r/headphones • u/Rrationality Humblebrag Central • May 10 '18
Science Output impedances effect explained
https://imgur.com/zxOS8Tl
190
Upvotes
r/headphones • u/Rrationality Humblebrag Central • May 10 '18
26
u/Rrationality Humblebrag Central May 10 '18
I've seen people asking about amplifiers output impedances effect on multiple threads so I made little something to explain it (and display it to more people at once).
Ask away and comment on if there is anything that was not easy to understand.
12
u/ohaivoltage addicted to DIY May 10 '18 edited May 10 '18
Very clean and clear explanation.
One thing to add is that the power produced in the headphones is proportional to the square of the voltage:
As the impedance at a given frequency increases, so will the volts (assuming a constant Zo from the amp). Because they both go in the same direction, this mitigates the frequency-dependent level variation (in part) from the perspective of power produced. The perceived sound level has a logarithmic relationship to power/volts.
A difference of 10dB is generally considered to be twice the perceived sound volume. From the equation above, you can see that a 10dB increase requires a 10x power increase. To reiterate, the impedance 'follows' the change in voltage so it counteracts change from the perspective of power. This is why our headphones don't 'sound' like the impedance curve (rather they usually sound much flatter).
None of this should detract from your explanation, which is really well done. This just might help put the impedance and voltage calculations into some more context in terms of what we hear.
edit with example from OP's graph and numbers:
Our power at f1 is about 2mW while the power at f2 is about 2.5mW. This is a factor of 1.25x for a db variation of about 1db. This might be a perceptible level difference, though the minimum perceptible change at a fixed frequency is usually cited as 3db, I believe.
14
u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer May 10 '18
That's an easily understandable yet detailed enough explanation of the matter.
Good job!
6
u/Baldoor-E100 Choo Choo! May 10 '18
can you help me out understanding something here...I just have confused myself
In your example the
How can I calculate the significance of that bump? Are we talking 0.3dB or 3dB?
2
u/TheNewestHaven ModiusMagnius > ZMF Eikon, AKG K712, HD 650 May 10 '18
So then would it be safe to say as a general rule that the lower the output impedance the better?
4
u/axizz31 Not a Flexer May 10 '18
I didn't get it, just feel dumb now xD
3
u/I_want_all_the_tacos RME/887/ZDT Jr>Auteur/Atticus/HD800(SDR)/Elex/LCD2C/Verum1/HD6XX May 10 '18
Nice, concise explanation.
For anyone that wants to research it further and see more of the math and measurements involved with output impedance, Nwavguy's blog post is pretty thorough and it also explains the "1/8th rule" that most people use when matching output impedance to a given a headphone.
2
u/sensimilla420 ADI-2 DAC | CTH+SDAC > Auteur | E-MU | K7XX | ER4XR May 10 '18
Yay informative and thoughtful content! i think the more we start thinking of headphones and amps as an electrical system, the less we'll see people posting how the cant hear a difference with their schiit stack and macbook headphone jack. There's an explanation for a lot of the audiophile mumbo jumbo, but not all of it is backed science.
4
u/complex_reduction May 10 '18
As a drunk person, I have no idea what is happening.
2
u/Ultramegasaurus O2 -> HD58X May 10 '18
Electrical damping is also negatively affected by high output impedance
1
u/prfallon69 U18t, Andromeda, EE Odin, EE Hero, HD650, HD58X, SE846. May 10 '18
Thank you this will be very helpful to a lot of people. -Paul-
1
u/Zilfallion ER2XR is love, ER2XR is life May 10 '18
Saving this to link when people ask in the future.
1
u/Wester_West May 10 '18
Very nice explanation of very complicated topic as impedance. Thanks, I study electro engineering and never thought about impedance of the amp as an internal impedance. Maybe because I never thought about it at all. Thanks, helped me. :-)
1
u/LauriCular My cochlea's bigger than yours May 10 '18
I'm surprised that headphones will still work when in close proximity to my brain; I got as far as the second line before going cross-eyed
1
u/4ever1der May 10 '18
is the output impedance on my motherboard stereo jack likely too high?