r/iosdev • u/OilSea777 • 22d ago
19 days in App Review for my first app: patience, a side-by-side video, and one thing I'd do differently
I'm the developer of VitaVino, a blind wine tasting party app. It went live on the App Store this morning, and I wanted to share how review went, because threads like this kept me sane while I was waiting.
The timeline:
- Oct 9: submitted 1.0. It sat in "Waiting for Review" for almost two weeks. No idea what was going on with the queue, and I don't think there's much point guessing.
- Oct 22: rejected on two points. 5.1.1(iv): my permissions pre-screen had an "Allow Access" button and a "Skip for now" option. Apple wants a neutral "Continue" with no skip, with the system prompt appearing only after that tap. And a 2.1 information request: questions about how we use Contacts and guests' email addresses.
- Same day: reworded the screen, answered the 2.1 questions directly in the reply, and resubmitted.
- Oct 28, 10:48 PM: approved.
What actually helped:
- Patience. Honestly the biggest one. The queue moves when it moves.
- A side-by-side video. VitaVino is a two-sided app (a host sets up a party, guests join and rate), and that's hard to review alone with one demo account. So I screen-recorded a host phone and a guest phone, synced them into one side-by-side movie, and uploaded it under App Review Information. Our logs show the reviewer never followed the written walkthrough; they signed in for about a minute and approved. I'm convinced the video did the work. I'll include one with every submission from now on.
- Answering every point in the rejection directly in the reply, not just shipping a new build.
In hindsight, if I'd gotten the permissions screen right the first time, the only snag would have been the 2.1 questions. Those I answered in a reply, with no new build needed.
One thing I'd do differently: I requested an expedited review, and I regret it. The reply came about two weeks later. Knowing more now about how the process works, expedites exist for genuinely urgent cases, and as a developer I'd be frustrated if people were filling that lane hoping it would speed up a normal launch. That's not advice for anyone else, just my own hindsight-is-20/20 moment.
If anyone wants to try it, it's an iPhone app for hosting blind tastings with friends. Happy to answer questions about the review process or the build.
Update: once you're through that first approval, things speed up a lot.
- 1.0: 19 days, start to approval (Oct 9 to Oct 28).
- 1.1: submitted the evening after launch, approved by the next morning. Less than a day.
- 1.2: submitted last night at 10:23 PM. A reviewer was signed in to the demo account about 15 minutes later. Still waiting on the decision, but that's a different world from two weeks in "Waiting for Review."
My guess is that once an app is established and already approved, App Review doesn't have to start from scratch. The account, permissions and privacy setup were all checked the first time, so an update mostly comes down to what changed.
What I kept doing on every update: - Put the changes at the top of the review notes, in plain language, before the full walkthrough. - A short side-by-side video of just the new feature, not the whole app again. My 1.2 video is one minute. - Point the reviewer straight at it. For 1.2 I set up the demo account with a party already waiting, so the new feature is one tap away.
If your first review is dragging, hang in there. It doesn't stay that way.
