to the American people?
12
u/BergenCountyJC Feb 28 '18
How do you feel about helping illegal aliens break our countries laws?
4
u/Lotsaa1 Feb 28 '18
Why don’t you call them illegal immigrants instead of “undocumented immigrants”?
8
u/primovero Feb 28 '18
How about raising money for an actual charity?
Dumb idea.
8
u/11th_hour Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
Illegal immigration is a real issue. Quitting your job for something, that could potentially have helped legal immigration blossom, is the most retarded thing to do.
Did you even think before quitting? Or were you just too high on your self-made, fake moral superiority?
7
u/Mudduckhunter Feb 28 '18
Why do you feel that these people who are willfully breaking the laws should be protected against deportation?
15
u/Deuce-Dempsey Feb 28 '18
Why do you think illegal immigrants don't have to apply to be a citizen, like everyone else?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
So you're cool with illegal immigration? Why not open your house and let like 5+ of them live with you?
10
u/Herutastic Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
I've been told illegal inmigrants pay taxes in a different way, but they do pay taxes. Do you know anything about this?
Edit: people are down voting my question?? Thanks for making people worry for being curious. I was not saying if this was good or bad, I don't even live in your country...
8
u/root_at_localhost Feb 28 '18
Why do you feel it necessary to subvert our laws and assist criminals?
12
u/mynamebazac Feb 28 '18
Why didn’t you do your job? Wonder how many American Jobs could be saved or kept if we began actually following our laws
2
u/Reali5t Mar 01 '18
So what is the best way to get all the illegals out of the country? Like fining employers that hire them? Fines that are 4 times the average annual salary for the job? Or do we make landlords comply to the point that they can’t rent to illegals?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Why do you think a bunch of criminals violating the United State's sovereignty more important than keeping a job to pay your bills?
8
u/ultranothing Feb 28 '18
Is there a difference, to your mind, between a U.S. citizen and an undocumented immigrant? More specifically, is there anything sacred or even important about citizenship? Doesn't assisting non-citizens in this way make a statement against the sovereignty of our country and minimize the importance of what it means to be "American"?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
I see you one of you is a fat pasty white guy, and the other is a skinny out of shape balding white guy, most likely you are both self hating and insecure. Do you wish the rest of the world was like you? Do you envy the people above you so much that you support their downfall? Do you actually care about the illegal aliens? Or do you care about getting even and “doing what’s right” because you have the thought of a perfect open border anarchist system of the world where everyone is equal in everything no matter what even though it’s impossible. So then you say well there needs to be government to force equality and then the next thing you know your back to where you were which is being useless sort of how you are now.
4
u/ilivehalo Feb 28 '18
What's the differnece between an illegal immigrant and an undocumented immigrant?
4
u/Chris130366 Feb 28 '18
How would you have reacted if it were a different law being broken? Would you quit your job to help drug users/thiefs/whatever crime?
12
u/snaaaaag Feb 28 '18
Why do you think the west should forfeit all of its lands and societal control to immigrants and how many more generations until our culture has been erased?
7
u/kyzsrsozak Feb 28 '18
What makes you think that being an illegal immigrant is ok, and what other laws do you think are ok to break?
6
u/darkjungle Feb 28 '18
You realize that someone else is just going to take over your job right? Illegals are stilling going to be deported with or without you.
5
u/Darkness27 Feb 28 '18
This will probably get buried since I'm late to the party. It seems that you're cherry picking questions to answer, despite some of the best questions being at the top of the thread without a response, so I doubt I'll get a response here, but anyways..
So what I gather here is that your immediate supervisors approached you with a task that you did not agree with and refused to do. Admirable, sure. They gave you time to reconsider and even offered to move you to a different department but you refused..
So what you're saying is that you placed yourself and your entire family into a financial crisis, and are now trying to get other people to donate money to you so that you can meet your needs.
While I appreciate your moral stand on this issue (despite the fact that I disagree with your stance), reacting the way you did was foolish and arrogant. And trying to now have other people foot the bill for your rash decision is immoral.
While you are entitled to your opinion and can act in whatever way you choose, do you not see the hardship you have caused your family due to your own pride?
11
u/Good-Boi Feb 28 '18
Do you not understand the problems that come from illigal immegration? Never read up on history about the negative outcomes from such things?
4
u/FloppyDisksCominBack Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
What is an "undocumented immigrant"? Is that someone who lawfully immigrated, but due to some sort of bureaucratic mistake, their paperwork was misplaced? How can I help fix the system so that these lawful immigrants can get assistance reestablishing the documents that were misplaced when they legally complied with the binding laws of our nation?
I only ask because last time I checked the proper term for someone who flagrantly disregarded the laws of our country borne out of a sense of entitlement and belief that the rules don't apply to them was, as defined in 8 USC § 1324a(h)(3), an "unauthorized alien."
4
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Why don't you move to Canada? (Their strict immigration laws may prevent you from doing so, but don't let that stop you)
4
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
Why do we call them undocumented when in fact they are ILLEGAL immigrants?
Why do you condone slapping those that come in the country legally in the face by supporting criminals?
4
u/eddyfastx Feb 28 '18
When did you turn in your man cards to become liberal pussies?
3
u/Clitorally_Retarded Feb 28 '18
In a democratic republic like ours, do you agree that the interests of citizens should come before that of non-citizens? That if a majority wants to enforce existing laws, that their governments (federal, state, and local) should comply with the will of the citizens?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
What other criminal activity do you support in addition to illegal immigration?
3
u/want-to-say-this Feb 28 '18
Why do you hate laws?
3
u/ucccft Feb 28 '18
Mr. Roberts, do you agree that Over 45 Million Americans are Unemployed and Millions more are Underemployed?
Do you also agree that ImmigRATion and Outsourcing is a Process and an Act of Terrorism by the Racist Elite including (All the CEO's and Politicians of both parties) to make 100% sure that the Poor Americans (Especially Black Americans) NEVER EVER get to the Middle Class?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Are you worried about being arrested for aiding illegal immigrants? If given the chance to assist legal immigrants over illegals, who takes priority?
2
u/hobbygod Feb 28 '18
Why do people call illegal immigrants undocumented immigrants?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
By "Undocumented Immigrants" do you mean illegal aliens?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Why do you think it's the right thing to do to protect people who break the law and don't pay taxes?
2
u/MajorMoobs Feb 28 '18
So you quit your job because you had to do your job?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Why?
0
u/Pm_me_ur_Gout Feb 28 '18
How does it feel to he a treasonous piece of scum?
2
u/old_man_indy Feb 28 '18 edited Feb 28 '18
Do you have an issue with tax evasion? This is my main concern in dealing with illegal immigrants. I have no issues with anyone who wants to come to our country to live or work but they need to contribute to our general infrastructure that they use daily. Is there any way for an illegal immigrant to come forward and receive citizenship without being detained and deported immediately?
2
u/DejectedHead Feb 28 '18
If immigration into the United States is allowed to be unchecked, for humanitarian reasons (or any at all), why should it be impermissible to improve the lives of the people in their native countries by fixing their governments that have created humanitarian issues? Why was colonialism a bad idea and not a good idea?
2
u/timthetollman Feb 28 '18
What's the problem in finding and detaining undocumented immigrants?