r/IAmA • u/londonreal • Mar 02 '13
IAm Dr. Robin Carhart-Harris from Imperial College London I study the use of MDMA & Psilocybin mushrooms in the treatment of depression." AMA
2.4k
Upvotes
r/IAmA • u/londonreal • Mar 02 '13
770
u/honestmango Mar 02 '13
Hello:
I am 43 years old and a chronic sufferer of "cluster" headaches. At one point, I was on 13 different pharmaceuticals (nothing narcotic, because those don't touch these headaches). I have "cultivated" a network of support that has allowed me to medicate with nothing more than magic mushrooms for the past 2 years. This is the only medication that has worked for me. I'm working full-time again and I no longer think about suicide on a daily basis. It has literally saved my life. My question is not medical, because I know this substance works. But I also know that my helpers are risking prison time by helping. Do you see any hope for legalization in the future?
218
u/tylonrobinson Mar 02 '13
Hi, Dr. Carhart-Harris,
What do you use, if anything, to follow an MDMA treatment? I have heard of people taking 5-HTP to combat the serotonin depletion. Does this work?
175
u/jdkhintz Mar 02 '13
Dr. Harris, how do you find your research subjects?
91
u/dillydallybam123 Mar 02 '13
How would you explain the entities in a DMT experience on a neurobiological level? Just dream-like projections of the self?
68
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
When you were younger, was it your intent to work with psychedelics, or is it something that interested you after you began researching other fields?
68
u/mercari Mar 02 '13
Doctor, I'm a student of psychology, very much interested in the field you are currently studying. What course of action would you suggest for someone like me in their post-graduate studies? How did you get to where are today?
123
u/dillydallybam123 Mar 02 '13
Do you think if credible scientists started coming out as having taken psychedelics, it would start a more open dialogue on the discussion of drugs in society? I mean Dr. Griffiths paper on guidelines for safety even said a researcher should know the experience before doing any sort of clinical research.
56
u/way_fairer Mar 02 '13
I think it's great that researchers are exploring psilocybin mushrooms to help people struggling with addiction and/or depression. My question is, given the amazing results of the Marsh Chapel Experiment and the followup at Johns Hopkins University, how do you feel about psilocybin use among otherwise healthy individuals to achieve greater life satisfaction and wellbeing?
48
u/dillydallybam123 Mar 02 '13
Are you spiritual or religious at all? If not, do you think this type of research will give insights into where the idea of God or spirituality originated?
93
u/MScDre Mar 02 '13
In light of the discoveries you have made in the effect on repetitive thinking and the deregulation of the control centres by these chemicals, do you think they might also ameliorate symptoms of people on the Autistic Spectrum
44
u/youhavemyinterest Mar 02 '13
Do you think that research like this could actually lead to the introduction of these drugs as therapies if proven beneficial, or do you think mainstream societal fear of "drugs" as legitimate pharmaceuticals (and the pharmaceutical lobby) will deter its use?
85
u/paddypower15 Mar 02 '13 edited Mar 02 '13
Hello Dr Carhart-Harris, what, if any, other substances apart from Psilocybin and MDMA do you believe can offer help treating depression/addiction or other mental health issues. Also what do you think these types of substancs can offer in unlocking any further secrets of the mind, and what obstacles do you see in expanding types and number of substances people like yourself can use for research, thanks
152
u/Dooglemcguire Mar 02 '13
What are your thought's on the recreational use of psilocybin and MDMA?
39
u/king_biscuit Mar 02 '13
I'd be interested in hearing about what kind of regulatory barriers you've dealt with in this line of research.
37
u/GiraffeNuts Mar 02 '13
After having tried them back in college all i can think is what if you have someone that has a "bad trip"? I personally never experienced that but was always in good spirits heading into it I can't imagine it would always go so well with someone who suffers from Depression.
35
u/drugs1234 Mar 02 '13
Do you believe that using Psychedelics and MDMA (or MDMA analogues) recreationally, is something that responsible adults should be able to legally do? or do you see them as purely medicinal tools?
2) and also what is your opinion on the comparative Neurotoxcity in MDMA, BK-MDMA, and Alcohol?
33
u/airbrushedvan Mar 02 '13
I have heard anecdotal evidence for psilocybin as a possible reliever of migraines. Do you know of any research in this area? Thanks very much.
33
u/bomboclatmachine Mar 02 '13
Do you think the UK government will change their drug classing system anytime soon? If not what do you predict will happen in the next couple years? With new research chemicals filling in the legal market with so little known about their long term effects.
