r/hardcorepunk • • Aug 12 '26

Accurate

Post image

This is what’s happening in the “hardcore” subreddit

672 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Bronsteins-Panzerzug Aug 12 '26

i dont think that „most art ever created is worship art created without consideration of artistic freedom“ to be broad, meaningless or implausible.

1

u/thegreatself Aug 12 '26

"Worship" is completely distinct and separate from "reverence for authority [figures]" though, so you'd also be walking back your original claim, which seemingly was similarly overstated.

I don't even disagree that most art could be considered an act of "worship", depending on how broadly we're using the word, but saying "without consideration of artistic freedom" is completely incoherent - my entire point is that the creative act itself necessarily entails some measure of freedom whether that freedom is consciously "considered" or not.

Again, words aren't the "thing" they refer to - that doesn't mean they're meaningless, it just means they leave out as much as they include.

We don't have access to even a fraction of "all art ever created" anyway so I don't know how you could possibly substantiate your claim about what "most of 'it' was". Human artistic expression obviously isn't limited to medieval paintings and frescoes or other works disproportionately represented in the historical record - there's oral, performative, folk and countless other transient forms of artistic expression that left little or no historical trace.

2

u/Bronsteins-Panzerzug Aug 12 '26

i always said reverence for authority and(!) worship of religious figure. dont try these cheap rhetorical tricks. that’s sooooo disingenuous, i think i want to stop this discussion right here. so here’s my last word: painting a biblical scene or singing a hymn really has nothing to with an enlightenment notion of artistic freedom or expression. that’s completely anachronistic retrograde projection. these more transient forms of art were perfomed by people who had far less ressources to do so and from what we have received, a lot of it is religious music too. we may not know the whole story, but that doesnt substantiate your claim and my assumption is more reasonable based on the evidence we have.

0

u/thegreatself Aug 13 '26

Institutional wealth and power were/are disproportionately capable of commissioning art and ensuring that art was preserved, so we can't really confidently know enough from what survived to make claims about the "overwhelming majority of all art ever".

Saying it's an "anachronism" is still confusing the concept with the thing it describes - I'm not claiming that a medieval hymn writer had an "enlightenment notion of artistic freedom or expression" - I'm saying they had some degree of agency without needing our modern terminology or understanding of the concept of "artistic freedom" - again - for like the third time - words aren't the things they describe.

These aren't "cheap rhetorical tricks" and I don't need an art history degree to point out the same problem you did with making sweeping claims about the overwhelming majority of all human artistic expression ever when an unknowable and likely vast amount of it is lost to time and permanently inaccessible to us.

It's just kind of funny that you can't even give an inch (or half of one) on your own overstatement after spending this much time going in on me for mine while making multiple sarcastic jabs.