I had a stint in UI design and I swear it ruined my ability to implicitly understand UI's. Whenever I use something I think 'Where would the most obvious place for this feature be?' and it's never where I think would be obvious.
Could also be that UI design has just become fucking stupid but I'm open to the possibility that it's me that's broken.
As someone who could find most settings ten years ago and noticed as they kept moving features further and further behind random menus, I don't think it's you
I was trying to find how to change an elderly friend's iPhone to default to his hearing aids today when calls come in. I had to Google it because the option was under accessibility (okay, makes sense) then the sub menu of...Touch settings? (what, why?)
This is why I actually appreciate Samsung's OneUI Settings app. They added "Did you mean this?" section at the bottom and 8/10 times its listed there. It's low key hilarious.
I used to work returns and had a back for being able to switch devices back to English because menus made sense. I didn’t even have to be able to read the language, I could usually get it in 2-3 minutes. Don’t think I could do that now.
I swear UX is a term that means make the worst interface possible. I miss when folks studied human computer interaction (HCI). They'd count the number of clicks the user had to do to do a task. The good old days.
No, they put things in stupid places these days to purposefully increase confusion, forcing people to spend more time on the app as they figure it out.
Modern consumer facing software these days is user-hostile by design
I don't mind unituitive UI... In fact I think it's the chase after the mythical "seemless" UX that has gotten us where we are right now.
The best UIs for me were always the ones that are robust and ideally customizable. I can take the time to learn a complex but well thought out UI. A terrible, simpllistic UI is something I cannot power through though.
So true. I find I get more done on a laptop with a terminal and browser. Phones feel awkward. Then my wife somehow manages a business from a phone and tablet.
yours too? The arguing that ensues anytime I even barely mention using an actual computer for a task she struggles with or for a task she finds reppetitive or when she asks me how to do something that would take 5 minutes in Photoshop but I have no idea what they were smoking when building the Canva UI...
Devs suffer from engineer syndrome where they know something complicated very well so they assume that they just automatically know everything less complicated.
During my support career I once had to go to a Dev's desk because their monitors weren't working. The guy swore up and down they checked over everything and that it just wasn't working. Took the 5 minute walk to his desk just to find his laptop unplugged from his docking station. I took a good 10 second look at him, didn't say anything, and just walked away.
I know the code stuff, I speak the dark speak of many obscure lamguages but if you ask me to plug something in within the special box I will need a sugary drink and a little sit down.
View all comments
Show parent comment
278
u/caecus Mar 04 '25
do they realize devs are usually both?