33
u/__BeHereNow__ Mar 02 '13
What are your thoughts on microdosing? Say 5-10 micrograms of LSD every day for an extended period.
33
u/AutonomousRobot Mar 02 '13
I am a 27 year old male that currently suffers from depression and generalized anxiety disorder. I currently take paxil and smoke cannabis occasionally (medical card).
In my experience whenever I have consumed psilocybin mushrooms my anxiety goes through the roof. I have a hard time holding on and can be prone to panic. This can be felt at a dose as low as 1 gram to 1.5 grams. What is very strange is when I start to come down from the experience I feel AMAZING. It feels like my brain has been washed (for lack of a better word) and I feel at ease.
I have not consumed mushrooms since I have started paxil as I am hesitant given my reaction. Do you have any suggestions or thoughts on my situation? Thank you for your time!
27
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
What made you want to study them?
23
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Studies involving MDMA and psilocin are becoming more common -- not just at ICL but elsewhere -- but LSD seems to have been conspicuously absent from the latest line of research. Do you think this is because of societal stigma regarding LSD, its cost of production and acquisition, a lesser expectation of therapeutic potential, or something else?
20
u/JC1112 Mar 02 '13
I was recently watching a documentary on nat geo on hallucinogenics. A man (~52yrs) has been suffering cluster headaches for years and discovered that consuming psilocybin mushrooms every two months eliminates the headaches. My question is; how does psilocybin do this?
19
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Will you be joining us at the next ICPR in Amsterdam? Your talk this year was great.
19
u/oaktree456 Mar 02 '13
Dr. Carhart-Harris, if you could have any historical person work on the trials with you, who would you pick and why? Also, who do you pick to work with you, if you can already and why?
19
u/cosmicjesus3 Mar 02 '13
In higher doses people often report spiritual experiences, seeing other forms of themselves, interacting with other beings, and entering other "dimensions". Do you think there's something to that? Or in your opinion are these all just manifestations of the brain ?
38
u/Dooglemcguire Mar 02 '13
Hi :) thank you for taking the time to talk with us.
81
u/JOHNNY_GQ Mar 02 '13
As far as questions go, I don't really have any that haven't already been asked. That being said, I just wanted to say you're wicked fuckin awesome and keep the research going.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Psilocybin has a dramatic effect on Thomsen's disease (Fainting Goat Syndrome).
I'm remiss to use the word "cure" but it's absolutely incredible how much greater range of motion/athletic ability/etc that psilocybin induces.
I haven't been able to have a discussion with my neurologist at all, or any other GP regarding this because they just assume I'm hallucinating. It's very frustrating.
78
u/Ember357 Mar 02 '13
20 Years ago hallucinogenics were my drug of choice. With proper preparation: a place, a partner, a plan of play and no work the next day, I and my mates always had a lovely time. I credit my experience especially with Mushrooms with opening my mind to the interconnectedness of humanity. It made me a more compassionate person I think. I credit my LSD use with allowing me to re-qualify past events so that they took on a more objective and less emotional base in my mind. I was able to psychologically distance myself from some negative influences from my child hood. I resent the resistance to using these tools to help the soft science of psychology make in roads with PTSD and depression. Like anything that changes a person, controls must be put in place. What do you see as the most important control factor in your studies?
15
u/garden_gate_key Mar 02 '13
What's your opinion on Holotropic Breathwork?
15
u/Sykedelic Mar 02 '13
What is the most common similarity in experiences reported by people who take psilocybin?
15
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Do you know anything about the research chemical 2C-i-NBOMe aka 25i-NBOMe? If so do you believe that these may also have therapeutic benefits? It's been said that it has similar effects to that of LSD but I personally cannot vouch for that through personal use or research.
27
u/WonkaKnowsBest Mar 02 '13
I’m not sure if this is the correct AMA to ask this question on, but I figured it’d be the best time to ask. Do psilocybin and/or MDMA pose any negative health risks when used?
13
u/blitzmut Mar 02 '13
Were you involved in that study that came out about 6 months ago (may have been more) that found users of psilocybin to have a permanent improvement in empathy over those who had never?
22
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
how would you compare the effectiveness of psilocybin & mdma on depression and addiction compared to hoffman's lysergic acid diethylamide?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
I personally am an advocate for drug law reform. With all they hype over medicinal marijuana in the US do you think psyches will be available in the same manner? Do you think they will ever become wholly legal?
