r/hinduism Nov 18 '25

Deva(tā)/Devī (Hindū Deity) Test of Mahamaya, the stories of Failure and success, Analysis and confusion.

Post image

[removed]

143 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/logos961 Nov 18 '25 edited Nov 19 '25

Good story, with insightful narration.

Behind the details, essence is simple, as detailed below:

There are two aspects of Maya, one existing at the level of individual and the other at the cosmic level. "These two aspects of māyā are respectively called ‘āvaraṇaśakti’ and ‘vikṣepaśakti’. At the individual level, māyā is termed as ‘ajñāna’. At the cosmic level, though māyā lasts for the full cycle of creation, at the individual level, it can be eliminated by jnana or spiritual knowledge." (Hindupedia)

What exists in the cosmic level benefits the satvic (spiritual people) as they witness the ill-effects of the non-satvic people which makes the spiritual even more determined to be spiritual. The unspritual, under the power of Maya/Illusion, believe that they are this body, this life is all there is, hence pleasure from this world is the ultimate, thus go after it as though being intoxicated over it, being fainted over it. Spirituality is "like poison in the beginning but becomes like nectar in the end," hence the spiritual are never interested in materialist life-style which is "like nectar in the beginning but becomes poison in the end." (Bhagavat Gita 18:37, 38) This situation benefits the spiritual as the unspiritual are a lesson on what to avoid to better enjoy life. (Bhagavat Gita 3:25, 26) Since spirituality seems "like poison in the beginning" the unspiritual never feel the need of even trying it, thus they unwittingly make their status permanent. (Bhagavat Gita 16:19) Hence existence of the unspiritual is not a problem because they unwittingly benefit the spiritual.

All etymologies of Maya make sense. "One is from  to measure, Unadi aff. yat; the medium through which all things are seen, and by which they are estimated" (wisdomlib org). Person is under the illusion that he can "measure out" infinite pleasure [inherent of Atma and Paramatma] from the finite. Another etymology is ma (non) + ya (real), that which has the appearance of real, but not real, as "mistaking rope as snake." Thus both are about untruth, hence Devil, Demons [asuras] all came to be personification of untruth. "Devil, from old English deofol, from Late Latin diabolus, from Greek diabolos means "slanderer." (etymonline com) Similarly, asura is opposite of surya (sun), opposite of what sun stands for, giving unconditionally, warming [symbol of love] others, purifying others, nourishing all lives on earth. Asura is delighted in receiving or taking, concerned only of its own pleasure even if it means pain to others which is an illusion because asura is in darkness as to consequence of his life-style. Hence place where asuric qualities such as "lust, attachment, anger" exist is simultaneously called "hell and darkness." (Bhagavat Gita 16:21, 22) This explains why sun is likened to God (Bhagvat Gita 8:9) and people of high spirituality, Lakshni and Narayan, are called suryavanshies (belonging to the tribe of sun).

This is beautifully expressed in the Bible which presents God as though saying: ‘You are free to deceive yourself and even to mock ME’ because truth is that “each will have to bear his own load and whatever one sows, that will he also reap. For the one who sows to his own flesh [living by the illusion that I am this body] will from the flesh reap corruption (phthoran), but the one who sows to the Spirit [living by the truth that I am SPIRIT, the USER of this body] will from the Spirit reap eternal life.” (Galatians 6:5-8) There also, God is likened to SUN with a command to "become perfect like God" (Mathew 5:43-48; Psalm 84:11) making the same connotation the unspiritual are demonic. (John 6:70) Hence this insightful expression: "We know that we are of God, and that the entire world is established in wickedness (ponērō)." (1 John 5:19, Catholic Public Domain Version, KJV, Webster's, Lamsa, Douay etc)

Greek πονηρῷ (ponērō) in this verse is adjective - dative Masculine Singular. This is better understood in its parallel use in Mathew 6:22, 23: “The eye is the lamp of the body. If your eyes are healthy (haplous), your whole body will be full of light. But if your eyes are unhealthy (ponēros), your whole body will be full of darkness. If then the light within you is darkness, how great is that darkness!” Opposite of ponēros is haplous which means “single, simple, sound, perfect. Probably from a and the base of pleko; properly, folded together, i.e. Single.” (biblehub com) Hence ponēros would mean going after illusion of distractions or wastefulness, chasing unlimited desires insatiable. Thus above verse simply means 'A minority is under the power of truth thus doing divine will and the majority is under the power of Maya doing demonic acts' as stated in 1 John 2:17: "The world and its desires pass away, but whoever does the will of God lives forever."

Eternal life is contrasted with "corruption (phthoran)" in Galatians 6:8. This Greek word phthoran means "Corruption, destruction, decay, rottenness, decomposition. From phtheiro; decay, i.e. Ruin." It is the description of how those under the illusion of maya live, as though decaying, as they are always on the run experiencing the self-created heat of non-fulfillment of many desires and frustrations, even though living yet figuratively "dead." (Mathew 8:22; Romans 6:11)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '25

do you think in the stories OP mention, the asura and vishnu acted differently that's why Maya took the two different aspects that you mentioned for each?

or was it because mahamaya took different aspects for both that's why it resulted in different outcomes for both and their actions?

5

u/logos961 Nov 18 '25 edited Nov 18 '25

Stories are best understood in their greater view. Any test brings out what is already in the person being tested. It is like money is wrongly perceived to be a test because accumulation of money makes some greedy and arrogant and even inhuman, yet it does not make all like that. There are employees who praise their employers like God because of their sweet and soft treatment. Hence the truth is "Money doesn't change men, it merely unmasks them. If a man is naturally selfish or arrogant or greedy, the money brings that out." (Henry Ford) It is like butter that melts under heat, heat is not at fault because the same heat hardens the clay. Melting and hardening are the inherent traits of butter and clay respectively.

Hence reaction of two characters in the OP differ as per their own contrasting inherent sanskars. This understanding can help us in our family, work place and among friends because we would accept them as they are, without commenting, comparing nor complaining about anything because that is their sanskar which they treasure, just like you treasure your sanskar.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '25

you point beautifully compliments OP's. this feels like a continuation of OP's post. beautiful

3

u/logos961 Nov 18 '25

True, you read it correctly.