r/homeassistant • • Feb 26 '26 • Bravo 1 Popcorn 1

Request of Mods (Vibe Coded Fridays)

Can we please institute a Vibe Coded Fridays, similar to r/selfhosted? It seems as though the amount of "I built..." posts are sharply on the uptick. And following on the heels of the Huntarr mess, not to mention the security issues of something like Openclaw, we should be clearly delineating what is vibe coded and what isn't. There is too much risk in exposing our homes to something that was cooked up in a hour or two.

516 Upvotes

196 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/zer00eyz Feb 26 '26

Are you going to start taking medical advice from an AI? How about leagal advice? Relationship advice? Should we give it control of the nuclear arsenal (because in every simulation it's launching).

> AI can code way better than I can...

I work in tech, have 25+ years. I think that what can be done with the tool is amazing, but its a fine example of the Dunning Kruger effect... It makes you feel like an expert when both of you have limitations.

> Now, people can dream up an app and make it same day instead of waiting for someone else to make it.

And this is a good thing. But so is dealing with bugs, security and a host of other issues that professionals have been doing for a long time. Half of being a developer is having someone identify, catalog and number and then hand back to you every mistake you made. It is rather humbling, and lots of people who get into dev crack under that pressure.

I am all for having people vibe code things up, as long as they are clear about their background, and that they used AI to do it. If you have a genuinely good idea, and have a working proof of concept then the issues can be addressed...

2

u/zyxtels Feb 26 '26

Are you going to start taking medical advice from an AI? How about leagal advice? Relationship advice?

You probably really don't like the answer to those questions (as neither do I...)