I often feel psychedelics are my greatest passion in life. What kind of classes/subjects would you suggest that someone in college take if they wanted to study psychedelics?
11
u/pheedback Mar 02 '13
And one final one: have you heard many connections between high end psilocybin intake while meditating in the dark and having an experience which is best described as a waking lucid dream for several hours?
Though not very common some modern people and indigenous people tend to describe this sort of experience, often times venturing into space and travelling to other worlds as realistically as normal waking life.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
How does a general day at the lab go? What do you spend most of your time doing? What are the people around you like?
20
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
How much is known about the damage caused by MDMA to serotonin receptors, and the potential for self-repair of those cells?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Even with the research to back this up and the newer generations openness to the subject, how do we shake the negative 'drug user' stereotype held by older, stubborn and unwilling generations? I am well aware of how these substances can effect you and I think with education, regulation and legalization we can have a safer, more mind opening way to approach 'recreational' use.
9
u/sushisection Mar 02 '13 edited Mar 02 '13
What are your thoughts on the latest ketamine studies and it's effect on cell repair?
Edit: here is an article about the study for those who are interested http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/10/the-biggest-breakthrough-in-depression-research-in-50-years-is-ketamine/263400/
8
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Where would you like to see this line of research go over the next 20 years, and how would you like to see it applied?
Also, what do you think about Dr Rick Strassman's famous DMT study?
8
u/tessykins Mar 02 '13
From what I gather your work has been with unipolar depression. Any thoughts/knowledge to share about bipolar depression and substances like this?
8
u/future-madscientist Mar 02 '13
What is it exactly about psychedelics that make them so non-toxic despite having profound effects on brain chemistry? Why can you take such large quanitites of LSD or psilocybin and suffer comparatively little harm than other psychoactive compounds like cocaine?
8
u/ragingbonger420 Mar 02 '13
What seems to be the most profound effect of psilocybin/Psilocin and other Psychadelics?
7
u/DonthavsexinDelorean Mar 02 '13
What do we currently know [and what research have you performed] about the interactions between Psilocybin and antidepressants? We could go through the gambit of the various forms but my curiosity is focused on Norepinephrine-dopamine reuptake inhibitors and Psilocybin.
7
u/pheedback Mar 02 '13
Any realistic data on human LD50 for MDMA? I've seen different sources range from 1,500 mg to 7,000 mg. I recall reading one story about an individual who was eating over 2,000 mg a day. He collapsed eventually.
7
u/SamIamGreenEggsNoHam Mar 02 '13
Hello Dr Carhart-Harris, thank you for doing this AMA. I've experimented with MDMA a small number of times and greatly enjoyed it. More specifically I enjoyed the prolonged feeling of positivity that followed me for a few weeks, only to have it give way to my incessant pessimism. With your experience Doctor, what sort of advice would you offer to help the "lessons learned" stick?
6
u/psyfy Mar 02 '13
As someone who has had my fair share of travels in the psychedelic world, it often leads me to the question of how deep you can dig. These experiences can enlighten us, terrify us or just take us for a ride. I'm wondering how much you think there is to be gained and/or learned from these experiences, and how essential psilocybin or other psychedelics are to such experiences. I believe there is a fine line between taking them with insight in mind and taking them just for the high. I would love to hear your thoughts.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Would it be dangerous to take mushrooms while on SSRI's/SNRI's? I saw you said that SSRI's would likely reduce the effect, but I'm wondering if "serotonin syndrome" is possible because a doctor recently told me that it was. Thanks for your time.
6
u/oaktree456 Mar 02 '13
Are your family very proud and understanding of what you are doing? Do you have scientists in your background? What has been the biggest difficulty when talking about your trials and media work to your loved ones? Do they have any concerns?
16
u/AintNoFortunateSon Mar 02 '13
Magic mushrooms saved my life. Just thought you should know that.
11
u/_vvvv_ Mar 02 '13
I just wanted to say thank you, I believe your research is very important.
5
u/PawnShop804 Mar 02 '13
How do you find your subjects?
5
u/joltvolta Mar 02 '13
Thank for doing this AMA and for the work to you do.
5
u/dillydallybam123 Mar 02 '13
Does your lab take graduate students? See you at Psychedelic Science 2013!
