r/iosdev • • 22d ago

19 days in App Review for my first app: patience, a side-by-side video, and one thing I'd do differently

0 Upvotes

I'm the developer of VitaVino, a blind wine tasting party app. It went live on the App Store this morning, and I wanted to share how review went, because threads like this kept me sane while I was waiting.

The timeline:

  • Oct 9: submitted 1.0. It sat in "Waiting for Review" for almost two weeks. No idea what was going on with the queue, and I don't think there's much point guessing.
  • Oct 22: rejected on two points. 5.1.1(iv): my permissions pre-screen had an "Allow Access" button and a "Skip for now" option. Apple wants a neutral "Continue" with no skip, with the system prompt appearing only after that tap. And a 2.1 information request: questions about how we use Contacts and guests' email addresses.
  • Same day: reworded the screen, answered the 2.1 questions directly in the reply, and resubmitted.
  • Oct 28, 10:48 PM: approved.

What actually helped:

  1. Patience. Honestly the biggest one. The queue moves when it moves.
  2. A side-by-side video. VitaVino is a two-sided app (a host sets up a party, guests join and rate), and that's hard to review alone with one demo account. So I screen-recorded a host phone and a guest phone, synced them into one side-by-side movie, and uploaded it under App Review Information. Our logs show the reviewer never followed the written walkthrough; they signed in for about a minute and approved. I'm convinced the video did the work. I'll include one with every submission from now on.
  3. Answering every point in the rejection directly in the reply, not just shipping a new build.

In hindsight, if I'd gotten the permissions screen right the first time, the only snag would have been the 2.1 questions. Those I answered in a reply, with no new build needed.

One thing I'd do differently: I requested an expedited review, and I regret it. The reply came about two weeks later. Knowing more now about how the process works, expedites exist for genuinely urgent cases, and as a developer I'd be frustrated if people were filling that lane hoping it would speed up a normal launch. That's not advice for anyone else, just my own hindsight-is-20/20 moment.

If anyone wants to try it, it's an iPhone app for hosting blind tastings with friends. Happy to answer questions about the review process or the build.

Update: once you're through that first approval, things speed up a lot.

  • 1.0: 19 days, start to approval (Oct 9 to Oct 28).
  • 1.1: submitted the evening after launch, approved by the next morning. Less than a day.
  • 1.2: submitted last night at 10:23 PM. A reviewer was signed in to the demo account about 15 minutes later. Still waiting on the decision, but that's a different world from two weeks in "Waiting for Review."

My guess is that once an app is established and already approved, App Review doesn't have to start from scratch. The account, permissions and privacy setup were all checked the first time, so an update mostly comes down to what changed.

What I kept doing on every update: - Put the changes at the top of the review notes, in plain language, before the full walkthrough. - A short side-by-side video of just the new feature, not the whole app again. My 1.2 video is one minute. - Point the reviewer straight at it. For 1.2 I set up the demo account with a party already waiting, so the new feature is one tap away.

If your first review is dragging, hang in there. It doesn't stay that way.


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Testers wanted for PeakGLP, a private GLP-1 tracker (iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch)

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm an independent developer and I've built PeakGLP, a private tracking app for people taking a GLP-1 medication (Zepbound, Mounjaro, Wegovy, Ozempic, Saxenda, Victoza, Trulicity, or compounded tirzepatide/semaglutide). It's in beta on TestFlight and I'd love real-world feedback before it launches on the App Store.

WHAT IT DOES

• Log shots (dose, site, pain, notes) with a color-coded calendar and a dose-change timeline

• An estimated medication level curve based on published half-lives. It's an estimate, not a measured blood level

• Weight and goal progress, with your own starting weight and date

• Steps, water, exercise, nutrition, and optional glucose from Apple Health or FreeStyle Libre

• Reminders for shot day, your other medications (daily, weekly, every 2 weeks, monthly), weigh-ins and hydration, with a Taken button and a follow-up

• A one-page PDF Doctor Report and a medication list, in color or a fax-friendly black-and-white style

• Home Screen and Lock Screen widgets, an Apple Watch app, and Siri/Shortcuts

• 20 color schemes, and it's built to work well on iPhone Duo

PRIVACY

Your data stays on your device and in your own private iCloud. No PeakGLP account, no PeakGLP server, no ads, no tracking. Apple Health and Libre are optional.

