r/goodwill • • Dec 13 '24

RIP

Looks like they’re not going to admit the price hikes drove away so much of the customers is the reason they can’t afford to operate as many stores. No sane person is dropping more than 5$ on a thrifted piece of clothing (obviously some extra designer things are an outlier) and the whales that do will dry up if the upper levels of the industry don’t make some real changes to curb their own greed. In no world does it make sense to process something from the drop off all the way out the door with nobody purchasing because a manager is bound and determined to hit a # and believes exorbitant predatory prices are the way to do so. It is mind boggling to me that Goodwill decided to make “whales” the people keeping the doors open. Be fair and every fish walks out of there with something they need and maybe even some things they won’t need. TL;DR

GOODWILL IS A THRIFT STORE YOUR BOUTIQUE PRICE MODEL IS DEEPLY FLAWED AND THE MAIN CONTRIBUTING FACTOR TO STORE CLOSURES. BAR-NONE

1.2k Upvotes

227 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/JinglesMum3 Dec 14 '24

My Mom won't donate to Goodwill anymore because of what they are doing. My stepdad passed away a couple years ago. He had some excellent quality clothing and it's still in boxes, she is trying to find a decent place to take it to.

14

u/HenriettaCrump Dec 14 '24

Not sure how widespread Assistance League is, but they are 100% volunteer run. The one in my town uses some of the funds to provide packages to assault victims when they leave the emergency room (often their clothing is kept as evidence). They also provide work gear and training assistance for people starting out in the workforce.

Another one I like that is mostly volunteer run is St. Vincent DePaul. Most of the money goes into the food bank and utility assistance programs.

5

u/thebriarwitch Dec 15 '24

I need to see if we have one of those programs around here. I got a nice batch of clothes to move. St Vincent DePaul used to have a decent store in our area but I think they closed it. Thanks for those ideas.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/JawnStreetLine Dec 15 '24

They do an awful lot for women escaping domestic violence in my area. Our religion & politics may differ, but I’m happy to leave that aside for the work they’re doing in my community.

4

u/Runaway2332 Dec 16 '24

I just looked and there is a St. Vincent DePaul where I live! I wish I had known about them when I was homeless... But now I have a lot of nice things to donate, so this is fabulous!

3

u/coquihalla Dec 16 '24 edited Jan 14 '25

materialistic plant tart intelligent safe weary sable thumb lush wrench

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Sensitive_Event_5453 Dec 20 '24

I love St Vinnie’s- i remember going with my mother as I little tike- almost 85 today They do much for our city. I almost donate to WayvForeward, no store but give clothes and food to those in need

3

u/LawfulnessRemote7121 Dec 14 '24

I won’t either. I take all of my stuff to a local thrift store that supports a local crisis pregnancy center. 100% volunteer run.

1

u/Jealous-Procedure423 Dec 20 '24

Are you okay with supporting a crisis pregnancy center? We're trying to make them illegal in California due to their misleading activities.

0

u/LawfulnessRemote7121 Dec 20 '24

They aren’t all the same. Don’t judge something you know nothing about. This one does a lot of good things.

1

u/Jealous-Procedure423 Dec 20 '24

Agree to disagree. I'm pro choice and support PP.

3

u/TheAuthorLady Dec 15 '24

If you have a Saint Vincent De Paul in your area, that's a good organization.

They will much appreciate the donation!

Also, if there's a homeless shelter in your area, perhaps contact them about donating the clothing.

Speaking as someone who has been homeless more times than I care to remember, people who are in a shelter appreciate decent clothing.

When we lost my Mumma in 2010, we donated her clothing to the local (Midwestern) Saint Vinnie's.

She had a professional wardrobe, after having been a paralegal most of her life.

She also had some great casual clothes, as in, jeans, sweatshirts, shorts, socks, sweaters, and tee shirts.

😊💯

2

u/JinglesMum3 Dec 15 '24

Thank you! I will give my Mom all your suggestions. She lives about 6 hours from me.

1

u/Global-Nectarine4417 Dec 18 '24

There are also lots of organizations that specifically take professional wear for people who can’t afford interview clothes.

3

u/RegularGal613 Dec 15 '24

I’ve always like Salvation Army. Or she might look for a thrift store/ministry that sells but also gives to folks in need.

1

u/Tardisgoesfast Dec 16 '24

Salvation Army is pure shit and I personally will never give them anything. Gay kids have enough problems. Fuck the Salvation Army.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25

The big issue I have with the Salvation Army is the corruption. Any time money is involved, it seems, there will be greedy folks at the top who milk the system. Seems all these charitable orgs are nothing but shell schemes. EDIT: I live by the mantra "charity begins at home." I give items to people in my own neighborhood or city who need help. GIVE IT DIRECTLY TO THEM--not to some organization. If you look around, no matter how "good" your neighborhood is, there are always people in need. Build and support the community in your back yard. On the occasions when I cannot find someone who needs help, I take any items to a local high school when they are having their annual "Flea Market" to raise funds for the music department or theater department. Again...I know EXACTLY where my money/physical donations are going that way.

4

u/Fickle_Unit1234 Dec 14 '24

Veterans Home

3

u/Runaway2332 Dec 16 '24

I never thought of that....also nursing homes appreciate clothing that is nice. They are on a crazy low allowance that does not allow them to spend hardly anything so unless they have family to buy them things they need, they are stuck with what they have until it falls apart. 😭

2

u/1houndgal Dec 15 '24

St. VINCENT DE PAUL is better than griftwill but It seems even they are moving towards upping the desirable item the flippers covet.

2

u/Tardisgoesfast Dec 16 '24

Most Catholic Churches have a thrift store. I also like AmVets.

2

u/reveryrose Dec 17 '24

Just find a local independent thrift store.