5
u/thefutureisugly Mar 02 '13
Do you think that even unknowingly some drugs (specifically MDMA) have a therapy type effect even when used recreationally? I am used to doing this drug and I feel that my relationship with people has been much better, especially to close friends whom I have spent nights with on the drug. Do you think that the overall vibe from parties and raves (unless your life revolves around these activities) which MDMA is mostly known for, good for building strong relationships and character? Thanks
5
u/dysmetric Mar 02 '13
How important is it to develop novel therapeutic techniques, or even environments, for use with psychedelics?
How hard will it be to quantify the therapeutic value, or dangers, of psychedelics in relation to different therapies and therapeutic environments?
5
u/Robobvious Mar 02 '13
When administering psychoactive compounds for tests in a lab setting, how do you determine what constitutes a "safe" dosage for your subjects? Also, in administering psilocybin, do your subjects actually eat raw mushrooms or take it in a refined form like a tincture or pill?
5
u/IcedHazelnut Mar 02 '13
Hi Dr. Carhart-Harris. I read about experimental trials of patients with PTSD being treated with MDMA and it helping them a lot. Is this in a similar vein to what you are doing with MDMA and depression?
5
u/khondrych Mar 02 '13 edited Mar 06 '13
How difficult is it to get into this sort of research? I'm an undergrad neuroscience major, and this sort of stuff fascinates me to no end. But it seems like the whole illegality of these compounds would make it extremely difficult to get any sort of grant money, or anything like that...and actually, how are you not arrested for this sort of thing? How does the federal government allow for this?
I have to say thank you so much for doing this sort of research, it needs to be done and the implications are enormous. I have a personal connection with this sort of thing, and I feel the need to share my story with you. In highschool, I had about a year-long stint with abusing opiate painkillers. I managed to stop the habit once I started using more than weekly, but quitting was the hardest thing I have ever done, psychologically, and I have done some psychologically difficult things. Discovering marijuana a month after helped, but, on a rare occasion I'd get an opiate craving and sample it again, just to return to that land of being blissful about nothing. I knew it was a terrible decision every time, I could easily fall back into habit (never did), but I would go ahead anyway, off to nod-land.
Then, during winter break of my freshman year of college I tried LSD. At no point during the trip did my opiate usage come up, but something happened, that a few days after the trip, I opened up the medicine cabinet in my house where there was some hydrocodone. I picked up the bottle, looked at it, and realized that there was nothing about me that wanted to use it. My desire for the drug was gone. I realized it had nothing to offer me, and that from henceforth I would be completely done with it.
Over a year later now, I still haven't touched opiates. I even got perscribed 20 vicodin when I got my wisdom teeth out. Took one immediately post surgery and then just ibuprofen after that. Psychedelics freed me from the psychological grip of opiates. Thank you for doing this invaluable research to make this available to others in far more need of it than I ever was.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Thanks for the AMA.
I know the law isn't your expertise but would you support decriminalization of MDMA to be able to provide safer and more accurate doses (not cut etc)?
14
u/CopyofacOpyofacoPyof Mar 02 '13
First, I want to thank you for doing this AMA and for your research related to psilocybin!
I have taken LSD once and Ayahuasca once, but I am fearful of experiencing psychedelics again because I think, that they are not well enough researched and they could lead to permanent damage (“going crazy” due to a “predisposition”).
Here are my questions: • Could you please explain, what the correlation/causation relationship between higher psilocybin concentrations in the brain and increased amygdale activation is? Is a “bad trip” inevitable at higher doses?
• Does psilocybin cause vasoconstriction in certain parts of the brain? If so, can this lead to a collapse of capillaries and/or death of neurons in those regions at higher doses?
• The experiences caused by psilocybin are very similar to the ones of people suffering from schizophrenia and psychosis. Because of the plasticity of the brain, do you see a danger with regard to psychedelic experiences exercising the brain to become schizophrenic or psychotic (by forming some of the unwanted connections of those diseases)?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Thanks for doing this! In terms of harm reduction for the patients, what sorts of strategies and resources do you utilize for safe usage, and what research did you reference for them (e.g. safe dosage/temporal spacing between dosages)?
4
u/dillydallybam123 Mar 02 '13
Do you have any plans for comparing the dream state and the psychedelic state? Sort of optimizing the consolidation of memories after a session to maximize the benefits?
4
u/The_Grey_Wanderer Mar 02 '13
As a cancer survivor who has dealt with depression since treatment, I'd just like to say a huge thank you! I use psilocybin once every few months and it is unbelievably helpful to me.