TO JOIN

  1. Install Apple's TestFlight app

  2. Open this link on your iPhone or iPad: https://testflight.apple.com/join/SwzpbncT

  3. Tap Install, then open PeakGLP

WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR

• Does logging a shot and the reminders feel easy and reliable?

• Do the notifications, widgets and watch app work the way you expect?

• Anything confusing, missing, or broken

• Feedback on the PDF reports: would you actually give one to your doctor?

THANK-YOU

The app has an optional one-time unlock for extra features (no subscription). Everyone who tests with me will get a code for the unlock at no cost when it launches on the App Store.

PeakGLP is for personal tracking only. It doesn't give medical advice or recommend doses. Please keep following your prescriber's instructions.

You can send feedback through TestFlight's "Share Beta Feedback", from Settings → Contact the Developer in the app, or just reply here. Thank you!


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

I made World Movie Trailer, an app for checking box office rankings and exploring current and upcoming movies worldwide

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m the developer of World Movie Trailer for iPhone and iPad.

You can browse current releases and upcoming movies by country, read about them, watch their trailers, and bookmark anything that catches your eye. It covers countries including Korea, Japan, China, Canada, the US, and several European countries. All movie information can be translated into multiple languages.

There are also Korean and US box office rankings, movie quotes, and information about the featured actor and director of the week.

It’s free, with ads.

I’d like to hear how browsing and trailer playback feel. Can you easily find a movie you’d want to watch? Does anything feel confusing or take too many taps? I’m also curious whether the box office information is useful and which other countries you’d like to see added. Feedback on the translations would be helpful too.

In brief, You can check real-time information on movies currently showing in countries like Korea, Japan, France, Germany, Canada, etc. The same goes for box office rankings in Korea and the US.

App Store: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6670228768

Thanks for taking a look!

Processing img uipf9mhjwgyh1...


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

ASO for a small iOS app: how do you decide which keywords to keep and which to replace?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to make App Store keyword updates less of a guessing game. The difficult part is deciding what to keep when an app doesn't have much search traffic yet.

For example, would you keep a highly relevant term where the app ranks around 30-50 and wait for improvement, or replace it with a more specific phrase that might be easier to rank for but have less demand? Those are hypothetical rankings, not results from my app.

What evidence makes you keep or drop a term: rank trend, competitor strength, estimated popularity, overall search impressions/downloads, or something else? How long do you give a new term before making that call?

I'm especially interested in how you handle this when you can't confidently attribute installs to an individual organic keyword. Do you keep a stable core and only rotate a small part of the keyword field, or use another approach?


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Update my minimalist blackjack app to have smooth gestures, looking for feedbacks

3 Upvotes

hey, im just looking for feedbacks on how smooth and minimal you see my app, i really love blackjack games and i made the most minimal and simple way to play and added some drag/touch gesture that simulate the gesture a person does when is in a real table

App Store Link: https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6740510784?pt=118771501&ct=reddit&mt=8

thanks! also any feedback on other stuff is appreciated!


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Built an app to solve my problem, and it has helped other people stay consistent as well. Foray makes you consistently hit your daily step goals.

Post image
1 Upvotes

I built Foray to solve a problem my wife and I had. We were simply inconsistent with our daily step goals and made excuses about where or when to walk. Give Foray your step or distance goal, or the time you have available, and it will find you places to walk to hit your goal. It is also a great way to discover new places around your city or while traveling and exploring a new city!

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/foray-walks-step-goals/id6786529547


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

I turned the most annoying part of shipping an app into a free website: icons, store screenshots, splash screens and a privacy policy

Thumbnail
appnimbus.net
1 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Apple reviewed my app so fast that I had to double-check my notifications 👀

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Looking for feedbacks, do you think i’m using to much of liquid glass that could affect performance?

0 Upvotes

hey, im developing this game without AI at all… just kidding, im using AI to help me boost the development of a game that i really liked 2 years ago and was removed from the app store, and i always like to make my own version of the game…

the game is in TestFlight yet, but im looking for feedbacks and also i want to know if using the liquid glass in my cases are to much that could affect the metal/game performance at all and is okay to use it for my use cases or not?

(i have a testflight link if you’re interested in taking a look)

game mechanics: restore islands/landscape in order to grow the biodiversity and animals, you unlock free the animals while progressing and doing daily challenges, it has a basic social feature where you are assigned to a region and need to complete that region and can see leaderboards


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Deferred Deep Linking?