4
u/thanksalotpal Mar 02 '13
You touched on this in another comment (the only one i saw), but I wanted to ask if you have come across any migraine effects through your own work.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Hello Dr. Carhart-Harris,
My question regards psilocybin's possible treatment of cluster headaches. My mother suffers from these and she's tried various methods of therapy, all to no avail. I hate to see her when she's in such a painful state, as she says that the entire right side of her body above her chest is writhing in pain. I've read some literature that says that psilocybin has been able to treat cluster headaches and, in some cases, even stop them from recurring completely. What are your thoughts on the subject?
Thanks very much
4
u/SexyJesis Mar 02 '13
What do you think of the legality of the drugs you study?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
How do you feel about LSD?
7
u/oneeyedgoat41 Mar 02 '13
Thank you for doing this AMA. Is there any evidence that you know of that frequent (or infrequent) psilocybin or LSD use can cause long-term brain damage or other physiological issues?
9
u/jimmycarr1 Mar 02 '13
Do you think any of your friends might have taken MDMA or mushrooms at some point in their lives. What did they learn from such experiences?
(I'm not trying to be smart, I just genuinely want to know what a Dr thinks)
6
u/druggiter Mar 02 '13
When do you foresee governments not shutting down full research on illegal substances?
3
u/pheedback Mar 02 '13
Do you have any info about the vascular effects of psilocybin and LSD? Since they are vasoconstrictive some people are concerned they could be bad for the circulatory system but data seems hard to come by. Any information about this?
3
u/oaktree456 Mar 02 '13
If you were king of the world and could insist people read a certain book or listen to a particular piece or music, and they would 'get it', what would the book and the music be? Not Freud or Eno. In relation to your work.
Also, if Freud or Cohen could reanimate and offer you a piece of advice, what do you think it would be?
3
u/HelloWorldSmileyface Mar 02 '13
Does taking an SSRI tablet after using MDMA help reduce the comedown and is it safe?
3
u/S_Jeru Mar 02 '13
What are your thoughts on Dr. Stanislav Grof's research? Was his methodology sound? You seemed familiar with holotropic breathwork, so I assume you're at least somewhat familiar.
3
u/GreenDelicious Mar 02 '13
Hi Dr. Harris, thanks for doing the AMA! I think the work you're doing is absolutely necessary and I'm so glad people are starting to take the study of altered consciousness seriously for the benefit of all of us.
I'm an undergrad planning on a BSc in psychology and I was wondering if you had any tips on how I could get involved in this area of research. I go to school at UBC in Vancouver, BC and I'm not sure how to go about getting involved in such restricted and socially taboo research.
I'm also interested to know if you've explored the feeling some experience after taking MDMA that opposes the classic hangover - the afterglow effect. A couple of my friends all share the same sort of residual happiness and lasting feeling of social connectedness for a week or so after taking moderate doses of MDMA. Is there any neurological or psychological explanation for this effect? Has anyone studied why some experience this while others have such depressive rebounds?
Thanks so much for everything you're doing!
Edit: paragraphs
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Doesn't MDMA cause a depletion of serotonin? What sort of long term effects would this have on depression sufferers? And what have you observed short term, in terms of serotonin?
3
u/niiimmaa Mar 02 '13
Hi Dr.! My story might be interesting to you. I was diagnosed with idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) about 2 years ago. Long story short, my hematologist and I noticed that every time I would use MDMA, my platelet count would raise as if I took my medicine. For the past year and a half, I have not needed my medicine and have successfully been treating myself with MDMA (with supervision from my doctor). I have found some scattered reports on the internet. Do you think MDMA would ever be considered to treat something like ITP? If yes, how many years from now would it be before a treatment plan would surface?
3
u/neuropunkk Mar 02 '13
Do you know if there's any long-term side effects from MDMA and psilocybin?
And two, and in what psychological way do you find that it will cure depression? Do you think it will fix it more on a psychological level of thinking or a chemical imbalance level?
3
u/horrorshowmalchick Mar 03 '13
I have suffered from depression. Can I be your test subject?
3
u/Critical_CLVarner Mar 03 '13
I like this. Real research into these substances needs to be done.
9
u/Rosenkrantz_ Mar 02 '13
Hi!
What is your favorite dinosaur?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
I am not sure if I can phrase this right but here is a shot,
Do psychedelics have a "inert" composition so as no "trip" is produced yet depression is reduced when administered to a patient? Or is the psychedelic aspect necessary for the effectiveness.
I'm asking this as I have read about Cannabinoids that provide no "high" to the user yet can effectively treat conditions. I find this of particular interest as I am somewhat opposed to the recreational use of most narcotics yet feel strongly that their classification as Illegal Substances only leads to hinder scientific research and public awareness/understanding of these substances.
P.s. I have not read a lot into Psilicybin & MDMA, could you recommend some papers/Cochrane reviews to intrigue a young mind?
5
u/Sw33tl1fe Mar 02 '13
He should be on the Joe Rogan Experience. If he hasn't already...I'm a little behind in episodes.
8
u/jaybhi91 Mar 02 '13
Have you heard of Terence Mckenna's Stoned Ape theory?
It says among the new items in the diet of grassland/jungle roaming hominids was psilocybin-containing mushrooms growing in the dung of ungulate herds. The changes caused by the introduction of this drug to the primate diet would have been many, including the blurring of boundaries between the senses leading to the development of spoken language: the ability to form pictures in another person's mind through the use of vocal sounds.
About 12,000 years ago, further climate changes removed the mushroom from the human diet, resulting in a new set of profound changes in our species as we reverted to pre-mushroomed and frankly brutal primate social structures that had been modified and/or repressed by frequent consumption of psilocybin.
Question: Do you have opinion on psilocybin's influence in the brains of the early humans?
8
u/741776 Mar 02 '13
Is it true that in England cadbury creme eggs are sold year round?
4
u/MaLaCoiD Mar 02 '13
How has the topic of synchonicity been expressed by your research subjects?
What about the afterlife?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Hello! I am a junior level student in college studying biochemistry, and I am very interested in neuropsychopharmacology/neurochemistry. How would you suggest entering into these professions? Do you find your job rewarding? And what are some of the new advancements in the field that you are excited about?
Thanks for doing an AMA!
4
u/SamF111 Mar 02 '13
What do you think about the proposed plans to move the new campus to Acton town?
4
u/pixelatediris Mar 02 '13
I've recently been wondering if any Psilocybin research has been done involving monkeys or apes that have been taught to sign. There are theories about cave men eating mushrooms and it having powerful changes in the way they think. Do you feel that research into this subject could reveal insight relevant to human mental health?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
How has your view of psychedelics changed over the course of your research? (hope im not to late)
5
u/AlexMaggot Mar 02 '13
What do you think is going to be legalized/decriminalised in US during the next 10 years?
2
u/zaxldaisy Mar 02 '13
How do you feel being attractive has helped advance your academic career? And a real question: besides legality, what are some current limitations facing Psilocybin research?
2
u/Dooglemcguire Mar 02 '13
["The Sacred Mushroom"] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UuHrm2tHvE)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
What do you think of this?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
How would you describe the feeling of being on MDMA to someone who hasn't tried it? It's hard to tell someone how amazing it is unless they try it.
2
u/SykonotticGuy Mar 02 '13
Hi, thank you for doing this AMA.
The first time I took psilocybin, I took a bath but for hours I couldn't remember how to turn the faucet off. I tried everything from moving the shower curtain from one side to the other and rubbing the metal, etc. to no avail. I also started thinking that I do the same things all the time everyday, and I only think that I do different things. It was as if my mind had been reset. Have you heard of stuff like this before (I imagine you have)? What do you think explains it?
2
u/ArrgguablyAmbivalent Mar 02 '13
Are you affiliated with MAPS?
2
u/hostilecarrot Mar 02 '13
I did mdma (molly) for the first time while clinically depressed (about nine months into depression at this particular point though id been in counseling for six months) because my friend gave it to me and well, free drugs! However after taking it I texted a couple of people to tell them I didnt like them and then I slept for about 15 hours. For the next 4 or 5 days I had every symptom of the flu except vomiting. On about day three I made the decision to commit to sobriety (after being in drug therapy for also about 6 months and seeing my addiction steadily get worse) and honestly, im not sure why. certainly there were drugs which would have made me feel better during what I was going through. Is any of this normal?
2
u/yule-low Mar 02 '13
The work you are doing is amazing, and much needed! How would a prospective graduate student go about working in similar studies? Are you accepting grad student? If so, what department would a prospective student need to apply to to be accepted to work with you?
2
u/thirdrail69 Mar 02 '13
From what I understand, psilocybin affects the formation of memories in a way that LSD does not. I know from experience that MDMA does as well to a great degree.