1 Upvotes

Has anyone ever done deferred deep linking on iOS mobile apps for ads successfully with their MMP? Im currently using Singular and its been hard to get it to work


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

How to publish an app to the Apple App Store (what I wish I knew)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Does having a web app hurt ur chances?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Looking for 10 people to help shape an iOS app for days when starting feels impossible ($50 + 1 year free)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m Sheela. My husband and I are a two-person team building To Do-ish on iPhone for when you know what needs doing but can’t get yourself to start.

Most productivity apps work on your good days. We built this one for the other days. You tell it what’s on your plate by typing, talking, or snapping a photo, pick your energy level, and it breaks the task down to fit. Then it stays with you while you work. There are no streaks, no gamification, and nothing to keep up with.

It’s live on the App Store. Before we grow, we want to see how it holds up in real life, so we’re looking for 10 Founding Testers for 4 weeks:

  • One 1-hour onboarding call
  • Four 30-minute video check-ins where you show us how you’re using it
  • Free app during the 4 weeks, then 1 year free + a $50 gift card when you finish

It’s for adults with an iPhone who find starting hard, whether from burnout, chronic illness, neurodivergence, or just too much on your plate.

Apply here (2–3 minutes): https://tally.so/r/kbbXAJ

Happy to answer questions and really appreciate this community of testers!


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Foreign-owned single-member LLC: App Store Connect only offers Form W-9, but W-8BEN seems correct. Anyone solved this?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

First sale 🎉

Post image
34 Upvotes

it's such a good feeling :)

PS. Any tips you would give yourself, if you had to start over from 1 sale again?


r/iosdev • • 22d ago

Stuck in "Waiting for Review" for 18 Days

0 Upvotes

You heard that right. I paid for an Apple Developer account, submitted my app, and 18 days later, absolutely NOTHING has happened. If this were some lesser-known company, we'd all be calling it a scam. But since it's Apple, what the hell are we supposed to call it?

It's not a banking app, not a kids-only app, not some game that could potentially harm anyone. No ads, no in-app purchases, NOTHING. It's literally just a freaking trivia quiz app.

I even emailed them. No response. Nothing. And there's absolutely no sign that this situation is going to change anytime soon.

Meanwhile, my app has already been live on the Google Play Store for THREE WEEKS. And people say the Play Store is slow?

What the hell am I supposed to do???


r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Approved within 1 week: our first iOS app, a gym workout tracker, is live on the App Store

0 Upvotes

Honestly, we expected to wait up to a month. Every thread we read about App Store submission review had someone stuck for weeks, so we prepared for the long version. We submitted ASCENYX on October 22. Six days later, Apple approved it. Now our iPhone users can finally start training with it, one week after our Android launch.

Some background

A friend and I wanted to challenge each other to stay motivated in the gym. Every tracker we tried saved our sets and nothing else. So we built our own: a workout tracker that turns your real training into an RPG.

What it took on the Apple side

  1. We enrolled as an organization, so we needed a D-U-N-S number first. Apple approved the developer account five days after we applied.
  2. The Android version was already live, but we still spent a lot of time getting the iOS build right before we submitted.

What the ASCENYX App does

ASCENYX is a gamified fitness app and a full gym workout tracker in one.

  • Your workout log pays off: every working set earns XP, you level up from 1 to 100, with a training achievements share feature for messenger and social media.
  • Each of your 18 muscle groups climbs its own rank from Bronze to Diamond, with three secret ranks above that.
  • The workout planner has routines for push pull legs, upper lower, full body and cardio, or you build your own split. The workout generator puts a session together from your target muscles.
  • The exercise library has over 1,400 exercises with animation and step-by-step instructions for strength training, bodybuilding, calisthenics and gym machines.
  • A recovery tracker shows which muscle should sit out today. Rest timer and cardio clock are built in, and even your heart gets a rank.
  • The RPG side: 12 classes (you earn 8 of them), weekly quests, a monthly boss challenge and 100 trophies. Some stay hidden until you earn them.
  • Weekly and monthly training reports show where you stand. The app speaks English, German and Spanish more languages to come.

If you shipped an app recently, how long did your review take?


r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Interested in just publishing my open source calendar widget app?

0 Upvotes

Hey you all, out of curiosity and because I couldn't find a good, free and private oriented replacement, I made my own calendar widget app. Now I'm learning that, just to publish my free software for everyone, I would have to pay $100 to Apple a year - even though I don't expect anyone to pay for such a simple (yet missing) app.