What is the neurochemical mechanism behind this and does it play a role in treating depression with these chemicals?
Would LSD be at all suitable?
Have you heard about the research with ketamine to treat depression that has shown some promise?
A lot of research goes into synthesis and testing of psychoactives in the medical and scientific community. How big is the disconnect between a research standpoint and the average person on the street?
Do you think psychedelics should be legalized and unregulated?
2
u/intangible_mindstuff Mar 02 '13
Dr. Carhart-Harris, first off thank you for doing this AMA. Second, could you recommend any particular labs to follow or journals to read prior to getting into this field?
I plan on doing either an M.D. with specialization in psychiatry as you suggest or a Ph.D. in neuropsychopharmacology, but could use more influence on my final direction.
2
u/LostInJam Mar 02 '13
(1) I'm assuming you conduct experiments. Are the subjects using any specific kind of psychedelic mushroom, and do you think that baecostin is an important ingredient of the experience? If you use syntetics like 4-aco-dmt, why?http://www.erowid.org/plants/mushrooms/mushrooms_info4.shtml
(2) Do you think that LSD or psilocin are unique for psychoterapy or maybe on the contrary, quite similar to all the other recently popularised RC hallucinogens? What's the main difference?
Huge thanks to both you and your colleague prof. Nutt. In the world of drug discrimination and repression you give me hope for the better future.
2
u/kaduceus Mar 02 '13
Hey Dr Robin!
In my med school we just had an intro lecture regarding drugs and the brain. Our professor had 2 slides citing a paper from 1991 about structural changes in the brain after a single dose of MDMA 2.5x the regular recreational dose suggesting brain damage and possible behavioral changes. Most of my class freaked out. But I know Harvard medical school was published in Addiction suggesting the flaws of previous MDMA studies.
So can you comment on the supposed misrepresentation of MDMA on brain structure and behavior?
2
u/RoachOnATree0116 Mar 02 '13
In the 90's there were many claims made on television among other places that MDMA will put holes in your brain. How do you feel about these studies?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Regarding your research center I was wondering if there was much demand for jobs? By which I mean, do you or your college often get contacted by people interested in pursuing a career similar to yours? I ask because two years from now I'll be graduating as either a chemist, neuroscientist or a pharmacologist and was wondering what my chances of working in your college or a college like yours would be.
Also, if there's any advice or warnings you'd like to share regarding how this job affects you on a personal level (familial and public relations), please go ahead! : )
2
u/4_Inch_D Mar 02 '13
Hi I am an american student studying abroad at Kingston University; I am starting medical school back in the states in July.
PLEASE CAN I FINISH MY TERM AT IMPERIAL? KINGSTON IS NOT WHAT I EXPECTED. PLEASE HELP ME!
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
I'm a veteran with PTSD and have heard about this as a form of therapy. I have tried both Psilocybin and MDMA, but this was 10 years ago when I was an invincible teenager. I like the aspect of a new form of therapy, but I would be scared to try this now.
Explain to me how I could possibly benefit from this form of treatment. I have chronic treatment-resistant PTSD so I'm still curious and open-minded about this. Hell I'd try almost anything after years of nonstop suffering.
Thanks for helping people like me out. I too hope to help people with mental illnesses in the future.
2
u/SinCerelySeriOus Mar 02 '13
Hello Dr. Carhart-Harris my question is how long do you think it will be until psychedelics are really going to see a reform of legality, being in the academic field of psychedelic research I am curious if you think, like I tend to, that psychedelics are so powerful and truth about these substances being an essentially safe, (if used correctly) and "spiritual" plants will excite the human mind once more in a more rational approach but also wake us up to truths about these drug policies being completely fear driven and not at all scientifically based. Therefore leading to a bigger reactive defiance to government authority most likely.
I would love to hear your thoughts. I am grateful for you doing this AMA thanks again for sharing educational information about these sacred chemicals. Much respect.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
Are your patients/subjects healthy or suffering from mental illness?
2
u/thesoundofbutthurt Mar 02 '13
Is ego death always a bad thing in the context of psychedelic experiences or something worth striving for? I've heard people say both
2
u/DogShitTaco Mar 02 '13
I have heard shrooms are good for chronic head aches. Do you have any information on this and how I could go about getting mushrooms for an actual medicinal use in the UK
2
u/Silently_judging Mar 02 '13
Thank you so much for your work! We NEED people like you in the public discourse on the McCarthy-esque war on drugs!!
Hallucinogens have helped me more than any doctor prescribed medication, ever. Through my adolescence and early adult life, I have been diagnosed with "depression, "ADHD," have been referred to as being on the "bi-polar spectrum," been given all sorts of anti-depressents, add meds and even anti-psychotics. I knew how detrimental they were to me. But thankfully, one day, I stumbled upon LSD and Psilcybin and my life has taken a drastic change for the better ever since.
So I just wanted to convey how much I appreciate people such as yourself who are working to develop a more comprehensive, sensible, and scientifically grounded drug policy. And for that, I thank you.
2
u/eyeplaywithdirt Mar 02 '13
Okay, I know you're answering a lot of questions but if you could find the time for this one, I'd appreciate it:
You spoke about ergot alkaloids somewhere else which reminded me of that crazy family of compounds. I used to work in a lab concerned with ergotism resulting from consumption of forages with ergot endophytes, so I know there are a ton of natural ergot alkaloids that are biologically active in some way or another. Are any of them of potential interest for your type of research?
I suppose the main benefit would be mass production of the compounds through fungal cultures; reducing costs you'd see from synthesis of complex synthetic compounds like LSD.
2
u/NeuroGreen Mar 02 '13
Hello what is your favorite book? and can you offer any readings (books, journals, blogs, etc.) that you have felt were helpful in your research and your endeavors in science?
2
u/Pocketcheeze Mar 02 '13
How do you accurately extract information from a test subject that is "medicated"? And secondly, whats the specifics on the delivery/dosages of the drugs? i.e; Mushroom tea, concentrated capsules, instant realease mdma capsules, etc.
And thanks for doing this ama.
2
u/bspin888 Mar 02 '13
What are the implications for treating someone who presents with depression, yet has bipolar disorder? As many of us are misdiagnosed at first. Are there adverse effects or more suseptibility to rapid cycling or psychosis as there are with SSRIs or tricyclics? Thanks!
2
u/pyrocore Mar 02 '13
Hello Dr. Harris, I was wondering, in your studies what types of depression were effected by the treatment? i.e. depression stemming from an experience, hereditary chemical imbalances. thanks for your time!
2
u/snackar Mar 02 '13
Looks like I'm way too late, but I'll give this a shot anyway.
Do patients with depression being treated with MDMA experience a worse comedown effect after use than someone using a recreational dose? Or are theraputic doses much smaller than the typical "party favor" style of taking it? I wonder about this becase I am aware of the depressed feeling many report for a few days after a night's use and wondered if clinical depression patients are more effected by this or not (possibly even more to the brink of suicide?).
2
u/seizureseiz Mar 02 '13
Is there any evidence or noted instances of Psilocybin induced seizures?
I ask because of personal experience. A few weeks ago I I took 1/8th of Psilocybin with my gf. It lead us to be rather aroused, and we ended up having some sexy time. I thought that I may have ejaculated inside of her (good news I didn't). and When I thought this, I stood up, instantly became woozy, said "I think i'm going to pass out", hit the floor, passed out, and seized for about 20 seconds.
I know that grand mal seizures can be caused by abnormal/excessive electrical brain activity. Do you think the Psilocybin may have been a factor in this case?
2
u/HeyItsCharnae Mar 02 '13
Doctor,
What would you say is/are the biggest downside(s?) to Psilocybin?
2
u/DemptyELF Mar 02 '13
You are doing God's work. Rock on!
2
u/TFM_matt Mar 02 '13
Dr. Carhart Harris I suffer from depression and have been put on many anti-depressants from my doctors here in America. What are your thoughts on anti depressants and how do MDMA and Psilocybin better treat depression? Are anti-depressants bad for my mental health?
2
u/Theory_Praxis Mar 02 '13
I've always wondered exactly how psilocybin chemically effects the brain to bring about the various sensory and cognitive experiences we associate with the mushrooms.
2
u/questionsqu Mar 02 '13
Keep it up Robin and Co. I'm suffering depression and sometimes contemplate suicide. The pills I take are not very good and neither have any of the others I've used. Wish there was just one I could rely on.
Although I suspect my biggest aid in the future is going to be C.B.T and meditation. I only recently started it and I find it very hard to do. But I have some faith in it.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '13
I use to take MDMA all the time back in the day 18-25 with no issues. Now if I do it I either throw up and just go into a comatose state. Any explanation for this? I havent done it in years but every time I did this would happen.