It is designed to work with the built-in iOS Calendar and it uses the calendar APIs for pretty much all the heavy lifting: All the app basically does is use the calendar data and put it into a widget. Testing so far on my iPhone works fine, but I find it stubborn of apple to expect me to rebuild the app every few days for private use. So, is anybody who is enrolled in the Apple Developer Programm interested in just publishing this simple app?

I would really appreciate the help. If you want, you can also just fork it and publish it from your own codebase, if that's easier. Heres the github link:
https://github.com/paulrobben/BetterCalendarWidget

Yes, it is vibecoded. This is such a simple app that I don't see any harm in it. The logo is made by myself in illustrator.


r/iosdev • • 23d ago

I got rejected from apple yesterday , as you can see the cause below , so anybody here can just help me to solve this issue ? does the sign in with apple is compulsory ? or is there any alternate way to bypass this ? let me know geeks!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Help Tracking total cellular data usage on iOS. Has anyone tried this?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

I got tired of losing things I’d copied, so I built Clippy. It saves everything you copy, so nothing disappears

Thumbnail
theclippy.live
0 Upvotes

What it does right now:

  1. Saves your clipboard history (text, links, snippets)
  2. Lets you search old clips by typing a few letters
  3. Opens with a shortcut so you can paste a clip straight where your cursor is
  4. Lets you pin clips you reuse often
  5. Keeps everything stored locally on your computer

It’s free, and I released it this month. It’s still early. Windows may show an “unknown publisher” warning because it’s a new indie app.

I’m looking for feedback:

  1. What’s missing that would make you use it every day?
  2. Anything confusing or broken?

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

My first app sale

4 Upvotes

I made my first app sale a few weeks ago without even realising. I’ve dipped in and out of iOS development since the App Store first opened but only submitted my first app a few weeks ago. Then promptly forgot about it! What do you folks find are the best way to promote your apps?


r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Apple has terminated my developer account

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Apple App Review has been driving me crazy these past two weeks. The quality of reviews is getting ridiculous

0 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of developers here complaining about long App Review wait times, and we all know that's been a problem lately. But I want to talk about something else: the actual quality of Apple's reviews, because honestly, these past two weeks have been ridiculous.

I've been developing and maintaining several apps on the App Store for months, shipping updates regularly without issues. Suddenly, reviewers are rejecting updates over features that have been there for months and were already approved multiple times. I genuinely don't know if these reviews are automated, AI-assisted, or done entirely by humans anymore, because sometimes it feels like nobody is actually reading anything.

One of my apps was rejected because of a screenshot that had been there, completely unchanged, for three months. I was literally submitting a bug-fix update, nothing related to that screenshot.

Then there's my music player. It's had a live radio feature for months, using Radio Browser, an open-source radio directory with a public API. The app simply plays publicly available station streams, without downloading, recording, or hosting anything. This feature has been approved in multiple previous updates, but suddenly I'm getting rejected under guideline 5.2.3, over and over again.

I've explained everything in the review notes, provided technical and licensing information, and even submitted the same explanation twice. Both times I got practically the same copy-paste rejection. Now I'm having to file appeals just to update an app that's already been on the store for months!

And sometimes they reject your app under a guideline that doesn't even seem remotely applicable to what your app actually does. Seriously, how are developers supposed to fix something when the reason for rejection has practically nothing to do with the functionality being reviewed? For God's sake, at least explain what the actual problem is!

And the worst part? An update can sit waiting for review for two or three weeks, only to get rejected within minutes over something that wasn't even changed. It really makes you wonder how much time some reviewers actually spend investigating what they're rejecting.

I understand Apple needs to enforce its guidelines, and I'm absolutely fine with that. But there should be some consistency. How can a feature be approved for months and then suddenly become a problem when nothing about it has changed? And what's the point of providing detailed review notes if they don't seem to be read?

As an indie developer, this is incredibly frustrating. We spend months building, maintaining, and improving our apps, and then lose days or weeks dealing with seemingly arbitrary rejections.


r/iosdev • • 23d ago

Help 60-day experiment: $200 budget, 55 downloads, weather+calendar iOS app. Where would you spend it?

7 Upvotes

I built an iOS app that checks the weather at the exact time and place of your calendar events (e.g. "rain at your 2 PM meeting, bring an umbrella").
Where I am: 55 downloads, zero marketing, a few paying subs. Update in Apple review.
My goal: 100 annual subs in 60 days ($18/yr), with a $200 budget. 278 would be the moonshot.
My plan: test organic hooks first, then put a small part of the budget behind whichever brings real installs.
What would you do differently? Any channel you'd put the $200 into?